Mafia 41 - Sid Meiers Civilizaton Mafia - Official Game Thread

[LordQuas]

Foxcastle is 100% the Doctor.
He is the Mafia Doctor.
I have him in my net.
If he is town, I will eat a shoe.

why did he claim jailed then, was he jailed? Why didn't scum kill you

[LordQuas]

thank you worce

[Foxcastle]

Also, you've played this game more than enough to know that the scum team almost always orders their NK shortly after the lynch rather than right before the deadline. (That's not definitive, just a pattern I've noticed in the many fewer games I've played than Jamiet.) You also know that not everyone on the scumteam votes, and that it's usually one person making the formal order to the GM with the consent/consensus of the rest of the team.

So your assertion that I got confused because there was some last minute full-team mafia vote that I would have been required to participate in goes against what you should know to be the usual way that mafia NK votes actually happen.

[Jamiet99uk]

Foxcastle is 100% the Doctor.
He is the Mafia Doctor.
I have him in my net.
If he is town, I will eat a shoe.

why did he claim jailed then, was he jailed? Why didn't scum kill you

The question "why didn't scum kill [me]" is not really relevant here surely? If he was town, why didn't they kill me?

[LordQuas]

Foxcastle is 100% the Doctor.
He is the Mafia Doctor.
I have him in my net.
If he is town, I will eat a shoe.

why did he claim jailed then, was he jailed? Why didn't scum kill you

The question "why didn't scum kill [me]" is not really relevant here surely? If he was town, why didn't they kill me?

that's why I think he's SK, but you still aren't answering the question

why even bother claiming he was jailed if he was scum

[Jamiet99uk]

Also, you've played this game more than enough to know that the scum team almost always orders their NK shortly after the lynch rather than right before the deadline. (That's not definitive, just a pattern I've noticed in the many fewer games I've played than Jamiet.) You also know that not everyone on the scumteam votes, and that it's usually one person making the formal order to the GM with the consent/consensus of the rest of the team.

So your assertion that I got confused because there was some last minute full-team mafia vote that I would have been required to participate in goes against what you should know to be the usual way that mafia NK votes actually happen.

Then what was it that made you remember my reads list causing you to almost miss casting a vote?

[Jamiet99uk]

why did he claim jailed then, was he jailed? Why didn't scum kill you

The question "why didn't scum kill [me]" is not really relevant here surely? If he was town, why didn't they kill me?

that's why I think he's SK, but you still aren't answering the question

why even bother claiming he was jailed if he was scum

Because the jailing could still be real if he is scum. They may have been worried he would be tracked, or I would be watched.

[LordQuas]

The question "why didn't scum kill [me]" is not really relevant here surely? If he was town, why didn't they kill me?

that's why I think he's SK, but you still aren't answering the question

why even bother claiming he was jailed if he was scum

Because the jailing could still be real if he is scum. They may have been worried he would be tracked, or I would be watched.

then he would get more town cred for visiting you as a doctor? that still seems wrong

[Jamiet99uk]

that's why I think he's SK, but you still aren't answering the question

why even bother claiming he was jailed if he was scum

Because the jailing could still be real if he is scum. They may have been worried he would be tracked, or I would be watched.

then he would get more town cred for visiting you as a doctor? that still seems wrong

Why do you think scum didn't kill me?
Why kill Flash or Crimson over me?
Isn't the Role Cop a major threat to them?
Yet still, I live.

[Foxcastle]

Also, you've played this game more than enough to know that the scum team almost always orders their NK shortly after the lynch rather than right before the deadline. (That's not definitive, just a pattern I've noticed in the many fewer games I've played than Jamiet.) You also know that not everyone on the scumteam votes, and that it's usually one person making the formal order to the GM with the consent/consensus of the rest of the team.

So your assertion that I got confused because there was some last minute full-team mafia vote that I would have been required to participate in goes against what you should know to be the usual way that mafia NK votes actually happen.

Then what was it that made you remember my reads list causing you to almost miss casting a vote?

I wasn't even thinking of your reads list. I was simply recalling how I almost missed voting for Darg at EOD because I was replying to someone's posts. I just assumed it was your post when you mentioned it, but it was actually Lord Quas at 3 minutes to lynch...

Obviously, I saved no one.

I mean yeah but who did you try to save

Did you not read the setup? Askia doesn't have a N1 save. That's why it's obvious.

... and 2 minutes to lynch...

Did you not read the setup? Askia doesn't have a N1 save. That's why it's obvious.

FUCKIn

no I didn't, I skmimed it last night briefly for the first time

Well, why don't you and CrimsonFox start a bookclub

Before I voted with 1 minute to lynch.

[LordQuas]

Because the jailing could still be real if he is scum. They may have been worried he would be tracked, or I would be watched.

then he would get more town cred for visiting you as a doctor? that still seems wrong

Why do you think scum didn't kill me?
Why kill Flash or Crimson over me?
Isn't the Role Cop a major threat to them?
Yet still, I live.

you aren't answering my questions, you're just dodging them and saying the same thing over again

I've given you my theory several times, you know why I think they didn't kill you

now why do you think scum!foxc is possibly with these NKs, not me, don't answer a question with a question, why do YOU think your line of solving works

[Foxcastle]

The question "why didn't scum kill [me]" is not really relevant here surely? If he was town, why didn't they kill me?

that's why I think he's SK, but you still aren't answering the question

why even bother claiming he was jailed if he was scum

Because the jailing could still be real if he is scum. They may have been worried he would be tracked, or I would be watched.

Why would scum do this? If they're worried about a watcher, they should also be worried about me being watched and the jailer being discovered. It's all WIFOM, but I was also a reasonable target for the watcher, if they thought that, since I was saving you, scum might try to kill me.

[Jamiet99uk]

@Foxcastle:

You weren't even thinking about my reads list, when you responded to my post about how quickly you commented on my reads list....?

Seems legit.

[Jamiet99uk]

then he would get more town cred for visiting you as a doctor? that still seems wrong

Why do you think scum didn't kill me?
Why kill Flash or Crimson over me?
Isn't the Role Cop a major threat to them?
Yet still, I live.

you aren't answering my questions, you're just dodging them and saying the same thing over again

I've given you my theory several times, you know why I think they didn't kill you

now why do you think scum!foxc is possibly with these NKs, not me, don't answer a question with a question, why do YOU think your line of solving works

Honestly? My best guess is that scum guessed Flash was the SK, perhaps?

[LordQuas]

Why do you think scum didn't kill me?
Why kill Flash or Crimson over me?
Isn't the Role Cop a major threat to them?
Yet still, I live.

you aren't answering my questions, you're just dodging them and saying the same thing over again

I've given you my theory several times, you know why I think they didn't kill you

now why do you think scum!foxc is possibly with these NKs, not me, don't answer a question with a question, why do YOU think your line of solving works

Honestly? My best guess is that scum guessed Flash was the SK, perhaps?

and the sk killed a confirmed town? scum doesn't even want to hit SK with the NK as it removes their kill for the night. Still doesn't explain why they would jail foxc instead of you either

[Foxcastle]

@Foxcastle:

You weren't even thinking about my reads list, when you responded to my post about how quickly you commented on my reads list....?

Seems legit.

Yeah, I was answering the question I thought you asked, off the cuff while distracted at work, and in doing so, I made a mistake. I conflated your reads list with EOD, and if you'd asked about your reads list, I'd probably have gone and looked it up before answering, but like I said, I remember almost missing the deadline because I was responding to someone's post, and that's what you asked about, so that's what I replied to.

[Jamiet99uk]

you aren't answering my questions, you're just dodging them and saying the same thing over again

I've given you my theory several times, you know why I think they didn't kill you

now why do you think scum!foxc is possibly with these NKs, not me, don't answer a question with a question, why do YOU think your line of solving works

Honestly? My best guess is that scum guessed Flash was the SK, perhaps?

and the sk killed a confirmed town? scum doesn't even want to hit SK with the NK as it removes their kill for the night. Still doesn't explain why they would jail foxc instead of you either

What was your theory? You post a lot.

[LordQuas]

Honestly? My best guess is that scum guessed Flash was the SK, perhaps?

and the sk killed a confirmed town? scum doesn't even want to hit SK with the NK as it removes their kill for the night. Still doesn't explain why they would jail foxc instead of you either

What was your theory? You post a lot.

fair, Foxc is SK, blind claimed doc to try and save himself d1 (it makes it even more likely in that he might not have known scum got fake claims, I haven't actually gone back to check if he knew this or not but whatever it's not vital). He wouldn't have the opportunity to do something right away, it's a good fake claim honestly

Scum then believes he's doctor, doc happens to not be one of their fake claims or the role they randed, so what else could he be? They try to get him MLed for several days straight as hell, a town doctor ML? That's sick!

But they don't, and the first doctor heal comes around, and oh shit the role cop claimed, but they can't kill him, they kill the next best thing, the mason, instead

Foxc though, he needs a reason why he wasn't able to visit in case of a watcher, and to set up the idea that there's a JK out there somewhere, so he claims jailed

Sick play huh

[Jamiet99uk]

@LordQuas:

That is actually the most plausible explanation I have read, as to why I am somehow still alive.

##VOTE DAMO666

[LordQuas]

@LordQuas:

That is actually the most plausible explanation I have read, as to why I am somehow still alive.

##VOTE DAMO666

why did you vote damo after that then >.>