MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[brainbomb]

Will I still think the way he pushed dip is true to form and is not hellbussing. It doesnt make sense that will would have gone here with so
Many options. He was a primary driver of this wagon D1.

[bozotheclown]

Based on my thinking above,

##VOTE ND

It does seem like D&W may have been distance voting ND knowing that he (D&W) was at risk of being the DK:

Screw it. I want more info.
##vote ND

The top wagon is 2 votes and nobody has voted me today, which is making me anxious because I'm likely going to end up flashwagoned at some point.
Moreover, the foodcoats wagon is relatively low-quality, the vecna wagon is going nowhere, and I'm the only one on the worce wagon
And voting ND just encourages ND to make a bigger deal out of the whole situation and his stupid "dip is acting dumb" arc.
but screw it
##vote ND

Here is one of ND's responses that explains ND not voting for D&W D2:

@Dip&War: If you have read all my posts then you would have seen my interaction with Damo during Night #1 where we discuss this. I am of the opinion that it was T(ND) v T(Red) v T? (Dip&War) v T (Worcej)

-Worcej, I have basically ruled out due to his actions -see EON analysis
-Red was town.
-I am town.

I talk about you in my EON analysis and give my take on your behavior + the larger picture at EOD#1. There was very little movement during the latter parts of the day. I talk about it at length and it is important for how EOD (sub 25 minutes goes).

Anyway, I think your motives are questionable. I find it unlikely that you are mafia, but not impossible. I find it more likely that you are town or a 3rd party.

[brainbomb]

If Will was a 3p here I would expect him to mimic his townplay but naturally would display some withdrawn behavior and laying low more than usual. I havent seen that; hes pretty much been a kodiak bear this game; trying to rend everything he thinks is evil

[brainbomb]

The nuclear option is we no kill today or tomorrow and make it impossible for a potential warlock to win

[brainbomb]

There is one other person id vote today and im gonna keep that one to myself.

[bozotheclown]

Screw it. I want more info.
##vote ND

The top wagon is 2 votes and nobody has voted me today, which is making me anxious because I'm likely going to end up flashwagoned at some point.
Moreover, the foodcoats wagon is relatively low-quality, the vecna wagon is going nowhere, and I'm the only one on the worce wagon
And voting ND just encourages ND to make a bigger deal out of the whole situation and his stupid "dip is acting dumb" arc.
but screw it
##vote ND

The similar wording to somewhat hedge these votes is interesting.

##VOTE ND

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I’m here

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

He spent a large chunk of D1 peddling a theory that darg was editing his posts before posting them because there was a post with a double line break in it. It was terrible logic, they were both town, and it was a major factor in Dip getting miskilled.

Digging on BB, I found this nugget and it looks

I stand by the analysis. Apparently Dip can fake his tinfoil lunacy.

My thing is he *wasnt* doing his tinfoil lunacy

Dip is a good player, and has underrated solving ability. This game it was just plainly obvious he was not trying to solve at all. He was just throwing random ahade

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I think this vote for Just is inconclusive. If DiplomacyandWarfare had voted for anyone else there, Just would look bad when DiplomacyandWarfare flipped mafia. DiplomacyandWarfare did make some posts that made it seem like he was trying to get Just DKed over him:





However, DiplomacyandWarfare didn't make a town PR claim, which might have been able to divert the DK to Just.

This is actually a good point

I think this lends more merit to that the wolves were bussing DIp for credit

interesting data point to follow up on.

a town/3p just would know for certain that DW didnt forego claiming to save his ass, so id expect this to influence his behaviour going forward from this point if he indeed did think it was a good point.

Well lol guess what

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

will has felt town to me since day 1, but also, i am worried the folks just wont get off him until hes dead, and am contemplating just getting it over with so we can move on

Spirit 3p theory intensifies

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I am almost certainly the target for any sort of warlock

[brainbomb]

I am almost certainly the target for any sort of warlock

I think me or you are almost certainly warlocks choice unless its witch.

[foodcoats]

will has felt town to me since day 1, but also, i am worried the folks just wont get off him until hes dead, and am contemplating just getting it over with so we can move on

Spirit 3p theory intensifies

I re-read Spirit last (real life) night. I was hoping to think he was scum but that doesn’t feel right. One of the challenges to my reading is OMGUS towards him and the other is I lack meta… but basically Spirit hasn’t really been reading since N2 and his analysis is totally stuck. He has claimed he has a tunnelling problem so that could be it. But he has a very limited locus of attention and analysis… There are swaths of players and events he doesn’t pay any attention to. He gets wrapped up in analyzing nightkills and third party tinfoil. On the one hand I don’t see clear scum indications for him but… I mean, fundamentally you could level the same argument against him as how Dip was caught… Spirit is not solving and has thrown some random unjustified crap at the wall.

I think I’d love to hear an analysis of Spirit from someone who isn’t tilted on him and who has played him before.

[brainbomb]

Ill do a full iso and compare on him later

[ghug]

If our eliminations are too scripted and predictable we can make this an easier win for possible warlock. We should kill outside of me or will to prevent this until we know more. Being too predictable in how we play is gonna turn us trying to sus out mafia to us handing a win to someone else.

Worcej is a good elimination as they werent someone a 3p would have predicted would die today. And he seems like scum or 3p.

I buy this until the killing worcej part.

[ghug]

The smart way to do this is to eliminate someone who fits both profiles.

Both witch and warlock or both 3p and mafia?

[ghug]

##VOTE brain

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

will has felt town to me since day 1, but also, i am worried the folks just wont get off him until hes dead, and am contemplating just getting it over with so we can move on

Spirit 3p theory intensifies

I re-read Spirit last (real life) night. I was hoping to think he was scum but that doesn’t feel right. One of the challenges to my reading is OMGUS towards him and the other is I lack meta… but basically Spirit hasn’t really been reading since N2 and his analysis is totally stuck. He has claimed he has a tunnelling problem so that could be it. But he has a very limited locus of attention and analysis… There are swaths of players and events he doesn’t pay any attention to. He gets wrapped up in analyzing nightkills and third party tinfoil. On the one hand I don’t see clear scum indications for him but… I mean, fundamentally you could level the same argument against him as how Dip was caught… Spirit is not solving and has thrown some random unjustified crap at the wall.

I think I’d love to hear an analysis of Spirit from someone who isn’t tilted on him and who has played him before.

I really don’t think spirit is mafia, if anything spirit is 3p

[SpiritoftheRadio]

ill say it again, lets just kill ghug ##vote ghug

[SpiritoftheRadio]

will has felt town to me since day 1, but also, i am worried the folks just wont get off him until hes dead, and am contemplating just getting it over with so we can move on

Spirit 3p theory intensifies

I re-read Spirit last (real life) night. I was hoping to think he was scum but that doesn’t feel right. One of the challenges to my reading is OMGUS towards him and the other is I lack meta… but basically Spirit hasn’t really been reading since N2 and his analysis is totally stuck. He has claimed he has a tunnelling problem so that could be it. But he has a very limited locus of attention and analysis… There are swaths of players and events he doesn’t pay any attention to. He gets wrapped up in analyzing nightkills and third party tinfoil. On the one hand I don’t see clear scum indications for him but… I mean, fundamentally you could level the same argument against him as how Dip was caught… Spirit is not solving and has thrown some random unjustified crap at the wall.

I think I’d love to hear an analysis of Spirit from someone who isn’t tilted on him and who has played him before.

i reread you too, then you came to me in the dream... I think we can be friends for a bit a least =)