At the time I posted the list, none of my list of people I wanted to kill were viable wagons. We were down to Flavius and bozo.ND wrote: ↑Thu Jun 06, 2019 2:01 amOkay, yeah I saw that post. Yeah, I mean, I see where you voted Bozo on Page 66. You give a ‘reason’ but I don’t see how this somehow invalidates your previous list on Page 64?? Why wasn’t Bozo on that list? Just making a best guess based on the wagons? This is what I am confused about.
If you check out the whole list from 4am or 5am or whenever it was, you will see that I had bozo in a pile of people who hadn't posted enough for me to think anything significant about them.
I did not want to lynch Flavius because I was very sure he was town. I incorrectly talked myself into believing bozo was a bit better than a shot in the dark, when in truth he was a shot in the dark and I was letting my strong desire not to let Flavius get lynched cloud my judgment on bozo.
The scenario was what 'invalidated' the list if you will.
FWIW I think about half of them were wrong and I am a bit lost right now. I think Flavius and Chippe are obviously town when it seems almost no one else does, and it's becoming very hard to sort out the townies who are wrong in good faith (in my view) and the mafia who are taking advantage of the townies being wrong (again in my view).
I think Foxcastle and dargorygel are still good lynches on that list. I've talked a bit about the wagons from the perspective of believing Flavius to be town, since I do, and Foxcastle and dargorygel look very suspicious to me if that's true.
Tom made some great points about TrPrado's big posts being mostly recap and little analysis. I think I put him in the kill list in error.
I'm not sure what to do with Durga or connorcompton, though I think Durga's desire to go for someone else besides Flavius or bozo is probably good for her.
I think I added TrPrado to the "COOL" or "PASS" categories (don't remember which) in error because I wanted to give credit for his big posting effort, but Tom and others have rightly pointed out that the big posts were scant on committal reads, which is odd for Prado having done so much reading. He's also in my view not followed up very much with all the questions he asked, which is what I figured he would do when the questions were effectively the culmination of his massive posts. And I think his continued pushing on Flavius really sucks.
But I have to admit I'm still struggling with reconciling how much work he seemed to put into his posts... do people really do all that work in huge mafia games? Especially in the presence of multiple players who immediately called it out for lacking in conclusions? I can't see myself doing it as mafia, I'll say that.
I keep coming back to Foxcastle and dargorygel so that's probably where I'll start d2 if I'm around for it.
