MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[SpiritoftheRadio]

I normally write excruciatingly long and somewhat thorough but not majorly right reads posts. The amount of work I need to do currently kind of makes that unjustifiable and im also realizing the game is more fun when I don't have to write out and justify everything. Plus it gives people more ammo to call you on having a change of heart or scum read you off of making a tiny mistake (see food scum reading me for a day and a half after forgetting he posted and calling him a non-poster in a reads list on D1).

#We're not going back

[brainbomb]

##vote ghug

[Jamiet99uk]

VOTE COUNT 4.1

JustAGuyNamedWill (2) - worcej, ND
ND (2) - foodcoats, bozotheclown
ghug (2) - SpiritoftheRadio, brainbomb
brainbomb (1) - ghug

NOBODY is set to be revoked.

Just under 27 hours are left in the day.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE GHUG

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Worcej needs to do more

He was towny after day 1 and has done jack since, so he needs to step it up in order to rejoin my towns

[ND]

if me being eliminated helps solve the game then I'm all for it.

I still think the best way to get at least one of Dip&War's team members is through D1. People that Dip&War interacted with, who were voting him and found a reason to vote for Worcej.

Highest probability of that is: RHK/Will, Brainbomb, Ghug.
-I view RHK/Will as higher possibilities than Brain/Ghug mainly because of gut reads.

But, yeah, totally down for it. Vote me if you think it helps.

[ND]

Worcej is about the closest to a soft clear that we are going to get. Guy literally made himself a wagon with 10 minutes left.

I know my alignment (town) so there was no reason whatsoever for him to do that.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

if me being eliminated helps solve the game then I'm all for it.

I still think the best way to get at least one of Dip&War's team members is through D1. People that Dip&War interacted with, who were voting him and found a reason to vote for Worcej.

Highest probability of that is: RHK/Will, Brainbomb, Ghug.
-I view RHK/Will as higher possibilities than Brain/Ghug mainly because of gut reads.

But, yeah, totally down for it. Vote me if you think it helps.

you did catch my analysis that there is a good chance king of pirates scanned rhk and got negative right?

[foodcoats]

if me being eliminated helps solve the game then I'm all for it.

I still think the best way to get at least one of Dip&War's team members is through D1. People that Dip&War interacted with, who were voting him and found a reason to vote for Worcej.

Highest probability of that is: RHK/Will, Brainbomb, Ghug.
-I view RHK/Will as higher possibilities than Brain/Ghug mainly because of gut reads.

But, yeah, totally down for it. Vote me if you think it helps.

you did catch my analysis that there is a good chance king of pirates scanned rhk and got negative right?

Someone has to be sent to do the NK. I assume that if RHK was scum but someone else did the kill RHK would not scan for blood.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Worcej is about the closest to a soft clear that we are going to get. Guy literally made himself a wagon with 10 minutes left.

I know my alignment (town) so there was no reason whatsoever for him to do that.

Thats what I thought towards SOD2/N1 time period

However a near-clear town worcej would use his towncred to actively solve and try and figure out the gamestate. He’s barely been doing any of that, I see minimal solving from him

In any other scenario other than this, he would be a scumread. But bc of D1 stuff, he is very middle of the road

[SpiritoftheRadio]

if me being eliminated helps solve the game then I'm all for it.

I still think the best way to get at least one of Dip&War's team members is through D1. People that Dip&War interacted with, who were voting him and found a reason to vote for Worcej.

Highest probability of that is: RHK/Will, Brainbomb, Ghug.
-I view RHK/Will as higher possibilities than Brain/Ghug mainly because of gut reads.

But, yeah, totally down for it. Vote me if you think it helps.

you did catch my analysis that there is a good chance king of pirates scanned rhk and got negative right?

Someone has to be sent to do the NK. I assume that if RHK was scum but someone else did the kill RHK would not scan for blood.

Role text:
Bloodhound - Each night, you may investigate a player. If at *any* time in the game, they have participated in a kill, you will detect the scent of BLOOD on them.

Note: The executioner's action causes them to carry the scent of blood. Simply being on the wagon of whoever is daykilled does not.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I assumed participating in a kill means the whole mafia team would register smelling of blood after N1

##call GM

Does only the mafia sent to do the kill smell of blood or does the whole mafia team after the first kill is done?

[Jamiet99uk]

you did catch my analysis that there is a good chance king of pirates scanned rhk and got negative right?

Someone has to be sent to do the NK. I assume that if RHK was scum but someone else did the kill RHK would not scan for blood.

Role text:
Bloodhound - Each night, you may investigate a player. If at *any* time in the game, they have participated in a kill, you will detect the scent of BLOOD on them.

Note: The executioner's action causes them to carry the scent of blood. Simply being on the wagon of whoever is daykilled does not.
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I assumed participating in a kill means the whole mafia team would register smelling of blood after N1

##call GM

Does only the mafia sent to do the kill smell of blood or does the whole mafia team after the first kill is done?

Only the member of the Mafia that actually performed the kill.

It has already been clarified that *voting* for a kill does not make you tainted with blood.

Likewise, it is standard interpretation on WebDip that the Mafia NK selection is a form of vote.

If all of the Mafia were tainted with blood as a result of the N1 kill, that would make a Bloodhound totally overpowered.

Is that clear?

[foodcoats]

Spirit conf not scum lol.

Or great fakeslip.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

Spirit conf not scum lol.

Or great fakeslip.

ill take the muddy soft clear from demon and wear it with pride

[brainbomb]

Spirit was probably never scum when he made that biggie smalls comment anyway

[SpiritoftheRadio]

Spirit was probably never scum when he made that biggie smalls comment anyway

if you go know, now you know.... fella

[SpiritoftheRadio]

lol i cant even biggie for a second

[ND]

I am going to go back tonight and catch up on a few things I missed @spirit

[foodcoats]

##VOTE brain

Ghug what’s your reason for voting brain?

[foodcoats]

Spirit 3p theory intensifies

I re-read Spirit last (real life) night. I was hoping to think he was scum but that doesn’t feel right. One of the challenges to my reading is OMGUS towards him and the other is I lack meta… but basically Spirit hasn’t really been reading since N2 and his analysis is totally stuck. He has claimed he has a tunnelling problem so that could be it. But he has a very limited locus of attention and analysis… There are swaths of players and events he doesn’t pay any attention to. He gets wrapped up in analyzing nightkills and third party tinfoil. On the one hand I don’t see clear scum indications for him but… I mean, fundamentally you could level the same argument against him as how Dip was caught… Spirit is not solving and has thrown some random unjustified crap at the wall.

I think I’d love to hear an analysis of Spirit from someone who isn’t tilted on him and who has played him before.

I really don’t think spirit is mafia, if anything spirit is 3p

What makes you think Spirit is not mafia?