MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[worcej]

Whoops, totally read the timeline on the bot wrong lol... that was 12 minutes left of D1

[Vecna]

its also interesting to me that ghug hasnt mentioned ND in a long time it feels like.

can hardly blame him, since I also sorta forgot he was in the game untill bb just voted him just now.

I mentioned ND less than 24 hours ago.

Read the fucking game, Vecna. If you're town you're playing like garbage.

I’m starting to feel like Vecna is 3P. I’m not sure if this has a foundation in the mechanics, though.

so youre agreeing with ghug that the energy between him and ND hasnt drastically changed?

The only reminder that ND was in this game was from the occasional ghug attack.

[bozotheclown]

i feel like it should be bozo. 1) demon wanted him and died for it, 2) bozo has read all the 3p set up and noted the PR claim thing and then demon died, and while its sad to scum read this, it is kind of a thing.

Besides that, im back to ghug, but i think he is much more likely mafia than 3p given his fake claim would be super stupid as 3p

You think Demon died for his bozo read and not his PR claim?

No, i just now know demon's read was real and from a towny. I am kind of on board to kill will but I think he's mafia if anything. Bozo feels more 3p to me. I don't see ghug claiming priest as 3p. Idk, ghug posts today seem omega town and the more I process the priest claim, the more I feel it comes from a towny place. ##vote bozo

What specifically makes me feel like 3P to you?

[bozotheclown]

Would ND really produce trumpian day 1 dialogues as a witch or warlock. Also some irony if yes.

But no, its probably just ghug we need to kill today.

##vote ghug

Do you think Ghug is 3p? I’m a bit confused as to why we need to kill the 3p here because a witch had no chance to hinder red’s ability as bg

Are you not aware that a witch wins when all PRs are eliminated?

[foodcoats]

Another tidbit. ND apparently equally scumread RHK and Will and when he voted yesterday those wagons were tied and he put RHK up. He did not explain why RHK and not Will at the time. And if you go back further in time you see he was always focused on RHK or Will and actually at one point said he preferred Will. And the problem with him moving to RHK for getting off Dip’s wagon D1 is that the case that Will’s movement was stranger is so much stronger, and ND is so highly analytical, that I think if he was town, he would ALWAYS see that and would prefer to vote for Will over RHK every time.

If Will flips scum, ND is a feasible partner because of that play. He was too hyper analytical to not miss that Demon’s shift off Dip was random whereas Will’s was calculated. It’s a great and classic hedge that he keeps saying “will or rhk” and then lands on rhk when it really matters. Plus it fits with my theory Dip was bus-reading ND.

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT

JustAGuyNamedWill (5) - foodcoats, bozotheclown, ghug, worcej, brainbomb*
Vecna (1) - JustAGuyNamedWill
bozotheclown (1) - SpiritoftheRadio

WILL has got the most votes.

A little over half the day remains.

[Vecna]

##vote brainbomb

[brainbomb]

Also ##unend

I feel like no one is willing to consider my actual strong scumreads here so and all were doing is just sitting around waiting to inevitably kill will. While I dont hate it I do sort of think ghug is most likely to be a hit here.

[brainbomb]

Food and worcej are basically worshipping ghug at this point. Spirit is the only one interested in it, ND is never talking and I dont even remember any interactions between bozo and ghug since day 1. Will has been getting pushed fairly consistently by him and then theres been some chastising of vecna’s skill
Level but other than that I havent seen anyone really do what it takes to actually challenge a scum ghug

[brainbomb]

When hes evil it takes an actual fucking army with machine guns to bring that bear down

[ghug]

Also ##unend

I feel like no one is willing to consider my actual strong scumreads here so and all were doing is just sitting around waiting to inevitably kill will. While I dont hate it I do sort of think ghug is most likely to be a hit here.

But I'm the Priest.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

Another tidbit. ND apparently equally scumread RHK and Will and when he voted yesterday those wagons were tied and he put RHK up. He did not explain why RHK and not Will at the time. And if you go back further in time you see he was always focused on RHK or Will and actually at one point said he preferred Will. And the problem with him moving to RHK for getting off Dip’s wagon D1 is that the case that Will’s movement was stranger is so much stronger, and ND is so highly analytical, that I think if he was town, he would ALWAYS see that and would prefer to vote for Will over RHK every time.

If Will flips scum, ND is a feasible partner because of that play. He was too hyper analytical to not miss that Demon’s shift off Dip was random whereas Will’s was calculated. It’s a great and classic hedge that he keeps saying “will or rhk” and then lands on rhk when it really matters. Plus it fits with my theory Dip was bus-reading ND.

this is a good point, I've also personally witnessed ND death tunnel on Will and never give up ever in 2 different games. One was scum will and one was town will I think, but ND tunnelled on him regardless, seems odd he'd ease up and go demon with his history

[ghug]

When hes evil it takes an actual fucking army with machine guns to bring that bear down

This is also true when I'm good though. I think there's usually more momentum to kill me as scum than there is as town.

Is there someone you prefer to Will if I'm off the table? I am starting to question if we should be killing the 3P here but I don't know how to hunt that.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

When hes evil it takes an actual fucking army with machine guns to bring that bear down

its been 3 days pushing ghug mostly... im tired boss

[SpiritoftheRadio]

##vote will
##end

[brainbomb]

Also ##unend

I feel like no one is willing to consider my actual strong scumreads here so and all were doing is just sitting around waiting to inevitably kill will. While I dont hate it I do sort of think ghug is most likely to be a hit here.

But I'm the Priest.

[brainbomb]

When hes evil it takes an actual fucking army with machine guns to bring that bear down

This is also true when I'm good though. I think there's usually more momentum to kill me as scum than there is as town.

Is there someone you prefer to Will if I'm off the table? I am starting to question if we should be killing the 3P here but I don't know how to hunt that.

Id be fine killing ND as he has good odds to be some
Evil role or a person who isnt even hardly playing at this point.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

You think Demon died for his bozo read and not his PR claim?

No, i just now know demon's read was real and from a towny. I am kind of on board to kill will but I think he's mafia if anything. Bozo feels more 3p to me. I don't see ghug claiming priest as 3p. Idk, ghug posts today seem omega town and the more I process the priest claim, the more I feel it comes from a towny place. ##vote bozo

What specifically makes me feel like 3P to you?

you're just hitting the right balance of being helpful, not controversial, and mostly in the background. That is the way you act normally, but you are usually hard to read and your always vibe mostly fits a 3p player in a vacuum

[ghug]

##vote will
##end

Why is everyone fucking hammering?

[ghug]

Like is Spirit just the warlock? Did scum figure this out days ago and try to tell us?