Mafia 41 - Sid Meiers Civilizaton Mafia - Official Game Thread

[brainbomb]

VOTE TALLY 3.3
http://mafia.peterlund.se/e/web/game_status?g=41

Foxcastle (4) flash2015 dargorygel bozotheclown Jamiet99uk
bozotheclown (2) Nephthys damo666
dargorygel (2) worcej CrimsonFox
Jamiet99uk (1) Foxcastle

Unvote (1) LordQuas

End-votes (0/7)

Non-votes
DemonRHK, Garden Gnome

Foxcastle is scheduled to have an incredible shower experience
25 hours remain

[LordQuas]

Trying to deduce who scum is based on game mechanics is useless? This is looking like a discredit attempt with a backhanded defense of Foxy.

Fox is at almost at half of his post count and a third of his word count at halfway through the day. That's hardly frozen.

Foxcastle posts
D1 - 26
N1 - 4
D2 - 7
N2 - 16
D3 (so far) - 13

his posts d3 were mostly made after I said he had been frozen, and in terms of content literally all he's talked about today is an SK gut feeling on jamie

he tunneled you also for allegedly no reason last night and has now ignored this

his activity has undeniably lessened

[LordQuas]

Trying to deduce who scum is based on game mechanics is useless? This is looking like a discredit attempt with a backhanded defense of Foxy.

Fox is at almost at half of his post count and a third of his word count at halfway through the day. That's hardly frozen.

Foxcastle posts
D1 - 26
N1 - 4
D2 - 7
N2 - 16
D3 (so far) - 13

his posts d3 were mostly made after I said he had been frozen, and in terms of content literally all he's talked about today is an SK gut feeling on jamie

he tunneled you also for allegedly no reason last night and has now ignored this

his activity has undeniably lessened

also I don't see how you're trying to determine scum with mechanics here as much as guessing what roles they may or may not have and then adding an extra layer of complicated randomness with the idea that GG's scum buddy made the shot, then they had GG claim the shot instead of the person who actually made it

like what?

[CrimsonFox]

foxcastle not posting is not an unknown fact

[CrimsonFox]

the only reason i backed off on lynching foxcastle was the sudden resurfacing of flash and darg voting them with popins


also the fact that they claimed a country and not the role.

but these are wifom things i'm trying to sort out.

[DemonRHK]

I walked backed the idea of Gnome, I had forgotten Ike took the shot.

But in what world is trying to determine who the scumteam is based of the actions of the dead scum useless? I would hazard to guess one of the scum was activated by Squigs.

Based on BB's count that is as follows:

Uni Backup can be Quas, Jamie, or damo (Crimson tossed out due to softclear)
Cond. Commute can be as above plus Neph and bozo (Gnome tossed due to gunshot)

[CrimsonFox]

please say the words flash and darg followed by more words

[LordQuas]

I walked backed the idea of Gnome, I had forgotten Ike took the shot.

But in what world is trying to determine who the scumteam is based of the actions of the dead scum useless? I would hazard to guess one of the scum was activated by Squigs.

Based on BB's count that is as follows:

Uni Backup can be Quas, Jamie, or damo (Crimson tossed out due to softclear)
Cond. Commute can be as above plus Neph and bozo (Gnome tossed due to gunshot)

because it's a thing they knew was going to be public, they were in anti-spew

that's like a red peeked wolf saying "oh my partner is x" and then you going "YO THEIR PARTNER HAS TO BE X! THEY SAID SO!!!1"

it's totally possible one of the ppl in that karma list is a mafia role that needs karma, but it's also totally possible that there isn't a mafia role that needs karma, or it's not in that list and they achieved karma elsewhere, or they didn't even get it they're just not worried abt dying ifi they're backup or whatever

do you know what wifom is? do you know what anti-spew is? because I fail to see how you can honestly be pushing this line of """"solving""""

[LordQuas]

foxcastle not posting is not an unknown fact

apparently it is to demon

[DemonRHK]

Yea, and by doing what he did, to the degree he did, has caused nearly EVERYONE to completely dismiss karma completely. One of the best ways to hide is in plain sight.

What is more anti town: Going down a path that might be wrong, or dismissing entire aspects of the game?

What's next? "HAY GUIS 'CAUSE TOWN AND WOLF BOTH MAKE POSTS WE CAN'T LOOK AT POSTS IT COULD TOTALLY BE WIFOM."

As soon as you start dismissing things for some maybe/maybe not bullshit where do you start drawing the line? You're saying you honestly think that (attempting) to vote for lack of activity is a more solid basis than examining the actions of known lynched scum?

[flash2015]

please say the words flash and darg followed by more words

OK then, "flash and darg followed by more words"

[LordQuas]

Yea, and by doing what he did, to the degree he did, has caused nearly EVERYONE to completely dismiss karma completely. One of the best ways to hide is in plain sight.

What is more anti town: Going down a path that might be wrong, or dismissing entire aspects of the game?

What's next? "HAY GUIS 'CAUSE TOWN AND WOLF BOTH MAKE POSTS WE CAN'T LOOK AT POSTS IT COULD TOTALLY BE WIFOM."

As soon as you start dismissing things for some maybe/maybe not bullshit where do you start drawing the line? You're saying you honestly think that (attempting) to vote for lack of activity is a more solid basis than examining the actions of known lynched scum?

you're literally trying to play a crapshoot right now, you're actually just trying to flame and cause discourse

you clearly have no idea how mafia works at all, so I'm just gonna ignore you for now :)

[LordQuas]

please say the words flash and darg followed by more words

OK then, "flash and darg followed by more words"

hey flash you subbed in for an inactive, slightly sus slot and have been even more inactive

any reads?

[DemonRHK]

Jesus, I have you flustered and I haven't even gone full Krellin yet.

I have to give you credit though, you see things that don't make you look good, you keep ignoring them.

I don't know how to play mafia? I ain't the one trying to play solitaire now in a game of hold 'em friend.

[Nephthys]

@Netphys:

Really serious important question about your plan to have the SK target Foxcastle:

What makes you think the SK will do what you want them to do?
Why would it be in the SK's interest to do this?

Slowly catching up so will respond to things as I come across them

- The SK loses if town lose
- Town are very close to losing
- SK therefore (for now) wants to help town
- This either gets scum or confirms doctor. We then are able to telegraph the doc saves or else we just lynch Fox as he would be scum
- This also prevents a likely dead town (7/4 odds) and so gives us more of a chance

[Nephthys]

So this is shaping up to be a super high-information phase, which is great. Perhaps town has a slim hope still? I don't know.

Here are some questions I want answers to:

@Everyone: Do you believe CrimsonFox's claim to be the other Mason?

I have asked this before but people are ignoring it.


@Foxcastle: Why do you (wrongly) suspect that I'm the Serial Killer?

Due to lack of counter claim, yes

[LordQuas]

ND parked a vote on squigs for no reason which makes me think he was trying to distance

wolves (especially ones that aren't as experienced and worry more about appearing too partnered with their teammates) very commonly place an early vote on their teammates as it's a safe spot to them, just something I've noticed (actually I stole this from someone else, maybe even bb?) but it rings true a lot of the time

has anyone analyzed spew from squigs yet?

[CrimsonFox]

is this site always this melodramatic?

[LordQuas]

@Netphys:

Really serious important question about your plan to have the SK target Foxcastle:

What makes you think the SK will do what you want them to do?
Why would it be in the SK's interest to do this?

Slowly catching up so will respond to things as I come across them

- The SK loses if town lose
- Town are very close to losing
- SK therefore (for now) wants to help town
- This either gets scum or confirms doctor. We then are able to telegraph the doc saves or else we just lynch Fox as he would be scum
- This also prevents a likely dead town (7/4 odds) and so gives us more of a chance

technically the SK needs town to lose in order to win, but I get what you mean

it does assure that cfox pmuch always dies today though

[LordQuas]

@Netphys:

Really serious important question about your plan to have the SK target Foxcastle:

What makes you think the SK will do what you want them to do?
Why would it be in the SK's interest to do this?

Slowly catching up so will respond to things as I come across them

- The SK loses if town lose
- Town are very close to losing
- SK therefore (for now) wants to help town
- This either gets scum or confirms doctor. We then are able to telegraph the doc saves or else we just lynch Fox as he would be scum
- This also prevents a likely dead town (7/4 odds) and so gives us more of a chance

technically the SK needs town to lose in order to win, but I get what you mean

it does assure that cfox pmuch always dies tonight though

ebwop