Mafia XXXIV Game Thread - Who Framed Roger Rabbit?

[thamrick]

For the record, people who haven't posted since Ezio's untimely death - ND, Tom, meme

Ugh. Meant to actually say...

Also, Reedeer?

Yep. You're right. I missed adding them

[Foxcastle]

@Foxy - why'd you jet yesterday after Ezio was shot?

It was Friday night and I went out. Catching up now.

[thamrick]

I had a dream Maniac went on a shooting spree and shot Yavuzovic. He flipped scum.

##VOTE Yavuzovic

You've been oddly quiet. Unconvincingly planted on ND for 2 days now. You halfheartedly investigated Mean and left out all the highlights of a case against her. You haven't really presented a case against ND and you said you forgot why you scumread him, but yet you're still on him. You're not convincing me you're town. At all.

[yavuzovic]

Everybody know that if I got the gun, I would shoot whom.

@Yavuzovic - Who would you shoot?

ND

I had a dream Maniac went on a shooting spree and shot Yavuzovic. He flipped scum.

&&VOTE Yavuzovic

You're not convincing me you're town. At all.

Actually true, not Vanilla Townie. At the expense of the attention of the scums, I'm cop - and ND gives crime report. He might be miller, but I don't think so.

[thamrick]

Ughhh. Why would you claim?

You couldn't present a more convincing case against him? The only thing you said was that he potentially bussed Jamiet.

Also, when did you investigate him? N1 or N2?

##UNVOTE

[Maniac]

##Vote ND

##Call Gm - we are told if the dead are millars aren't we.

[thamrick]

Yes. We were told when SuperSteve was Miller

##VOTE ND

I still want an answer on which night you investigated, and who you investigated the other night.

[thamrick]

I really hope he's hooker cause that's about the only way this is worth it

[bo_sox48]

Don't vote ND today. He's not going anywhere. We need info, not a mostly clear cut cop scan lynch.

[Hellenic Riot]

##GM Note: Yes, Millers are revealed upon their deaths.

[bozotheclown]

That explains Yavuzovic's message that he was not going to change his vote for ND at D2 EOD.

Yavuzovic, I am sorry that I did not consider the possibility that you were cop when I called out that post as suspicious.

[Maniac]

Don't vote ND today. He's not going anywhere. We need info, not a mostly clear cut cop scan lynch.

We also have to be careful about hitting our PRs. That's not possible if Yavuz is the COP. If ND is the hooker, we also need him dead.

I can't see any scum motivation in Yavuz's claim.

[thamrick]

I get the reasoning Bo, but I also feel like our PR's have been pretty exposed today.

NURSE DO NOT CLAIM!!! FOR THE LOVE OF GOD!

If we believe Yav, there's a 25% chance ND is hooker (3 scum, 1 miller), which would be HUGE for town. We can protect our PR's that way.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Okay, so first we need ND to show up and claim his role. If he says VT, we have some options

3 roles left that trigger a guilty scan: Hooker, Mafia II, and VT.

If ND is VT, there is a 50% chance he has a bullet proof vest.

So, if we have a gun right now, we should definitely shoot ND. If he has a bullet proof vest, he becomes a town clear and all guilty scans become 100% true.

If we do not have a gun right now, I think we need to lynch ND. Just too much chance that he is Hooker. If we lynch Hooker, our PRs are going to be pretty much unstoppable, with Nurse on Cop or Watcher and Watcher on Cop or Nurse.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I suppose we also want to wait to shoot until everyone has shown up and there has been no Cop CC. But, I'd be shocked if Yavuz is fake claiming here.

I guess one scenario where Yavuz fake claims is if ND is Cop and mafia know that from their investigative role.

@ND, claim a role, friend.

[thamrick]

ND flipping scum would pretty strongly soft clear Balki too. Would be VERY weird for them to have 3 lead wagons at EoD and there not be an effort to get another wagon going.

##CALL GM - would a Stalker scan reveal that a player is the Miller?

[thamrick]

Okay, so first we need ND to show up and claim his role. If he says VT, we have some options

3 roles left that trigger a guilty scan: Hooker, Mafia II, and VT.

If ND is VT, there is a 50% chance he has a bullet proof vest.

So, if we have a gun right now, we should definitely shoot ND. If he has a bullet proof vest, he becomes a town clear and all guilty scans become 100% true.

If we do not have a gun right now, I think we need to lynch ND. Just too much chance that he is Hooker. If we lynch Hooker, our PRs are going to be pretty much unstoppable, with Nurse on Cop or Watcher and Watcher on Cop or Nurse.

Can you explain the 50% chance?

[Balki Bartokomous]

Okay, so first we need ND to show up and claim his role. If he says VT, we have some options

3 roles left that trigger a guilty scan: Hooker, Mafia II, and VT.

If ND is VT, there is a 50% chance he has a bullet proof vest.

So, if we have a gun right now, we should definitely shoot ND. If he has a bullet proof vest, he becomes a town clear and all guilty scans become 100% true.

If we do not have a gun right now, I think we need to lynch ND. Just too much chance that he is Hooker. If we lynch Hooker, our PRs are going to be pretty much unstoppable, with Nurse on Cop or Watcher and Watcher on Cop or Nurse.

Can you explain the 50% chance?

One of the 2 millers has a bullet proof vest, and Mafia Thief died on Day 1.

[Maniac]

@yavuz - who is your innocent scan? I'm guessing if the other scan was also guilty you would have mentioned it

[thamrick]

One of the 2 millers has a bullet proof vest, and Mafia Thief died on Day 1.

No. It says 1 VT or Miller will be randomly given a bulletproof vest.

Also, I assume the vest is revealed upon death? ##CALL GM