Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

ooohh shiiiiet you caught me i'm the BA. let's make a deal. who you want dead tomorrow?

Nice! Maybe kill Foxy Knoxy if he survives the lynch? But I may update you later.

Cool! There's no reason why we can't work as a team. We're after the same thing at the moment.

i'm low key offended u think i'm dumb enough to claim jailed if i had my kill blocked :'(

[Balki Bartokomous]

for the record,

no way xorx as BA claims roleblocked esp if it meant his kill didn't go through.

and i obv don't claim jailed either with the jailer dead.

I was thinking about that.

Let's see...

Xorx might still claim RB, as he would be trying to hide his identity from Mafia? Mafia would have already known he was RBed.

The jailed thing...you might be right about that. I can't think of any way it would later become public that you were jailed Night 1... Maybe so.

Unless wifom, I suppose, but I find that somewhat unlikely given the way this all came out in thread. Yeah, I think I buy that. Durga is probably not Blind Assassin. I think Xorxes still could be.

[ChippeRock]

there is also

a) darg killed by car bomb, mafia killed Carl, SK targetted me/darg/Carl

i can't see why they would track either tbh, why is that a power?

regardless, we won't know. and i'm not sure what difference it makes

Well......thinking about this more....

it seems to me to be decently likely that the Blind Assassin did not make a kill last night. I just feel like Carl makes some sense as a Mafia kill target, and very little sense as a Blind Assassin kill target. Carl was probably the most widely town read player in the game. And it cannot be true that Blind Assassin targeted Darg based on order of operations (Blind Assassin kill happens before Mafia Assassin kill).

If we assume scum killed Carl, Blind Assassin did not kill. I think that makes odds fairly decent that Blind Assassin is Durga or Xorxes, right?

I fail to see how your logic jumped to Durga & xorxes... Please explain why.

[Durga]

for the record,

no way xorx as BA claims roleblocked esp if it meant his kill didn't go through.

and i obv don't claim jailed either with the jailer dead.

I was thinking about that.

Let's see...

Xorx might still claim RB, as he would be trying to hide his identity from Mafia? Mafia would have already known he was RBed.

The jailed thing...you might be right about that. I can't think of any way it would later become public that you were jailed Night 1... Maybe so.

Unless wifom, I suppose, but I find that somewhat unlikely given the way this all came out in thread. Yeah, I think I buy that. Durga is probably not Blind Assassin. I think Xorxes still could be.

does it matter if he hides from mafia? they can't kill him. and if a dying mafia makes a claim that xorx was roleblocked d1.... xorx can easily be like wtf they're lying to get me mislynched.

it makes very little sense for him to claim rb as BA. sorry buddy

[EspressoPatronum]

for the record,

no way xorx as BA claims roleblocked esp if it meant his kill didn't go through.

and i obv don't claim jailed either with the jailer dead.

I was thinking about that.

Let's see...

Xorx might still claim RB, as he would be trying to hide his identity from Mafia? Mafia would have already known he was RBed.

The jailed thing...you might be right about that. I can't think of any way it would later become public that you were jailed Night 1... Maybe so.

Unless wifom, I suppose, but I find that somewhat unlikely given the way this all came out in thread. Yeah, I think I buy that. Durga is probably not Blind Assassin. I think Xorxes still could be.

Agreed. Possible Xorxes Blind Assassin, possible Durga target.

I'm inclined to lean toward the latter, but the former could explain Xorxes' quieter behaviour. Perhaps he was trying to survive by staying under the radar?

[EspressoPatronum]

there is also

a) darg killed by car bomb, mafia killed Carl, SK targetted me/darg/Carl

i can't see why they would track either tbh, why is that a power?

regardless, we won't know. and i'm not sure what difference it makes

Well......thinking about this more....

it seems to me to be decently likely that the Blind Assassin did not make a kill last night. I just feel like Carl makes some sense as a Mafia kill target, and very little sense as a Blind Assassin kill target. Carl was probably the most widely town read player in the game. And it cannot be true that Blind Assassin targeted Darg based on order of operations (Blind Assassin kill happens before Mafia Assassin kill).

If we assume scum killed Carl, Blind Assassin did not kill. I think that makes odds fairly decent that Blind Assassin is Durga or Xorxes, right?

I fail to see how your logic jumped to Durga & xorxes... Please explain why.

IF Carl was maf kill, THEN the BA didn't kill bcz the other two kills were from modkill and carbomb.

IF BA didn't kill, THEN either (a) Durga is BA, (b) Durga was BA's target, or (c) Xorxes is BA. Durga and Xorxes are the only because Durga was jailed (thus roleblocked and protected) and Xorxes was roleblocked.

If you don't think Carl was the maf target, none of the rest follows.

[Durga]

this is both speculative and silly

[ChippeRock]

Well......thinking about this more....

it seems to me to be decently likely that the Blind Assassin did not make a kill last night. I just feel like Carl makes some sense as a Mafia kill target, and very little sense as a Blind Assassin kill target. Carl was probably the most widely town read player in the game. And it cannot be true that Blind Assassin targeted Darg based on order of operations (Blind Assassin kill happens before Mafia Assassin kill).

If we assume scum killed Carl, Blind Assassin did not kill. I think that makes odds fairly decent that Blind Assassin is Durga or Xorxes, right?

I fail to see how your logic jumped to Durga & xorxes... Please explain why.

IF Carl was maf kill, THEN the BA didn't kill bcz the other two kills were from modkill and carbomb.

IF BA didn't kill, THEN either (a) Durga is BA, (b) Durga was BA's target, or (c) Xorxes is BA. Durga and Xorxes are the only because Durga was jailed (thus roleblocked and protected) and Xorxes was roleblocked.

If you don't think Carl was the maf target, none of the rest follows.

Okay, that makes sense. But, this is assuming they're not fake claiming - which I guess would mean they're most likely scum, but there's a chance they're town with flavor.

[FlaviusAetius]

MY ISO ON CHIPPIE

Chippie posts 5 posts, and Durga is already saying Chippie is spamming
Chippie posts 6 posts, and Squiggs already thinks Chippie is scum
Chippie is at 9 posts, and has to already defend himself from xorxes
Guys he quoted the role PMs and said there was some way he could find out who was town with it. Weird, but scummy? Give me a break
QUOTE FROM ND, THE MAN WHO SAID HE WAS LOOKING AT CHIPPIE WITH NOTHING FROM THE OUTSIDE
"Chippie, about what I expected. A true retard right there."

Chippie has posted 180, Im not even at post 20, and everyone is already calling him scum. Does anyone have any idea why it was so obvious to just defend him?

Oh boy lets keep going

So basically he drops the cryptic posts by posts 30's(estimate im not counting) and now is on Squiggs for the stuff he pulled with Squigg's Dude, Im pretty sure he didn't read the beginning where this was all explained

Oh, by the way, Carl attacked Chippie for the same reason, but he forgave him, you should too

Seems like no one is letting him go with the beginning and et jumps into the nonsense as well

I then attack Chippie for saying his attacks on Squiggs made no sense, because he started the supposed 'easy wagons'

Oh interesting, Chippie thinks Crusader is a town
Oh. My. God.

Chippie started the bozo wagon


He jumped off it and went back to Squiggs seems like he ignored my defense of Squiggs

Chippie also just went back to all of Moscow's games and analyzed his meta, basically he doesnt talk Day 1 as town

Ok I need to go to bed now, I'll finish this tomorrow
So far I've seen some questionable stuff from Chippie, but nothing that makes him scum, I better see some crazy stuff when I get to teacon v Chippie @ND cause so far, nothing.

[ChippeRock]

this is both speculative and silly

Hey, you're the one that made the Jailed claim.

[EspressoPatronum]

this is both speculative and silly

Yes to speculative, no to silly.

Finding leads to the BA now can help us later when/if we need to lynch them.

[FlaviusAetius]

for the record,

no way xorx as BA claims roleblocked esp if it meant his kill didn't go through.

and i obv don't claim jailed either with the jailer dead.

I was thinking about that.

Let's see...

Xorx might still claim RB, as he would be trying to hide his identity from Mafia? Mafia would have already known he was RBed.

The jailed thing...you might be right about that. I can't think of any way it would later become public that you were jailed Night 1... Maybe so.

Unless wifom, I suppose, but I find that somewhat unlikely given the way this all came out in thread. Yeah, I think I buy that. Durga is probably not Blind Assassin. I think Xorxes still could be.

Agreed. Possible Xorxes Blind Assassin, possible Durga target.

I'm inclined to lean toward the latter, but the former could explain Xorxes' quieter behaviour. Perhaps he was trying to survive by staying under the radar?

Actually probably.
M45 he didnt talk at all, he just wanted to survive as long as possible, we were scum together
M1007 he was town and did the famous xorxes v teacon thing
imo He talks as town
He's quite as mafia adding him to my list

Foxcastle
TrPrado
xorxes
Espresso

[Durga]

this is both speculative and silly

Hey, you're the one that made the Jailed claim.

what does that have to do with anything. i was jailed. pls counter claim me if you know otherwise.

secondly ,can you answer my question. how do you have time to be on this thread 24/7

[ChippeRock]

Chippie started the bozo wagon

As I recall, that was a pressure vote since he was lurking. He made a couple posts and I went back to my scum-read at the time.

[Balki Bartokomous]

does it matter if he hides from mafia? they can't kill him. and if a dying mafia makes a claim that xorx was roleblocked d1.... xorx can easily be like wtf they're lying to get me mislynched.

it makes very little sense for him to claim rb as BA. sorry buddy

Well, they could lynch him.

I think that if I were Blind Assassin, I’d definitely want to keep my identity secret from Mafia, especially with Mafia in the lead. Blind Assassin is not going to win unless he or she keeps identity secret from the other two factions.

[Durga]

this is both speculative and silly

Yes to speculative, no to silly.

Finding leads to the BA now can help us later when/if we need to lynch them.

its silly bc neither xorx nor I are that dumb

[EspressoPatronum]

I fail to see how your logic jumped to Durga & xorxes... Please explain why.

IF Carl was maf kill, THEN the BA didn't kill bcz the other two kills were from modkill and carbomb.

IF BA didn't kill, THEN either (a) Durga is BA, (b) Durga was BA's target, or (c) Xorxes is BA. Durga and Xorxes are the only because Durga was jailed (thus roleblocked and protected) and Xorxes was roleblocked.

If you don't think Carl was the maf target, none of the rest follows.

Okay, that makes sense. But, this is assuming they're not fake claiming - which I guess would mean they're most likely scum, but there's a chance they're town with flavor.

Nobody CCd the claims, so I doubt either of them fake claimed.

[Durga]

can someone explain to me why flav is so obsessed w/ chippe

[ChippeRock]

this is both speculative and silly

Hey, you're the one that made the Jailed claim.

what does that have to do with anything. i was jailed. pls counter claim me if you know otherwise.

secondly ,can you answer my question. how do you have time to be on this thread 24/7

I refuse to answer questions about my family life.

Look, claims are unreliable. I can't prove you were or weren't jailed, and I can't prove xorxes was or wasn't roleblocked.

It's a shaky foundation - but if you're going to claim, there will be speculation. Don't whine about that speculation.

[FlaviusAetius]

Chippie started the bozo wagon

As I recall, that was a pressure vote since he was lurking. He made a couple posts and I went back to my scum-read at the time.

Yea well that pressure vote took off, I hope to find you defended bozo throughout the day from then on good night