Mafia 42 - Space Ghost Coast to Coast - OFFICIAL GAME THREAD

[dargorygel]

"The fuck? People that wanted a free townclear or a scum reveal look scummy?"
@vecna
I sort of get this line of thought... with Jaime being the Oracle, if he ends up lynched, they get a read, right?
So as long as he was in the sites of everyone, it would be better for him (from scum perspective) to be lynched that shot.

What am I missing?

[bozotheclown]

If bozo ended up being wrong about jamiet, I would feel like it 100% clears him. Instead, I think it increases the chance he's scum.

Also, thinking Tom was cop with a scan on Jamiet just because Tom voted for him if he didn't know Jamiet's alignment is kind of weird, but maybe he was just very convinced Jamiet was scum. I'll have to reread and think more about this.

The only reason I was confident Jamie was scum was because of Tom's indication he had a scan on Jamie. It was more than "just because Tom voted for him", and your claiming to not see the other signals increases my suspicion of you.

[bozotheclown]

Yes :D

So anyone that wanted to lynch Jamie today looks kinda scummy...

The fuck? People that wanted a free townclear or a scum reveal look scummy?

i think you are missing how the scum oracle works.

[bozotheclown]

If bozo ended up being wrong about jamiet, I would feel like it 100% clears him. Instead, I think it increases the chance he's scum.

If you think I was bussing Jamie and brainbomb, you should vote for xorxes to see if I am bussing him also.

[xorxes]

And suddenly everyone that was shouting really hard for the desperado to shoot jamiet is looking really really bad

Name names! Usually shouting hard for suboptimal moves is more of a towntell.

[Vecna]

"The fuck? People th at wanted a free townclear or a scum reveal look scummy?"
@vecna
I sort of get this line of thought... with Jaime being the Oracle, if he ends up lynched, they get a read, right?
So as long as he was in the sites of everyone, it would be better for him (from scum perspective) to be lynched that shot.

What am I missing?

If he was lynched, he reveals the alignment and role of someone. The oracle was negative scum utility.

By calling for Jamiet to be shot, they removed that added town benefit of getting an extra free townclear (or scum reveal, but that wouldve been really stupid).

[Vecna]

Wait wtf, wasnt the oracle public reveal during the signup part of this setup?

[Vecna]

disregard all my shouting then

[xorxes]

If bozo ended up being wrong about jamiet, I would feel like it 100% clears him. Instead, I think it increases the chance he's scum.

Also, thinking Tom was cop with a scan on Jamiet just because Tom voted for him if he didn't know Jamiet's alignment is kind of weird, but maybe he was just very convinced Jamiet was scum. I'll have to reread and think more about this.

The only reason I was confident Jamie was scum was because of Tom's indication he had a scan on Jamie. It was more than "just because Tom voted for him", and your claiming to not see the other signals increases my suspicion of you.

I mean before Tom's claim. You said that you had already thought that Tom was the cop and that ghug had claimed a guilty on Jamiet because he also thought that.

[dargorygel]

ALL your shouting? Or just your shouting about the Oracle?

[Vecna]

ALL your shouting? Or just your shouting about the Oracle?

Now that the hooker is dead, you could also save your daredevil shot for tomorrow or the day after.

Scum is pretty much forced to kill the cop tonight. Doc saved you tomorrow night. Removes 4 people from your pool of targets (IF we can manage not to lynch the doc in those 2 days that is)

[xorxes]

Wait wtf, wasnt the oracle public reveal during the signup part of this setup?

This looks like such a fake attempt at a townslip that it must be real

[Vecna]

go away xorxes

[Vecna]

VOTE COUNT:
thdfrance (6) DemonRHK Nephthys damo666 thamrick Jamiet99uk e.m.c^42
bozotheclown (6) xorxes LordQuas rdrivera2005 Vecna DoubtingThomas MoscowFleet
Jamiet99uk (5) Tom Bombadil brainbomb bozotheclown peterlund RagingIke297
brainbomb (1) ghug
Vaporwave (1) Ezio
ghug (1) thdfrance
damo666 (1) dargorygel
Nephthys (1) Vaporwave
xorxes (1) CrimsonFox

1 minutes left.

[Tom Bombadil]

Yeah. I like thamrick as scum here. I thought brain was pretty scummy - maybe he was the person scum would bus. Tham shades him throughout the game and defended Jamie pretty heavily d2

tham should definitely be a choice today

[ghug]

And suddenly everyone that was shouting really hard for the desperado to shoot jamiet is looking really really bad

Name names! Usually shouting hard for suboptimal moves is more of a towntell.

It wasn't suboptimal though.

[dargorygel]

Yeah. I like thamrick as scum here. I thought brain was pretty scummy - maybe he was the person scum would bus. Tham shades him throughout the game and defended Jamie pretty heavily d2

tham should definitely be a choice today

Ok
##vote thamrick

[dargorygel]

ALL your shouting? Or just your shouting about the Oracle?

Now that the hooker is dead, you could also save your daredevil shot for tomorrow or the day after.

Scum is pretty much forced to kill the cop tonight. Doc saved you tomorrow night. Removes 4 people from your pool of targets (IF we can manage not to lynch the doc in those 2 days that is)

I agree...

[Vecna]

##vote Thamrick

[Vecna]

Jamiet was also heavily defending Thamrick and attacking everyone scumreading him.