MAFIA 43 - GAME THREAD

[Durga]

i'm pretty committed to a bb lynch

[e.m.c^42]

OK, we have 10 conservative claims and 10 non-conservative claims, with MoscowFleet apparently out of the game. I think there is value in narrowing down the conservative claims. First, in my opinion, any non-conservative town who falsely claimed conservative should let us know now, even if it could give the scum a better chance if guessing the party cop. It would give us a good idea of how many scum claimed non-conservative. We do not want to be lynching in the conservative pool if all scum fake claimed non-conservative.

yes, this is an important one to discuss in the last few hours.

thoughts xorxes?

I guess we'll see if Tom appears anytime soon, and what alignment his slot claims.

as well as all the other people who dropped in to say "let me catch up" and vanished XD

[rdrivera2005]

Neph's (smaller) wall

So tham did answer my question but I really don't like the answer. I personally think that to really like someone to warrant posting you townlean is generally when you think they're on the right track, usually pushing good theories (xorx) or catching scum. I've already pointed out how this doesn't add up with the initial post. I think it more likely that he just picked people who he thought were easy TR. Scum lean

As for brain, what Tom said last game really stood out to me. There's no point lynching someone who will obv themselves easily. While overnight he went nuts and I'm suspicious, I'm not 100% yet. Based on last game (sorry brain), I really rate his scum game because its easy to pick up. I think he's best left alone for today put scrutinized tomorrow.

Attorney is really concerning me. Outing a PR is some horrific play. Luckily it was one of the more chill ones (assuming he was telling the truth). Regardless, Attorney needs to chill, he seems to do alright with some of his posting but then just makes some really dodgy decisions...

Vapor is still giving me odd feelings. Feels like he could be trying to buddy me? Not quite as overt as last game but still gives me pause. On the whole I think he's more likely town that Attorney (still think its S/T)

Percy is lacking severely in content which again is really concerning. Thinking a good lynch for tomorrow.

Vecna seems towny, prodding people and providing some content. My one concern is that he kinda pulled the rd susp out of nowhere. I don't feel ready to make a comment about rd yet but I note xorx voted for him just before. Also, I would like to know what this means?

Rdrivera explicitely not doing the thing

Overall
Scum - Percy, V/A (probs A), Tham
Will out themselves in the next day or two - Brain
Town - Vecna (for now), xorx, bozo

Lynch order
Attorney
Brain/Percy
Percy/Tham

town rdrivera always thinks and comments nearly the same shit as me wheb catching up. his posting and reasoning always has a distinct logic i can follow or agree with.

His only three posts lacked that. two of them I felt completely diffeerent on the topic, and they have a scent of him just trying to discuss currently hot topics to appear to be partaking.

Well, I really don't have the time and I feel I am lost in this game. I have guests at home and it's hard to find ways to use the phone. Hard to comment when I am skipping a lot. And if this post look like another pathetic excuse so be it.
I thought EOD was around this time, but seems it's one hour later, so will try to get back near EOD, but I see no reason to change my vote now, as I don't scumread Attorney.

[Foxcastle]

i'm pretty committed to a bb lynch

More because you think he's scum, or more because you want him out of the game?

[Vecna]

welcome wagons; Rdrivera, ike, percy, ND, Ezio.

probably forgetting some

[damo666]

Thanks Percy

(for omitting GSTQ)

[Ezio]

I want today to be Rdr vs Attorney.

I don't like how Attorney started treating today soley like a ratrace between him and brainbomb with 8 hours to go.

I don't like his calls for some low posters to get online.

I particularly hate this post:
"discussion time is always good for town
i was a bit on edge bc i was second wagon which is understandable"

Brainbomb should not be a wagon today. I think it was neph who said it perfectly: he's going to fuck himself over later 100% if he's scum. Better to use the lynch on someone scummier and less likely to obvscum.

[Vecna]

welcome wagons; Rdrivera, ike, percy, ND, Ezio.

probably forgetting some

Damo and thamrick?

[Vecna]

who is the person fooling us all?

The capable ones that could fit in here: nephtys and durga?

[Durga]

who is the person fooling us all?

The capable ones that could fit in here: nephtys and durga?

uhhhmmm pretty sure you're just targeting goddesses here, try again

[Ezio]

welcome wagons; Rdrivera, ike, percy, ND, Ezio.

probably forgetting some

Damo and thamrick?

Your thoughts on attorney have been changing dramatically through the day vecna. Where do they sit now?

[e.m.c^42]

If my posts seem really out of place, It's because I had a lot of catchup to do on all the posts that were spammed in.
Having read up to now, here is my wall analysis:

First the big posters,
Brainbomb seems scum to me, although I can believe his confession was a typo. He's been doing a lot of distracting posts only loosely related to flavour at best. Even if he's not scum, I don't think we'll be able to track down the scum with him still here. Thus he is my lynch vote.

Vapour feels town, I was suspicious at first, but then Vapour's defense seemed earnest and his analysis of everything was pretty good. I mainly used his "Hi" post as flavour to go with my vote.

Attorney: either a solid town or amazing mafia. He has been one of the most helpful and logical in this game in my opinion.

Lesser posters,

Nephys: love the walls, he seems town but there's not a lot to go off of

Emc: might be a scum, he seems to be mostly attacking others ideas, even if he isn't super aggressive about it. There are over 1000 posts so maybe I'm just missing his constructive posts.

Me: confident Percy is town. Mainly Percy is interested in some quality flavour, and at the start of the game was really unsure how this worked.

Everyone else: I'm really unsure. Where there hasn't been a ton of posting I don't have strong opinions, and I'm still figuring out how to figure out who is mafia in online mafia.

To damo, who finds me annoying: it's all for you. :-D :wink:

Thanks :D
can't say I agree with the all logic (especially with Attorney--can you perhaps explain a bit more on which part and how his posts have been logical? It's likely to be a personal fault of mine, but even with rereading it's a bit difficult for me haha---I can't really follow along to the "why+evidence" he has with his opinions)

but it's appreciated

(and be really thankful you didn't start by playing in the last game hah--this game has been really tame in terms of spam so far lol)

[Vecna]

welcome wagons; Rdrivera, ike, percy, ND, Ezio.

probably forgetting some

Damo and thamrick?

Your thoughts on attorney have been changing dramatically through the day vecna. Where do they sit now?

when in doubt, go with the initial gut i guess.

prefer a different lynch.

[Vecna]

yeah I think EMC has the charisma to be faking this as well

[Vecna]

who is the person fooling us all?

The capable ones that could fit in here: nephtys and durga?

uhhhmmm pretty sure you're just targeting goddesses here, try again

try convincing me with some insights.

youre still hiding the fact youre attributing to brainbomb the characteristics of being a black hole for attention.

[Vecna]

hiding behind*

such a peculiar sentence that i produced there

[Durga]

saying like "these are the people i think are sneaky enough to do 'x'" is meaningless and i have nothing to say in defense, nor do i have a desire to convince you otherwise atm

[e.m.c^42]

who is the person fooling us all?

The capable ones that could fit in here: nephtys and durga?

Neph was scum in his first game, right?

I remember being really quite impressed, and he provided analysis even as scum---in which case, I feel he's prolly one those you look into later in the game?

[Foxcastle]

saying like "these are the people i think are sneaky enough to do 'x'" is meaningless and i have nothing to say in defense, nor do i have a desire to convince you otherwise atm

The thing I dislike most about Durga's play is that she's setting herself up to mislynch Brainbomb and not have to feel bad about it. She doesn't even have to pretend that she thinks he's scum, she's just going to say "good riddance" no matter what happens. (Things pings me because I have done it as scum before.)

[e.m.c^42]

yeah I think EMC has the charisma to be faking this as well

:D

I'm touched you think that <3

but it's not really true this time--we'll have to wait some more games to see that ahah