Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Hey everyone. Ghug says you can't sheep me.

Thanks babe.

[ghug]

Tham townread Jamie all the time without any explanation. Lots of weakass scumreading with no push back and forth with brain. Interesting N2 quote:

If bozo is scum, why did he sit parked on Jamie with the vote tied for so long instead of switching to thd?

His reaction to Tom's claim seems over the top. The blatantness of his Jamie townread is giving me pause though.

[bozotheclown]

Also, thinking Tom was cop with a scan on Jamiet just because Tom voted for him if he didn't know Jamiet's alignment is kind of weird, but maybe he was just very convinced Jamiet was scum. I'll have to reread and think more about this.

The only reason I was confident Jamie was scum was because of Tom's indication he had a scan on Jamie. It was more than "just because Tom voted for him", and your claiming to not see the other signals increases my suspicion of you.

I mean before Tom's claim. You said that you had already thought that Tom was the cop and that ghug had claimed a guilty on Jamiet because he also thought that.

That is when I am referring to also. I was confident Jamie was scum at the beginning of D2, after Tom voted for him.

[Vaporwave]

bomb is browsing this thread

I find it incredibly funny

will update my list

with

bozotheclown still unsure, lean a bit townish haven't updated myself
brainbomb - boy with hooker fetish
CrimsonFox - trollish but fun, not sure which category, did we really have t/t/t D1
damo - townish, was he roleblocked? he's clear
RHK - can't rememer much beside his cool poem, he pushed hard for france, possible scum
Thomas - I had him as town, but then I had 2 other talkative scum as town, to be re-visited
e.m.c^42 - my 'peek' I still think he's town, I thought I hated him D1 but that's not how it was, I was clashing with his rambling, wordy style and it made me see him as scum

Ezio - scum candidate
flash2015 - no longer with us
foodcoats/dargoyle - desperado
ghug - bomb confirmed him as town
Jamiet99uk - a very loud scum
LordQuas - stilll wanna keep my trust in LQ, I love how he's independent and stubborn, doesn't really sheep that much, alpha vibe
MoscowFleet - this one had a bit of an aggro style early D1 then he got mellow, why that change in posting style?
ND - got his revenge on Jamie after all
Nephthys - could be ...something
peterlund - scum candidate, I think he's fake
RagingIke - another one that had okayish moments but nothing outstanding townie
rdrivera2005 - weakness read cos of his photo so don't ask me I'm biased and I won't vote for him, but I'll be honest, I think he's more town than scum
thamrick - Tom has spoken on him
thdfrance - france has been defeated
Tom Bombadil - the hero that we deserve
Vecna - I still think Vecna is town, Vecna had serious investigative points and his questions reminded me of Poirot or some other famous detective
xorxes - uncertain of his alignment

to summarize:

Town, no order cause hey: Vecna/Tom/rivera/LQ/gargoyle/ghug/damo/emc2

To be sorted and 'sniffed': xorxes/Raging/Moscow/bozo/Cfox/Tom

This is where scum lives: thamrick/peterlund/Neph/Ezio/Rhk

[Vaporwave]

Sheep my towns, I was one of the few that predicted ND as town

Had 2 failures within townreads, so now my strong townreads have a bigger chance of being pure

Never touch: Vecna + LQ, the magic duo

[rdrivera2005]

I still am thinking about rdrivera… My initial D1 analysis is still in my head, and he is on my original list of lynchables.

That being said, in my ISO, these things stood out to me now.

On page 10 of D1, he drops this comment about brain: “I liked Xorxes posts and Brain is acting weird, but he always act weird.” Which might be planting a seed of brain-voting, without being too accusatory… in case scum Rdr has to bus…

These two brain things would have more meaning if dargo hadn't shot so quickly before a vote test could be done on the brain...

On pages 60 and 61 he has a tunneling conversation with flash… which looks worse after flash’s townflip. He is too confident imo.

On day 2… there is some slow but unsubstantiated movement towards brain… which might be some bussing prep…

When I voted for him, he responded with a simple defense… but I wonder if a townie would even bother defending… but perhaps a scum might feel more prone to defend. Although Rdr is our professional scum…

Finally, he never did his vote analysis… promises, promises, promises.

Posting this NOT because it is great and profound… but because I want to keep an eye still on rdr, and maybe someone can add to it.

Just wanted to answer this while reading the last 4 pages: feel free to shoot me after next day....
But you are right on one thing, I should not make promises. So if I have the time, I will try to re-read, if not I will just vote with my gut feeling (that just sucked until now).

[rdrivera2005]

Ok, let's make this interesting ##vote thdfrance

This vote by rivera looks horrible.

Vote count was:

thd (6)
Jamiet (5)
bozo (5)

and rivera made it:

thd (7)
Jamiet (5)
bozo (4)

Ironically this actually makes me townread him. If bozo is scum, scum rivera keeps bussing him every time. If bozo is town, scum rivera doesn't try to save Jamie, I don't think.

My vote on thd here was really bad, all I can say in my defense is that I didn't look the vote count and thought Jamiet was on the lead. When I realized thd was a runaway wagon I moved back to Bozo.

[CrimsonFox]

There's something very liberating about being condemned to death but not dead yet.

For my last meal, I would like you to bring me all the bacon and eggs you have.

Wait. I'm concerned you might think you heard me say, "I want a lot of bacon and eggs". What I said was, "bring me all the bacon and eggs you have".

Do you understand? Good.

No.

it's ron swanson

[CrimsonFox]

i was roleblocked

[bozotheclown]

I don't know about thamrick as scum, but I may be biased because he defended me a couple of time against what I thought were bad reasons to scum read me. However, I would be surprised if he is scum and was trying to pocket me at a time when there was a good chance I was going to get mislynched.

[bozotheclown]

i was roleblocked

When?

[ghug]

i was roleblocked

Oh cool let's do ghug vs CFox.

[thamrick]

VOTE COUNT:
thdfrance (6) DemonRHK Nephthys damo666 thamrick Jamiet99uk e.m.c^42
bozotheclown (6) xorxes LordQuas rdrivera2005 Vecna DoubtingThomas MoscowFleet
Jamiet99uk (5) Tom Bombadil brainbomb bozotheclown peterlund RagingIke297
brainbomb (1) ghug
Vaporwave (1) Ezio
ghug (1) thdfrance
damo666 (1) dargorygel
Nephthys (1) Vaporwave
xorxes (1) CrimsonFox

1 minutes left.

Then bozo, Vecna, Moscow, LQ move to thd to break the tie. Not much we can conclude from that last minute.

Last vote on Jamiet was Ike's an hour and a half before the deadline to put him in a 5-3 lead against thd. That makes Ike look good.

The votes from there to the last minute were:

thamrick for thd (bad)
dargo for bozo (town)
emc for dargo (?)
thamrick for bozo (also bad if bozo is town)
LQ for thd (looks bad but I think LQ town)
LQ for bozo (looks bad again)
Jamiet for thd (scum)
emc for thd (bad)
rdr from bozo to thd (bad with bad reason)
DT from bozo to thd (bad)
rdr from thd back to bozo (bad)
Vecna to bozo (good if bozo scum, NAI if town)
Moscow to bozo (good if bozo scum, NAI if town)
DT from thd to bozo creating a 6-6 tie between thd and bozo (good if bozo scum, ok if bozo town)

I think thamrick and rivera look the worst there. ##VOTE thamrick

How are you this bad at interpreting the peterbot?

I literally only voted for thd D2.

[Tom Bombadil]

This is strange

[thamrick]

Regardless though, I'm a liability for town now. I'll try to reread and post some thoughts, but it's not super likely. I open at work tomorrow and work up to EoD. My only contributions will be what I can do tonight.

[CrimsonFox]

i was roleblocked

Oh cool let's do ghug vs CFox.

Cool

[thamrick]

Rereading brainbomb (ughhh), I feel like xorxes and MoscowFleet are pretty safe bets to be scum, and I'm even calling MF as godfather.

[Nephthys]

Rereading brainbomb (ughhh), I feel like xorxes and MoscowFleet are pretty safe bets to be scum, and I'm even calling MF as godfather.

What reasons do you have for this?

[Nephthys]

and Moscow is just pure town here. I could follow everything he was saying and nodding my head thinking, yea. this is it. this is right

Moscowfleet has made one substantive post. One. You'd think he'd posted loads from the way you talk. Weird.

I think this post is odd as Jamie had been voting for others for less (ND for not shitposting, brain for being out of meta) while he doesn't vote for MF here. I think that this is to small a detail to be intentional

scum points for MF

[thamrick]

discouragement meter

vecna is discouraged
flash is discouraged
ezio is claculating
ND is lively
Jamie is gaurded yet haughty
ghug is unengaging
crimsonfox is jovial yet buddyish
moscow is formulaeic
vaporwave seems dreamy

p.8

Post counts at this point:
Vecna - 1
flash - 5
ezio - 2
ND - 22
Jamie - 11
ghug - 2
crimson - 29
moscow - 2
vapor - 5

Here are Moscow's posts:

Ayy, I missed you guys.

##vote Ike for old times sake

Also do we still have the peterbot?

Compare to Vecna's post:

This is excited scum brainbomb

##vote Brainbomb

honest read. Brainybomb rolled scum. Sad. Its obvious on page1.

He might be scum with ND

and to Ezio's 2:

Hello everyone. I've learned my lesson from last game, and my conclusion is that hardclaiming scum is the optional strategy for town, and for me in particular.

So, I am scum.

##vote ezio he's scum.

OMG there isn't a vig in the game! This is amazing.

Change of plans Bois.

##vote nolynch. If we Lynch someone, they will be the vengeful town. This person will have their shot input on me. The only way I don't die d1 is with a nolynch.

Jamiet looks memey for voting me. Brainbomb looks scummy stupid for saying scum doesn't claim scum.

The MF inclusion here just feels off to me. The others kinda make sense based on who was active in the thread.

(Also, how awesome would it be if Brainbomb outed 3 scum in his post by misspelling his adjective of them?)