Mafia round 93: hot potato! (game thread)

[DreamTrawler]

Why did you pass it to Dream?

I thought we need to build another pairs so won't pass to mimi, you and Bozo. I also don't want to gave to a lurker. D&W faking some many claims looks notcreliable. So I was between Dream and Will, decided to toss to Dream because he isn't likely to be the NK and didn't have a HP.

This logic is highly suspicious. You tossed it to me because I was unlikely to be the nightkill? Did you forget the sweet potato has another use beyond generating clears? To me it looks like you got it safely out of the way to nightkill Mimi. And you gave it to one of the most highly suspected townies (me) so that I could be easily daykilled.

You haven't disclosed your townreads, but I'm wondering why you didn't keep the potato within the chain of people that already had it. Both to save them from nightkill and to self clear.

Why didn't you throw it to Mimi, even though she was a likely target for nightkill? "Mimi gave it to me so I wanted to generate new info" Ok sure

Why didn't you throw it to Bozo? Then voting Bozo on D4 would possibly clear 3 people right? "Because I thought Bozo was Mafia" Or because you knew Bozo was Mafia? Anyway, good thing you didn't because he's dead now.

Why didn't you throw it to Bunny? ??? I don't have a rebuttal for you here so please write your own.

[yavuzovic]

Dream is making sense ##unvote

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I thought we need to build another pairs so won't pass to mimi, you and Bozo. I also don't want to gave to a lurker. D&W faking some many claims looks notcreliable. So I was between Dream and Will, decided to toss to Dream because he isn't likely to be the NK and didn't have a HP.

This logic is highly suspicious. You tossed it to me because I was unlikely to be the nightkill? Did you forget the sweet potato has another use beyond generating clears? To me it looks like you got it safely out of the way to nightkill Mimi. And you gave it to one of the most highly suspected townies (me) so that I could be easily daykilled.

You haven't disclosed your townreads, but I'm wondering why you didn't keep the potato within the chain of people that already had it. Both to save them from nightkill and to self clear.

Why didn't you throw it to Mimi, even though she was a likely target for nightkill? "Mimi gave it to me so I wanted to generate new info" Ok sure

Why didn't you throw it to Bozo? Then voting Bozo on D4 would possibly clear 3 people right? "Because I thought Bozo was Mafia" Or because you knew Bozo was Mafia? Anyway, good thing you didn't because he's dead now.

Why didn't you throw it to Bunny? ??? I don't have a rebuttal for you here so please write your own.

While I disagree with the notion that rdr is scum, this seems a bit townie, just based on the conviction. Seems Dream truly belives this

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

[yavuzovic]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Can you summarize me the case against Control V? For some reason I don't remember much interaction with him.

[BunnyGo]

Dream is making sense ##unvote

Not to me....

But I am starting to wonder if he's making sense to himself as town. Sometimes things that I think are suuuuper scummy, are possible towny.

@Dream: Of the triple mimi-Bunny-bozo (while we were all 3 alive) who was your biggest townlean, and who your biggest scumlean?

[Chaqa]

I've mostly been throwing potatoes to people I think are not getting the scrutiny they deserve.

My game view is a little messed up because I had Bozo as my strongest town read.

I feel like Kak is the most towny by VCA from Day 3, looks like Bozo may have been saved. Bozo's flip also makes Will look better.

I think I like ##Vote yavu

[Control V]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Are we still doing this?

[DreamTrawler]

Dream is making sense ##unvote

Not to me....

But I am starting to wonder if he's making sense to himself as town. Sometimes things that I think are suuuuper scummy, are possible towny.

@Dream: Of the triple mimi-Bunny-bozo (while we were all 3 alive) who was your biggest townlean, and who your biggest scumlean?

I mean it’s kind of obvious to say this now but Mimi was my biggest townlean and Bozo my biggest scumlean. But I was generally considering all 3 of you as town.

[Control V]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Are we still doing this?

I Don't have a link to my most recent game anymore and don't know where to find one.

Can I interest you in killing Kaka/Chaqa, hopefully disabling the investigative powers of the sweet potato and allowing me to clutch out a win in endgame if I don't explode?

[DreamTrawler]

Well you and Bozo could be scumpair then. In fact the only way Bunny could know his statement is true is it he himself is scum. Could this be the biggest scumslip of all time?

still impossible

i passed the sp to bozo, so we can't both be scum. bozo passed the sp to bunny, so they can't both be scum. bunny passed the sp back to me, so we can't both be scum

I think this pattern of making a circle with the SP is interesting because of exactly this effect, but at some point it needs to move to others players to get more info. But then there is a risk of passing to a scumbo. Hard call.

Interesting post given he was holding the SP at the time. Not necessarily scummy, but interesting.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Can you summarize me the case against Control V? For some reason I don't remember much interaction with him.

He has failed to sufficiently solve imo and looks pretty bad based on the flips and his voting history

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Are we still doing this?

I’ve seen nothing since the last time I scumread you that would make me think otherwise

If you are town I’m hoping you step up and be towny

[Control V]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Can you summarize me the case against Control V? For some reason I don't remember much interaction with him.

He has failed to sufficiently solve imo and looks pretty bad based on the flips and his voting history

I Thought it was not explaining myself well.

[Control V]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Are we still doing this?

I’ve seen nothing since the last time I scumread you that would make me think otherwise

If you are town I’m hoping you step up and be towny

I Don't think that'll happen you'll have to find me imo.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Can you summarize me the case against Control V? For some reason I don't remember much interaction with him.

He has failed to sufficiently solve imo and looks pretty bad based on the flips and his voting history

I Thought it was not explaining myself well.

Yeah that falls under the umbrella of not solving well

[DreamTrawler]

@Control V Day 1 and 2 you were hard scumreading me and leading the case against me but with (IMO) flimsy evidence. Now I'm a leading wagon but you seem to be townreading me even though by my own admission I look sus rn. Why?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Are we still doing this?

I’ve seen nothing since the last time I scumread you that would make me think otherwise

If you are town I’m hoping you step up and be towny

I Don't think that'll happen you'll have to find me imo.

Yes, and if I am wrong I do apologize, but I think others have been townier and you are poe due to your unfortunate game history so far

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

what theres new emojis! How did i not know this

[yavuzovic]

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Are we still doing this?

I Don't have a link to my most recent game anymore and don't know where to find one.

Can I interest you in killing Kaka/Chaqa, hopefully disabling the investigative powers of the sweet potato and allowing me to clutch out a win in endgame if I don't explode?

I think bozo's flip makes Kaka looks good for now and Chaqa is ... he was lurky earlier but now I see his post, I must read better. I will also consider you.

@Yavu, would you be willing to vote Control?

Can you summarize me the case against Control V? For some reason I don't remember much interaction with him.

He has failed to sufficiently solve imo and looks pretty bad based on the flips and his voting history

I mean, I also failed to sufficiently solve yesterday because I was so convinced to kill damo, and I would probably townread bozo if potato didn't explode. Especially that we don't have power roles, it is pretty normal to have hard time solving the game. But the vote history is a different story. I indeed didn't like his votes. Especially bringing damo to compete against bozo yesterday.
Alright, let's ##vote Control V. And hear his defense.