Mafia round 93: hot potato! (game thread)

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

But no players are given special roles so that's not a thing, so fuck it who cares

I’m picturing bo making a post about PRs, then remembering to check the rules. Then posting this. I don’t remember him well enough to say what this indicates, but seems slightly scummy to me in a vacuum.

Interesting. I didnt really think of it this way

Theres potential that Bo wanted to make a post trying to seem helpful, then realized the post he was making was nonsensical, then backtracked

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Bunny BoSox team I can feel it in my potatoey bones

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Hello, Fellow Potatoes.

nope
all caps jamie is never a good sign

But it's not all caps... what an odd thing to say...

##VOTE DiplomacyandWarfare

@Dip why is Jamie using capital letters a bad sign?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

because we have prs

Fake dumbslip

Or obvious sarcasm.

*Puts on braincap* This is the actual bus. Bunny and D&W are scum.

Undecided on the Dip. But I agree on Bunny

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

bus

agreed
##vote mimi

Disagree

@Dip why

it reads as a non-genuine reaction
like, when has bunny ever said 'Damn it'?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Fake dumbslip

Or obvious sarcasm.

*Puts on braincap* This is the actual bus. Bunny and D&W are scum.

Nah, Jamie’s the scum. He’s frustrated D&W called him on something that is correct he’s scum but was factually incorrect.

That is not true, If someone got sus at me for capitalizing my letters I’d be pissed as either alignment

@Bunny can you say specifically why you believe it? And what its referring to cuz I’m assuming its about the capital letters thing but wanna make sure

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Fake dumbslip

Or obvious sarcasm.

*Puts on braincap* This is the actual bus. Bunny and D&W are scum.

Undecided on the Dip. But I agree on Bunny

I would be happy to "bus" bunny if there was a wagon there

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

agreed
##vote mimi

Disagree

@Dip why

it reads as a non-genuine reaction
like, when has bunny ever said 'Damn it'?

Ok, but if you find Bunny suspicious in this interaction and think that Bunny is bussing, why would you not vote Bunny?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Or obvious sarcasm.

*Puts on braincap* This is the actual bus. Bunny and D&W are scum.

Undecided on the Dip. But I agree on Bunny

I would be happy to "bus" bunny if there was a wagon there

Why didn’t you initially when you saw something sus of Bunny?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Or obvious sarcasm.

*Puts on braincap* This is the actual bus. Bunny and D&W are scum.

Nah, Jamie’s the scum. He’s frustrated D&W called him on something that is correct he’s scum but was factually incorrect.

That is not true, If someone got sus at me for capitalizing my letters I’d be pissed as either alignment

@Bunny can you say specifically why you believe it? And what its referring to cuz I’m assuming its about the capital letters thing but wanna make sure

reminder that jamie also:
(a) accused me of being scum for suggesting a team solve of four players (including jamie), then mentioning jamie might also be paired with someone else outside that gamesolve
(b) quoted my post, then edited it to make my argument seem worse

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Undecided on the Dip. But I agree on Bunny

I would be happy to "bus" bunny if there was a wagon there

Why didn’t you initially when you saw something sus of Bunny?

I was more sus of miminena (I voted miminena around this time)

[Jamiet99uk]

No.
Having suggested that a certain group of players might be on your team does not invalidate an argument that another group of players might be on your team.
This is a bad argument and is scum-indicative.
No town player gets this defensive about a suggestion regarding who they might be paired with.

You did it in the SAME post. You posited a four-person scum team, with me in it, and then you explained your logic that I was scum based on me being scum partners with SOMEONE ELSE.

You invalidated your own case.

No.
I made multiple cases, noting that you had multiple likely scum partners. Because of this, I determined the likelihood that you were scum was high and decided to vote for you.
No town player gets this defensive, therefore you are not town.

I am defending myself perfectly reasonably against an absolute steaming pile of bullshit that you are coming out with. It is NOT scummy to refuse false accusations. It is NOT scummy to reply to cases being made against me which are wrong and stupid.

Now you are saying that you had "multiple" cases on me, as if your own logic somehow doesn't have to be consistent?

You cannot make multiple contradictory statements and claim that doing so proves you are more likely to be right. Have you been to fucking school for one day of your dumb life?

If this was your first game I would give you a pass for "town Jamie wouldn't get this defensive" but I KNOW you have played MULTIPLE games on this site, and at least a few with me, so that's bullshit.

What do you expect a town player to do? Roll over and just say "oh well, you're wrong about me, I am kinda town after all, but it would be great if I died, so that's all just fine!"

Piss off.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Dream Traveler feels a bit too restrained.

Bo Sox's #33 might be scummy as it feels very real but should be a continuation of a joke. Or might be nothing?

Bunny feels very towny but not technically 100% sure rn.

Restrained how? This is only my second game and I still haven’t really gotten up to scratch on what tells people have in the early game. I have 1-3 suspects but don’t feel strongly enough to vote yet.

Who?

Also slightly towny post

[Jamiet99uk]

I will early gamesolve miminena-food-bunny-jamie
since mimi is bussing foodcoats and will move if that wagon picks up steam
##vote jamie who is using capital letters, made reference to bozo, and is clearly scum with damo.

^ This is what you logic boils down to. It is fake logic.

BREAKING NEWS:
Jamie is now blatantly editing quotes, literally making it appear that I said things that I did not, and absolutely nobody cares because everyone is either busy coasting or busy shitposting
except ghug, who made the right vote for the wrong reason

I DREW ATTENTION TO THE FACT THAT I HAD AMENDED IT, FOR FUCK'S SAKE. I WAS SUMMARISING MY VIEW OF YOUR DUMBASS ARGUMENT.

If you are legitimately this dense you should not play this game again.

[Jamiet99uk]

I will pre-emptively predict that bunny is going to vote me, as bunny and jamie are both scum
perhaps bunny will see this message and decide not to add more maf votes onto the wagon on me, as that will get them both found later
perhaps not
¯\_(ツ)_/¯

I am not scum.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I would be happy to "bus" bunny if there was a wagon there

Why didn’t you initially when you saw something sus of Bunny?

I was more sus of miminena (I voted miminena around this time)

Why did you vote mimi initially?

[Jamiet99uk]

I have muted Diplomacy&Warfare for the next few hours because I now believe he is trying to antagonise me on purpose which I think is in very poor taste.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

You did it in the SAME post. You posited a four-person scum team, with me in it, and then you explained your logic that I was scum based on me being scum partners with SOMEONE ELSE.

You invalidated your own case.

No.
I made multiple cases, noting that you had multiple likely scum partners. Because of this, I determined the likelihood that you were scum was high and decided to vote for you.
No town player gets this defensive, therefore you are not town.

I am defending myself perfectly reasonably against an absolute steaming pile of bullshit that you are coming out with. It is NOT scummy to refuse false accusations. It is NOT scummy to reply to cases being made against me which are wrong and stupid.

Now you are saying that you had "multiple" cases on me, as if your own logic somehow doesn't have to be consistent?

You cannot make multiple contradictory statements and claim that doing so proves you are more likely to be right. Have you been to fucking school for one day of your dumb life?

If this was your first game I would give you a pass for "town Jamie wouldn't get this defensive" but I KNOW you have played MULTIPLE games on this site, and at least a few with me, so that's bullshit.

What do you expect a town player to do? Roll over and just say "oh well, you're wrong about me, I am kinda town after all, but it would be great if I died, so that's all just fine!"

Piss off.

I didn't say that my multiple cases all had to be right. I simply said that having multiple cases is not scum indicative.
You're right, you do get defensive as town, but not this defensive.
I expect a town player to, among other things, not claim that I said things that I did not, in fact, say.

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

I have muted Diplomacy&Warfare for the next few hours because I now believe he is trying to antagonise me on purpose which I think is in very poor taste.

antagonizing people on purpose is something that jamie does do as scum, so this would be an odd stance for jamie to make.
unless, of course, jamie was lying. Totally ridiculous of me to suggest, of course.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I will early gamesolve miminena-food-bunny-jamie
since mimi is bussing foodcoats and will move if that wagon picks up steam
##vote jamie
for
(a) having all starting words capitalized, which reads as scum trying to buddy everyone (don't ask)
(b) shitposting about 'robot detective' and counting potatoes
(c) complaining unnecessarily about ghug's vote
(d) typed 'dam0' which reads as a soft to damo of having 0 potatoes between scum players

Theres actually 0% chance this is real so @Dip which parts of this post are legit? The teamsolve? Cuz unironically my gut is giving me that same team minus Jamie plus Bo