Mafia round 93: hot potato! (game thread)

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

will is obvious scum
therefore, will has the rp and is trying to ensure his partner (who he is implying is town) does not die (will dying is less problematic as it removes the rp and kills a town member)
therefore, we must ##vote dreamtrawler today

...did you read what just happened

...
oh
well I'm still right, will simply decided to disclose the rp

actually this didn't happen
@dreamtrawler what were you referring to?

[DreamTrawler]

First scenario (Scum Bo, town SP holder) feels most likely to me just because if I were Mafia I would go for the sure kill over hitting SP.

Second (Town Bo, scum SP holder) could also be likely but is predicated on Bo being everyone's top scumread (that was what I meant by the Mean Girls reference).

Third (Town Bo, town SP holder) seems unlikely but I guess Mafia would have a 1 in 3 chance of guessing who has the SP. But once again, why not kill Bo?

I agree first scenario is more likely. Second scenario I think it's unlikely because Dip is almost 100% town. But if Mafia thought they can't win last night, maybe third scenario is possible. It depends a lot on HP. If most HPs were on scum or if scum are well hidden, then targeting SP is a safe move.

What do you make of Rivera's post here?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Did you have the SP last night, yes or no? Because if you did have it, Rdrivera just scumslipped hard.

No, I did not have the sweet potato last night. I had it n4

[DreamTrawler]

Did you have the SP last night, yes or no? Because if you did have it, Rdrivera just scumslipped hard.

No, I did not have the sweet potato last night. I had it n4

Ah. Here I thought scum just self reported. ##unvote

[DreamTrawler]

Kakarroto is lurking. Kak, did you have the SP last night?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

First scenario (Scum Bo, town SP holder) feels most likely to me just because if I were Mafia I would go for the sure kill over hitting SP.

Second (Town Bo, scum SP holder) could also be likely but is predicated on Bo being everyone's top scumread (that was what I meant by the Mean Girls reference).

Third (Town Bo, town SP holder) seems unlikely but I guess Mafia would have a 1 in 3 chance of guessing who has the SP. But once again, why not kill Bo?

I agree first scenario is more likely. Second scenario I think it's unlikely because Dip is almost 100% town. But if Mafia thought they can't win last night, maybe third scenario is possible. It depends a lot on HP. If most HPs were on scum or if scum are well hidden, then targeting SP is a safe move.

What do you make of Rivera's post here?

WBTMODISPBIRRIQBDLB

[DreamTrawler]

Did you have the SP last night, yes or no? Because if you did have it, Rdrivera just scumslipped hard.

No, I did not have the sweet potato last night. I had it n4

Btw this makes me even more sure that either Bo or the SP holder is scum

[Kakarroto]

well, now I fear that mafia got their hands on the rotten potato. Dream and I both sent our hot potatoes to RD and bo, respectively, so chances are they are now in possession of it after sending it to Will?

Hmm. RD said they will send it to Dream, if I'm not mistaken, so maybe we should vote RD, but maybe it was a big lie. If they knew the rotten potato was still in the game, they might've switched their throw targets, to get a hold onto it.

If we vote out the one who has the rotten potato, we would be pretty much screwed, but maybe I'm overthinking it. Maybe RD just threw it to Dream like he said. I dunno.

Yeah, could be they didn't know that the rotten potato was still in the game, so they probably wouldn't have any plan for something like that. So in that case RD would most likely still throw to Dream, and thus not have the rotten potato.

So ##vote RD

a town is never this sure about another player being town
especially at f5
##vote kakarroto

you just have to look at last game, where I successfully identified Dream as town and pushed Will who was mafia. Sadly, Dream didn't believe me in the end, and I was again misvoted as often, even when I was correct.

Dream is practically the same like last game, and I have seen nothing from him that makes me think he is mafia.

You have shown your towniness from the start, and with the whole exchange with bozo I'm convinced you are town too.

and from the three others, I'm pretty sure that Will can't be mafia with bo, and bo is quite more sus than Will, and either way, RD just has to be the other partner.

On top of that, I believe that bo got the rotten potato by throwing his hot potato to Will, while RD probably sent it to Dream as he said before.

So RD is just the safest option to vote for today. If you all want bo instead, he should be mafia too, but I think he has the rotten potato and will take one of us with him, so it's better to vote RD, no?

Or is there something I'm missing?

[Kakarroto]

anyways I loudly demand everyone reveals full d5 and n5 hp info
the reason being that someone has thrown me a hot potato
although I'm not towncleared, basically nobody scumreads me at this point
I therefore conclude that a scum threw me a potato on suspicion I might still have the RP

I had a hot potato at D5, which I threw to bo. I didn't have a hot potato on N5

[Kakarroto]

well, now I fear that mafia got their hands on the rotten potato. Dream and I both sent our hot potatoes to RD and bo, respectively, so chances are they are now in possession of it after sending it to Will?

Hmm. RD said they will send it to Dream, if I'm not mistaken, so maybe we should vote RD, but maybe it was a big lie. If they knew the rotten potato was still in the game, they might've switched their throw targets, to get a hold onto it.

If we vote out the one who has the rotten potato, we would be pretty much screwed, but maybe I'm overthinking it. Maybe RD just threw it to Dream like he said. I dunno.

Yeah, could be they didn't know that the rotten potato was still in the game, so they probably wouldn't have any plan for something like that. So in that case RD would most likely still throw to Dream, and thus not have the rotten potato.

So ##vote RD

You are not paying attention and you are probably scum. I had the RP N4 and D5.

I'm talking about the current situation. I know bo had a hot potato from me last night. I know you had a hot potato from Dream last night. You also said you send it back to Dream, and I think you wouldn't lie about that as either alignment, so that makes bo the most likely to have sent to Will to get the rotten potato, I think

it's like the second day where a special potato saves bo's live, or if we decide to vote him out, that he takes one with us. So I think the better way to solve that is to get the potato back today if Will or dream throw their potato to bo. Or dip said he also got a hot potato today? So maybe dip should do that and we vote bo out tomorrow

[Kakarroto]

well, now I fear that mafia got their hands on the rotten potato. Dream and I both sent our hot potatoes to RD and bo, respectively, so chances are they are now in possession of it after sending it to Will?

Hmm. RD said they will send it to Dream, if I'm not mistaken, so maybe we should vote RD, but maybe it was a big lie. If they knew the rotten potato was still in the game, they might've switched their throw targets, to get a hold onto it.

If we vote out the one who has the rotten potato, we would be pretty much screwed, but maybe I'm overthinking it. Maybe RD just threw it to Dream like he said. I dunno.

Yeah, could be they didn't know that the rotten potato was still in the game, so they probably wouldn't have any plan for something like that. So in that case RD would most likely still throw to Dream, and thus not have the rotten potato.

So ##vote RD

a town is never this sure about another player being town
especially at f5
##vote kakarroto

Totally aprove this vote. Also, zero thought in this post, only an agenda to miskill the easiest wagon.

I've given my thoughts why you are the most likely mafia, probably together with bo, maybe with Will but I doubt that. Dream and dip have a lot going for them being town, both of their behaviour is like their town play, or like the quarrel with bozo, Dream being one of the saving, in fact the starting of the saving, vote for when we got away miskilling me onto Paste

that comment of yours feels like you don't even read what I post

[Kakarroto]

Kakarroto is lurking. Kak, did you have the SP last night?

I'm just catching up. I didn't have the sweet potato last night, nor before that

[DreamTrawler]

Kakarroto is lurking. Kak, did you have the SP last night?

I'm just catching up. I didn't have the sweet potato last night, nor before that

So PoE Bo threw it to Rivera?? Or someone is lying for some inane reason

[Kakarroto]

Kakarroto is lurking. Kak, did you have the SP last night?

I'm just catching up. I didn't have the sweet potato last night, nor before that

So PoE Bo threw it to Rivera?? Or someone is lying for some inane reason

the sweet potato? I have no idea, but if bo threw to RD then they can't be mafia together

[DreamTrawler]

Yeah, but if Bo threw it to Rdrivera than one of them is definitely Mafia, the question is which one.

[Kakarroto]

well, I think will can't be mafia with bo, so from the rest that just leaves RD. I don't think you nor dip is mafia, and I am sure aren't either

so if bo threw to RD, then the team has to be RD and will

[DreamTrawler]

well, I think will can't be mafia with bo, so from the rest that just leaves RD. I don't think you nor dip is mafia, and I am sure aren't either

so if bo threw to RD, then the team has to be RD and will

Why do you think Will can't be mafia with Bo?

[Kakarroto]

I think how they reacted to each other it's just not how mafia would act. Or at least I wouldn't have seen any maf-theater close to this. Maybe I'm wrong, but the way they treat each other unpairs them for me.

It's like the way Bunny and you were last game. It's like there isn't a layer beyond in their interactions

[Kakarroto]

or do you think I make a mistake there? Is there a way those two put up such an act for that long and are paired together?

[DreamTrawler]

I just think at the stage we're at we can't rule out pairings based on vibes