M1007 — "Mafia, She Wrote" Game Thread

[e.m.c^42]

what shocked me the most was you creating a 'fake' user and talking with him as if it were me, but in essence you were taking to yourself :shock:

Oh, that.
That was fun XD

[MoscowFleet]

I feel oddly buddied by rd.

Teacon, you go from asking others to join you on ND, to moving off of him yourself. How exactly do you currently read ND?

[Vaporwave]

what shocked me the most was you creating a 'fake' user and talking with him as if it were me, but in essence you were taking to yourself

Oh, that.
That was fun XD

What do you think of teacon and damo?

[Vaporwave]

would say that xorxes is more townie than bozo

btw, I'm not placing bozo in townlean ...yet,

list coming right up

[Vaporwave]

This is early vibe, flavor, smell, whatever you wanna call it, but it's weak stuff

Town:
xorxes
rivera

Could be this, that or the other:
bozo
damo
e.m.c
Moscow
Percy
teacon

Complete nulls:
Durga


Promising peeps:
Espresso
Vashta

[rdrivera2005]

I feel oddly buddied by rd.

Teacon, you go from asking others to join you on ND, to moving off of him yourself. How exactly do you currently read ND?

Why giving a townread on you is buddiyng? I didn't said your reads are great or something like that (and they aren't usually). People use this term far too often.

This game is vanilla (a 1 shot doc and a 2/3 shot cop don't change it much) so giving reads are one of the best ways to build info.

[Vaporwave]

once again, bozo would have been in town categ if it weren't for his last game

where he perfectly emulated his town meta

[ND]

Hey BOYS! What do you all think of ND and lol EVERYONE ELSE? Now, I'm not going to say anything about anyone else but I'm going to ask random questions #ND and #Everyone else. K?

Current mood in the room. Dumb AF

[Foxcastle]

Meanwhile,
##callGM : I don't know what you can or can't confirm, but maybe as a favor to vash can you send him a PM to remind him the game exists?

Sheriff Tupper held up his hands trying to calm the crowd in the lobby. "Folks! Folks! I ain't gonna say one thing or another about who we know to be here or not be here. You all just be assured we got the situation under control."

[MoscowFleet]

I feel oddly buddied by rd.

Teacon, you go from asking others to join you on ND, to moving off of him yourself. How exactly do you currently read ND?

Why giving a townread on you is buddiyng? I didn't said your reads are great or something like that (and they aren't usually). People use this term far too often.

This game is vanilla (a 1 shot doc and a 2/3 shot cop don't change it much) so giving reads are one of the best ways to build info.

Relax. I just got an odd feeling. I was surprised you made posts specifically to say how you liked my posts, not once but twice. I’m not scumreading you for it.

I take it you didn’t like that one as much?

[EspressoPatronum]

I'll be at work for mornings + afternoons. All my activity here will be at lunch time and/or evening + night!

Thanks for the heads up. GL/HF.

What time zone are you in?
What do you think of: emc. And what do you think of: ND ? so far?

EST time zone.

Re: my early thoughts on ND, see the posts in which I vote for him.
Put briefly, I am comfortable voting ND for two reasons:
1. His gameplay is erratic. Whether this is normal for his game or not, I don't find it very useful. It's a huge plus if we vote him out and he's scum. Even if we vote him out and he's town, we still cut someone who wasn't providing a lot of substance.
2. Trying to butter ppl up is a red flag. I'm not sure how normal it is in forum games, but I find it suspect if people rely on "gut feelings" to clear town. His whole, "I feel like Durga is town" seemed like a weak attempt at taking some heat off him.

Not many thoughts on emc yet. I'll reread the posts and get back to you. Any posts +/ pages that stand out?

[EspressoPatronum]

Haven't played forum mafia before, but I've played a ton of Mafia/Werewolf in person.

Nice to meet you.

Nice to meet you too. Get ready for lots and lots of reading.

If you didn't already, check out the bot at mafia.peterlund.se. It's also got links to various jargon terms that have come up in common parlance here.

Have you played f2f mafia/werewolf with durga? You might have insight on meta that we wouldn't.

Will check out the bot.

Yeah, I have. Lots of Secret Hitler and some Werewolf. Is sharing outside info on meta allowed?

[rdrivera2005]

I feel oddly buddied by rd.

Teacon, you go from asking others to join you on ND, to moving off of him yourself. How exactly do you currently read ND?

Why giving a townread on you is buddiyng? I didn't said your reads are great or something like that (and they aren't usually). People use this term far too often.

This game is vanilla (a 1 shot doc and a 2/3 shot cop don't change it much) so giving reads are one of the best ways to build info.

Relax. I just got an odd feeling. I was surprised you made posts specifically to say how you liked my posts, not once but twice. I’m not scumreading you for it.

I take it you didn’t like that one as much?

I have been playing this way (answering/commenting posts while catching up) in the last games because I liked when Vecna do it and it's a good way to show the way you are thinking while catching up, it's usefull to myself also when I am a lot of pages back on the thread(not the case on this game) and don't want to lose my first reaction.
When I played on computer I used to have a open text file to write this sort of thinking, and later build my readlist, but on phone it just doesn't work.

[rdrivera2005]

I'll be at work for mornings + afternoons. All my activity here will be at lunch time and/or evening + night!

Thanks for the heads up. GL/HF.

What time zone are you in?
What do you think of: emc. And what do you think of: ND ? so far?

EST time zone.

Re: my early thoughts on ND, see the posts in which I vote for him.
Put briefly, I am comfortable voting ND for two reasons:
1. His gameplay is erratic. Whether this is normal for his game or not, I don't find it very useful. It's a huge plus if we vote him out and he's scum. Even if we vote him out and he's town, we still cut someone who wasn't providing a lot of substance.
2. Trying to butter ppl up is a red flag. I'm not sure how normal it is in forum games, but I find it suspect if people rely on "gut feelings" to clear town. His whole, "I feel like Durga is town" seemed like a weak attempt at taking some heat off him.

Not many thoughts on emc yet. I'll reread the posts and get back to you. Any posts +/ pages that stand out?

Ok, you said ND play is not usefull, so you don't mind lynching him. I don't fully agree with it, but for the sake of the discussion suppose you are right. What kind of play you find usefull?

[e.m.c^42]

what shocked me the most was you creating a 'fake' user and talking with him as if it were me, but in essence you were taking to yourself :shock:

Oh, that.
That was fun XD

What do you think of teacon and damo?

Will be paying more attention to Damo in the future, since he was pretty accurate last game with reads, but early on Damo is...Damo. He comes off as lurky/one-liner spouting, but spectating I found that they weren't as contentless as I previously thought. No opinion for now.

Teacon, I can't tell how rusty he actually is, but he comes off as experienced enough to know what's going on - so he's null. Completely unrelated to alignment feelings, but his style so far is one I like.

[e.m.c^42]

Haven't played forum mafia before, but I've played a ton of Mafia/Werewolf in person.

Nice to meet you.

Nice to meet you too. Get ready for lots and lots of reading.

If you didn't already, check out the bot at mafia.peterlund.se. It's also got links to various jargon terms that have come up in common parlance here.

Have you played f2f mafia/werewolf with durga? You might have insight on meta that we wouldn't.

Will check out the bot.

Yeah, I have. Lots of Secret Hitler and some Werewolf. Is sharing outside info on meta allowed?

Afaik, nope. Share away!

[EspressoPatronum]

Hey BOYS! What do you all think of ND and lol EVERYONE ELSE? Now, I'm not going to say anything about anyone else but I'm going to ask random questions #ND and #Everyone else. K?

Current mood in the room. Dumb AF

As stated in my reply to teacon earlier, my vote against you right now is partially because of posts like this.

Could you write a longer, substantive post compiling your thoughts on selected players' town/scum alignment? I'm having trouble parsing through all of your posts, so putting all of your important information into one post would be a lot more helpful for me to see your viewpoint(s).

[e.m.c^42]

This is early vibe, flavor, smell, whatever you wanna call it, but it's weak stuff

[snip]

Where did ND go? Or is this part of your secret scheme, lol

[e.m.c^42]

Also, speaking of ND;
Ugh why did you have to go and switch like that. It is a bit boring going back to using a more generic syntax.

[ND]

I'll be at work for mornings + afternoons. All my activity here will be at lunch time and/or evening + night!

Thanks for the heads up. GL/HF.

What time zone are you in?
What do you think of: emc. And what do you think of: ND ? so far?

EST time zone.

-snip-
2. Trying to butter ppl up is a red flag. I'm not sure how normal it is in forum games, but I find it suspect if people rely on "gut feelings" to clear town. His whole, "I feel like Durga is town" seemed like a weak attempt at taking some heat off him.

Not many thoughts on emc yet. I'll reread the posts and get back to you. Any posts +/ pages that stand out?

Lol wtf this guy is a total fruit cake