Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[FlaviusAetius]

I have no idea how to interpret that entire message.

Is it a scum slip? Is he deliberately pretending he doesn't know who killed who as if it isn't completely obvious?

Is it a town slip? Does he not know the difference between the assassin and the BA?

I LITERALLY went back to the bot and saw who killed who, what are you talking about

How does the bot tell you who killed who?

Dead or replaced players
TrPrado died EoN2 - HE WAS Dick Gumshoe, THE TOWN COP.
Tom Bombadil died EoN2 - He was ??? of ???.
EspressoPatronum died EoD2 - HE WAS THE WEAK OLD MAN, THE VANILLA TOWNIE!
MoscowFleet was replaced Day 2 by peterlund
CruaaderReynauld died Day 2 - He was a random spectator, the VANILLA TOWN.
dargorygel died Day 2 - He was Mike Meekins, the TOWN BAILIFF.
Carl Tuckerson died Day 2 - He was Ema Skye, the VANILLA TOWN.
bozotheclown died EoD1 - He was CROAD McLAUGHLIN, a Vanilla Town!

Right bloody there it tells you

[rdrivera2005]

You're not convincing me right now Balki...

Welp, I don’t think I can win anyway.

Do you want me to reveal my power role scan? Pretty sure it’s on a Townie.

dont do it

Not sure if this is such a bad idea. Our PRs aren't great and being sure Balki is BA is important. Let's consider this before discarding.

[Durga]

I LITERALLY went back to the bot and saw who killed who, what are you talking about

How does the bot tell you who killed who?

Dead or replaced players
TrPrado died EoN2 - HE WAS Dick Gumshoe, THE TOWN COP.
Tom Bombadil died EoN2 - He was ??? of ???.
EspressoPatronum died EoD2 - HE WAS THE WEAK OLD MAN, THE VANILLA TOWNIE!
MoscowFleet was replaced Day 2 by peterlund
CruaaderReynauld died Day 2 - He was a random spectator, the VANILLA TOWN.
dargorygel died Day 2 - He was Mike Meekins, the TOWN BAILIFF.
Carl Tuckerson died Day 2 - He was Ema Skye, the VANILLA TOWN.
bozotheclown died EoD1 - He was CROAD McLAUGHLIN, a Vanilla Town!

Right bloody there it tells you

I don't think you understand or you're purposely playing stupid.

Do you know what the blind assassin is?

[ChippeRock]

Well, I don't recall TrPrado receiving a vote - so why did you even ask for a vote count if you weren't going to follow it?

You're not convincing me right now Balki...

Welp, I don’t think I can win anyway.

Do you want me to reveal my power role scan? Pretty sure it’s on a Townie.

Preferably don't do that. But please explain why you ignored your own damn "vote" count for the BA NK? I think TrPrado didn't receive any votes? If he did, it was only 1.

[Durga]

Welp, I don’t think I can win anyway.

Do you want me to reveal my power role scan? Pretty sure it’s on a Townie.

dont do it

Not sure if this is such a bad idea. Our PRs aren't great and being sure Balki is BA is important. Let's consider this before discarding.

while it could confirm that he is BA, the mere fact that he suggested it, in my mind, probably confirms that he's BA.

no reason to out our lovely judge or innocent whatever. i assume balki has decent reads

[Nephthys]

Welp, I don’t think I can win anyway.

Do you want me to reveal my power role scan? Pretty sure it’s on a Townie.

dont do it

Not sure if this is such a bad idea. Our PRs aren't great and being sure Balki is BA is important. Let's consider this before discarding.

I back this. Confirming is important here. We can't afford to fuck up and it's always gonna be rdr that does tonight

[et]

Scum will roleblocke Balki and Kill rdr Night3.
If we can lynch maffia today, that is best.
But we may lynch town.
Lynch Balki is safety option?
I don't have conclusion now.

[Durga]

aghhhhhhhhhhhhhh

i don't know

reveal it then i don't care!

[Balki Bartokomous]

I think that if I were lying, the real Slim Shady would kill me tonight. So lynching me would be a very silly thing to do.

If you like, I can reveal my power role scan at the last moment before tomorrow night ends. That gets this person through one more Night. Though, I suspect it doesn’t matter because rdrivera is the likely NK tonight.

[ChippeRock]

dont do it

Not sure if this is such a bad idea. Our PRs aren't great and being sure Balki is BA is important. Let's consider this before discarding.

while it could confirm that he is BA, the mere fact that he suggested it, in my mind, probably confirms that he's BA.

no reason to out our lovely judge or innocent whatever. i assume balki has decent reads

No, that was the obvious answer. Even I thought about it (that's what my "theory" was).

[FlaviusAetius]

Wait, if the assassin is lynched d1 but they already triggered the bomb, does the bomb still go off with them dead?

I assume so. Flav killed darg because of car bomb? Flav mafia would explain D1 nicely.

Perhaps, but the massive vote swap of 4 (which I, Carl, connor & Flav were a part of) to lynch bozo contained at least 1 town - since Carl was revealed as town.

Tom flipped as well, he said he was convinced of TrPrado, but now he was going to vote bozo with the rest of us

[Durga]

given you have to be rb'd if you're BA and rdr has to be night killed, i actually don't see the harm in revealing anymore.

[ChippeRock]

##CALL GM Can the Blind Assassin be roleblocked by the Mafia's Hooker?

[Durga]

##CALL GM Can the Blind Assassin be roleblocked by the Mafia's Hooker?

read the set up PELASE

[FlaviusAetius]

How does the bot tell you who killed who?

Dead or replaced players
TrPrado died EoN2 - HE WAS Dick Gumshoe, THE TOWN COP.
Tom Bombadil died EoN2 - He was ??? of ???.
EspressoPatronum died EoD2 - HE WAS THE WEAK OLD MAN, THE VANILLA TOWNIE!
MoscowFleet was replaced Day 2 by peterlund
CruaaderReynauld died Day 2 - He was a random spectator, the VANILLA TOWN.
dargorygel died Day 2 - He was Mike Meekins, the TOWN BAILIFF.
Carl Tuckerson died Day 2 - He was Ema Skye, the VANILLA TOWN.
bozotheclown died EoD1 - He was CROAD McLAUGHLIN, a Vanilla Town!

Right bloody there it tells you

I don't think you understand or you're purposely playing stupid.

Do you know what the blind assassin is?

What do you mean I don't understand? And of course, I do the Blind Assasin gets to kill anyone

[ChippeRock]

##CALL GM Can the Blind Assassin be roleblocked by the Mafia's Hooker?

read the set up PELASE

I did. I can't imagine a serial killer getting bribed...

[Durga]

##CALL GM Can the Blind Assassin be roleblocked by the Mafia's Hooker?

read the set up PELASE

I did. I can't imagine a serial killer getting bribed...

clearly you haven't seen american psycho. moving on

[FlaviusAetius]

THINK ABOUT THIS

If Balki wasn't BA then the BA would not claim right now because we all have our votes on him, think, please

[Durga]

There's only one town PR after the innocent child and the judge, and it's a pretty useless reporter.

Besides, scum haven't been aiming for PR, they're aiming for people who won't get mislynched. Pretty sure Tom is VT.

We're probably losing this game because this BA is so anti-town, agh.

I was looking at the bot, and I am reading from where I left off,
I also read a bit of Tom's stuff

The BA so far has been quite self-preserving, probably killing people he thought suspected him
So Balki killing Tom makes some sense but not much, he only made some comments about Balki in the beginning of the Night, Im not so sure Balki would kill Tom for that

When it comes to Carl and Darg I also looked about at them
Carl never even suspected Balki except for one moment in Night one, makes no sense that Balki killed him
So then I looked at darg
Darg >DEFENDED< Balki Night one

If the BA has been self-preserving, then there is no way its Balki

ok flav.

we've already establish, supported by GM FLAVOUR, that darg was killed by the MAFIA assassin, not the BLIND assassin.

you're right about Balki NOT killing Tom. Because Balki killed TRPRADO and MAFIA Killed Tom

What does the last sentence about the BA being self-preserving mean? I don't understand it.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I’m taking Mrs. Balki our to dinner. If you guys want me to reveal my power role scan before the lynch today, I will. But probably better to get more views on it.

Likely the optimal play is for me to reveal right before EON3.

If I live, I’ll obviously keep trying to keep Town alive, as that is the only way to keep my minuscule win condition chances alive. Also, BA killing Cop is the worst kind of luck. That’s the last player I wanted to kill (I scan innocent).