Mafia 46 - Ace Attorney - GAME THREAD

[Nephthys]

I am open to the Nephthys idea tomorrow.

Why not today?

Because Flavius is much higher on my list. And TrPrado is also a possibility. But I doubt I'll move off Flavius.

Oo prado could be a good wagon

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 1.16ish

FlaviusAetius(7) - Balki Bartokomous, Dargorygel, Foxcastle, Moscowfleet, Tom Bombadil, TrPrado, Durga
bozotheclown(4) - Percy Williams, et, Damo666, Connorcompton
TrPrado(3) - FlaviusAetius, ChippeRock, Carl Tuckerson
ChippeRock(2) - bozotheclown, EspressoPatronum
CruaaderReynauld(2) - ND, Teacon7
Nephthys(1) - Squigs44
Durga(1) - Nephthys
Percy Williams(1) - xorxes
Foxcastle(1) - Rdrivera2005
No‑Lynch(1) - CruaaderReynauld

Flavius is set for lynching.

You have 8 minutes remaining...

[ChippeRock]

Literally no one has a compelling answer for why scum Flavius would have been so invested in killing Prado and not bozotheclown when bozotheclown is an easy lynch and the counterwagon.
Yet seven bozos who are not clowns are parked on him anyway.
Unbelievable.

Agreed.

[Tom Bombadil]

@Tom, because TrPrado - when at the time all everyone knew was that Cruaader was a new player playing his 1st every Mafia game - instantly jumped on Cruaader's wagon immediately after ND did. It's simply irrational, based on the information about Cruaader they had at the time to jump onto his wagon and not rule out anything he said due to him being a noob.

Please note, this is at the time, and while their votes look good in hindsight - at the time, based on the info they had, they are very scummy.

Pass. This is NAI for Prado

[connorcompton]

Neph, if I'm scum - then I'm trying to protect someone by lynching you. Who am I protecting?

You don't have to. In fact I would go as far as to say that if you are scum then our lovely leading wagons are town.

HOW DOES THIS MAKE ANY SENSE

why would I lead a random wagon on you if I'm scum and the two leading wagons are town????????

i'm v sure neph is scum guys tomorrow we are doing this

I'm convinced.
But first, I need to ##VOTE TrPrado
For all over the reasons I have already stated plus the last comment he directed at me sounded oh so much like Mafia trying to scare the new guy.

[Squigs44]

##vote Bozo

[Carl Tuckerson]

Foxcastle,

Please tell me why you think scum Flavius would pursue Prado over bozotheclown in this situation.

Thank you.

[FlaviusAetius]

Let me finish rereading the game first...you should do the same
But
1) You just wanted a joke phase
2) You didnt even want Squigs to explain about his dude
3) You conveniently forgot everything about Squig's dude
4) You wanted zero lists to be made
5) Just asking questions, not providing anything, obviously a scum
6) You voted on an easy Chippie wagon with NO EXPLINATION
7) You asked what AI is yet you are giving lessons to people, what??
8) You said you'd post reads, yet you aren't going to reread the game??
Answer this all and why

1) k?
You wanted it, and kept fighting for one, despite us actually wanting to do stuff, why?

2) that’s not what I didn’t want him to explain. I didn’t want him to explain why he townread me and scumread you. It was pretty obvious to me and to Balki but you seemed very upset by it. I wanted you to puzzle it out for yourself because it was entertaining. And like page 2 or 3
Awful answer, obviously a lie, again back to just joking around if you were being truthful, not actually trying to solve anything

3) I didn’t forget. I just never cared. What’s so convenient about it?

Yes but it mattered, I went back to your posts, and you were trying to pin me because of it

4) if all lists are gonna be like yours then sure. Nobody making a list is better than everyone posting vague and incomplete lists that have no explanation

Did you not read my explanations I had clear criteria, and you fit every single bit of it. You don't contribute anything, and just like to poke holes and egg people on

5) I fundamentally disagree with the premise of your argument, there’s very little in terms of questions that are actively unhelpful. I’m trying to puzzle players out so I can try to figure out the game
Im not saying questions are unhelpful but when its all you do, thats a problem

6) correct

Explain then.

7) my mind went to artificial intelligence, I also don’t remember anyone ever using that lingo in that abbreviation when I played last

Hmmm, ok...

8) I didn’t say I WON’T reread. I said I haven’t. We’re not even 24 hours into the game. And if you want me to post a list (a better list) I’m not doing that for at least another 24 hours either.
We are asking for gutreads right off the bat, you went directly against that idea, also I did provide criteria to my list, aka an explination

FOUND IT
RIGHT THERE @TOM
I also responded to his questions, let me find that

[Nephthys]

Actually no, Prado lives today. I must support the walls

[ChippeRock]

Why not today?

Because Flavius is much higher on my list. And TrPrado is also a possibility. But I doubt I'll move off Flavius.

Oo prado could be a good wagon

Yeah, I think Durga is just too late of a wagon...

[Nephthys]

You don't have to. In fact I would go as far as to say that if you are scum then our lovely leading wagons are town.

HOW DOES THIS MAKE ANY SENSE

why would I lead a random wagon on you if I'm scum and the two leading wagons are town????????

i'm v sure neph is scum guys tomorrow we are doing this

I'm convinced.
But first, I need to ##VOTE TrPrado
For all over the reasons I have already stated plus the last comment he directed at me sounded oh so much like Mafia trying to scare the new guy.

Thats all it took to convince you?

[Foxcastle]

Foxcastle,

Please tell me why you think scum Flavius would pursue Prado over bozotheclown in this situation.

Thank you.

Because if he parks his vote on Bozo (the second wagon), he cannot move it to save himself. If he's not on either the first or second wagons, he has a chance to move it to save himself. Unfortunately, it's NAI behavior. Also, unfortunately for him, it does not look like it'll be close enough to matter.

[Nephthys]

Because Flavius is much higher on my list. And TrPrado is also a possibility. But I doubt I'll move off Flavius.

Oo prado could be a good wagon

Yeah, I think Durga is just too late of a wagon...

Likely but I'm partially curious to see how much/if it gains any momentum

[ChippeRock]

Squigs, you might want to jump ship...

[ChippeRock]

Squigs, you might want to jump ship...

To Prado I mean.

[Squigs44]

Squigs, you might want to jump ship...

I'd actually rather Flavius go than Prado rn

[Durga]

Oo prado could be a good wagon

Yeah, I think Durga is just too late of a wagon...

Likely but I'm partially curious to see how much/if it gains any momentum

lol you scum scum

[Carl Tuckerson]

Foxcastle,

Please tell me why you think scum Flavius would pursue Prado over bozotheclown in this situation.

Thank you.

Because if he parks his vote on Bozo (the second wagon), he cannot move it to save himself. If he's not on either the first or second wagons, he has a chance to move it to save himself. Unfortunately, it's NAI behavior. Also, unfortunately for him, it does not look like it'll be close enough to matter.

But that vote does save himself! It would have made bozo the lead wagon by one with the tiebreaker.
C'mon, move to Prado

[Durga]

its town v town so neph is chiiillllinnnn

[TrPrado]

You don't have to. In fact I would go as far as to say that if you are scum then our lovely leading wagons are town.

HOW DOES THIS MAKE ANY SENSE

why would I lead a random wagon on you if I'm scum and the two leading wagons are town????????

i'm v sure neph is scum guys tomorrow we are doing this

I'm convinced.
But first, I need to ##VOTE TrPrado
For all over the reasons I have already stated plus the last comment he directed at me sounded oh so much like Mafia trying to scare the new guy.

What did I direct at you?