MAFIA 45 GAME THREAD - BETWEEN A ROCK AND A...ROCK

[brainbomb]

We still deserve an extra hour btw.

##Call GM
please reward town an extra hour for the hour that was revoked.

scum doesnt deserve extra time.

[brainbomb]

anymore questions xorxes?

[xorxes]

for anyone to assume im.lying about my desire to tie wagons youd have to logically think worcej, darg or both are scumbuddies to me.

but not a single persons even suggested that

No, just that you preferred Nephthys killed over whichever one of them is town.

makes no sense. I gained nothing by picking him. Why is my explanation unlikely? I felt a tie was best play

It wasn't the best play, whether you felt it or not. A tie benefitted scum there.

[brainbomb]

No, just that you preferred Nephthys killed over whichever one of them is town.

makes no sense. I gained nothing by picking him. Why is my explanation unlikely? I felt a tie was best play

It wasn't the best play, whether you felt it or not. A tie benefitted scum there.

I disagree. I think all 3 wagons were town there and we were blistered no matter what happened. a tie wouldve gotten me lynched the following day but at least was 1 less death


I also dont regret it in hindsight because my action nearly saved the doc

[xorxes]

We still deserve an extra hour btw.

##Call GM
please reward town an extra hour for the hour that was revoked.

scum doesnt deserve extra time.

We still have like 26 hours, what do you want one more for? It will only mean fewer people on at EOD.

[brainbomb]

obviously I cant take credit for saving the doc. but my vote shouldve been counted as an unvote imo

[FlaviusAetius]

you guys always think on the most basic of levels

in a zero sum scenario with votes flying around crazily
player x did a thing with his vote that contradicted an earlier stance
player z also did a thing
player y also did a thing
oh and there was two other (4) wagons chock full of lurkers who also did things

lets have player x explain themself

oh okay
we dont like player x
hes a dick and he talks funny

lets go ahead and ASK NO ONE ELSE, A SINGLE QUESTION ABOUT THEIR EOD BEHAVIOR

ok i have to just say, ive been catching up on what I've missed, and you SPECIFICALLY SAID; go BASIC, and dont overthink it...now when it applies to YOU, its changed?? In the beginning of this game I admired you so much and nepthys too, as people who could find anyone...you've lost all my trust...

[xorxes]

makes no sense. I gained nothing by picking him. Why is my explanation unlikely? I felt a tie was best play

It wasn't the best play, whether you felt it or not. A tie benefitted scum there.

I disagree. I think all 3 wagons were town there and we were blistered no matter what happened. a tie wouldve gotten me lynched the following day but at least was 1 less death


I also dont regret it in hindsight because my action nearly saved the doc

What??? Your action killed the doc because the wagons were dargo vs worcej before you went for Neph!

[brainbomb]

We still deserve an extra hour btw.

##Call GM
please reward town an extra hour for the hour that was revoked.

scum doesnt deserve extra time.

We still have like 26 hours, what do you want one more for? It will only mean fewer people on at EOD.

ill take it however your teams willing to award it to us. maybe give yourselves 1 less hour where you cant night chat

dont cheat the new gms and town out of time they rightfully deserve

[brainbomb]

It wasn't the best play, whether you felt it or not. A tie benefitted scum there.

I disagree. I think all 3 wagons were town there and we were blistered no matter what happened. a tie wouldve gotten me lynched the following day but at least was 1 less death


I also dont regret it in hindsight because my action nearly saved the doc

What??? Your action killed the doc because the wagons were dargo vs worcej before you went for Neph!

I tried to tie it
and unvoted when I saw everyone actually forced a lynch on him.
the gms didnt count my unvote
my entire goal was to save lives, to tie the lynch and see what could be learned even at the expense of my own life.

[yavuzovic]

Brainbomb is a clever man but he's cunning and knows where to act like mentally retarded and (I hope he is) thinking it's a good time for this. I have a strong gut feeling and urge to vote brain but I don't really have an argument. Stay here for now, let's see where my dream leads me.

[bozotheclown]

I remember brainbomb reacting the way he did today when he was the leading wagon before, so I looked it up.

##Vote brainbomb

##End

im ready for a new game. lets just call this a learning experience and move on. me and. neph have a fun setup. id rather play that where town has a chance

##Vote brainbomb

##End

lets move on

##Vote brainbomb

##Vote brainbomb
##End

Fine, done with this game. Im not scum, it should be very obvious im not. Yavuz was up my ass from the second I walked into this game. Im fine dying if it gets rid of him.

Hmm this brainbomb guy is pretty scummy too tho.

##Vote brainbomb
##End

Non-votes
Foxcastle
nesdunk14
reedeer1
xorxes

##Vote Brainbomb
##End

Ya we better hammer before the scumteam votes

The first two posts are from this game, the third post is from M43, where brainbomb was scum, and the last three posts are from M35, where brainbomb was scum.

The point is brainbomb like to self vote when he is scum under pressure.

[e.m.c^42]

We still deserve an extra hour btw.

##Call GM
please reward town an extra hour for the hour that was revoked.

scum doesnt deserve extra time.

Well, the hour that was revoked was originally an extra hour added...changing it to normal EOD time...so there really isn't a way to add another hour without shifting phase timing later for the entire rest of the game?

Y'all are quite welcome to castigate me as much as you want after the game, but as of so far I don't believe there's any necessary action to take :D

[brainbomb]

How many more times do I need to explain my vote was to tie the lynch as a 3 way tie. not to kill amy of those 3 guys? not to.kill neph.

how much more evidence do you need?
why is this so hard to just accept this answer

[FlaviusAetius]

Maybe I'm missing something because I havent seen xorxes play in any games so far but this one, but from someone who just joined and is seeing these people for the first time brainbomb has contradicted himself, acted rude, given up on the game, and gone after people who werent even a sliver of mafia

The evidence is just piling up for him...

Some people think that if scum don't kill me N1 or N2 then I'm automatically scum, because I'm so good that everyone is scared of me.

for anyone to assume im.lying about my desire to tie wagons youd have to logically think worcej, darg or both are scumbuddies to me.

but not a single persons even suggested that

Literally, STOP with this argument
You SAID YOURSELF mislynching is BAD, then you ENCOURAGE IT
You were on worcej lynching and then switched, FINE, but when you saw a lot of people on worcej still, why didnt you keep PUSHING HIM?
Do you HONESTLY believe Netptys was a better option than him??
Cmon dude, you are going against EVERYTHING you said in this game, and its just sad...
Again, I thought you were a next level person, clearly not...

[brainbomb]

I remember brainbomb reacting the way he did today when he was the leading wagon before, so I looked it up.

##Vote brainbomb

##End

im ready for a new game. lets just call this a learning experience and move on. me and. neph have a fun setup. id rather play that where town has a chance

##Vote brainbomb

##End

lets move on

##Vote brainbomb

##Vote brainbomb
##End

Fine, done with this game. Im not scum, it should be very obvious im not. Yavuz was up my ass from the second I walked into this game. Im fine dying if it gets rid of him.

Hmm this brainbomb guy is pretty scummy too tho.

##Vote brainbomb
##End

Non-votes
Foxcastle
nesdunk14
reedeer1
xorxes

##Vote Brainbomb
##End

Ya we better hammer before the scumteam votes

The first two posts are from this game, the third post is from M43, where brainbomb was scum, and the last three posts are from M35, where brainbomb was scum.

The point is brainbomb like to self vote when he is scum under pressure.

irrelevant. I do it all the time. regularly. It has zero alignment indicative meaning whatsoever. Im in the flavour. the gms introduced me to the game as a morale boost after a town got lynched day 1 and vecna died n1.

a morale boost.

who needed a morale boost at that point?

[bozotheclown]

makes no sense. I gained nothing by picking him. Why is my explanation unlikely? I felt a tie was best play

It wasn't the best play, whether you felt it or not. A tie benefitted scum there.

I disagree. I think all 3 wagons were town there and we were blistered no matter what happened. a tie wouldve gotten me lynched the following day but at least was 1 less death


I also dont regret it in hindsight because my action nearly saved the doc

That is completely untrue, Nephthys had no chance of being lynched until you voted for him in the last minute of the day.

[brainbomb]

what are you gonna do. talk to me for another 24 hours?

[xorxes]

I disagree. I think all 3 wagons were town there and we were blistered no matter what happened. a tie wouldve gotten me lynched the following day but at least was 1 less death


I also dont regret it in hindsight because my action nearly saved the doc

What??? Your action killed the doc because the wagons were dargo vs worcej before you went for Neph!

I tried to tie it
and unvoted when I saw everyone actually forced a lynch on him.
the gms didnt count my unvote
my entire goal was to save lives, to tie the lynch and see what could be learned even at the expense of my own life.

OK, let's say you're town and it was all pure motives. Suppose your unvote had worked and Neph was still alive. What would we have learned from what happened?

[bozotheclown]

I remember brainbomb reacting the way he did today when he was the leading wagon before, so I looked it up.

##Vote brainbomb

##End

im ready for a new game. lets just call this a learning experience and move on. me and. neph have a fun setup. id rather play that where town has a chance

##Vote brainbomb

##End

lets move on

##Vote brainbomb

##Vote brainbomb
##End

Fine, done with this game. Im not scum, it should be very obvious im not. Yavuz was up my ass from the second I walked into this game. Im fine dying if it gets rid of him.

Hmm this brainbomb guy is pretty scummy too tho.

##Vote brainbomb
##End

Non-votes
Foxcastle
nesdunk14
reedeer1
xorxes

##Vote Brainbomb
##End

Ya we better hammer before the scumteam votes

The first two posts are from this game, the third post is from M43, where brainbomb was scum, and the last three posts are from M35, where brainbomb was scum.

The point is brainbomb like to self vote when he is scum under pressure.

irrelevant. I do it all the time. regularly. It has zero alignment indicative meaning whatsoever. Im in the flavour. the gms introduced me to the game as a morale boost after a town got lynched day 1 and vecna died n1.

a morale boost.

who needed a morale boost at that point?

Can you point to all the times you self voted under pressure as town?