MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Les go

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Ok now I definitely think Will is his teammate though.

?

Why??

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

The one thing I can be certain of is Worcej town

I think he’s essentially cleared atp

[ghug]

Probably not mafia:
ghug
worcej
Bunny
Spirit
At least two of Brain/Vecna/Demon
Food

Plausibly scum:
At most one of Brain/Vecna/demon
Will
Mimi
Pirates
ND
Bozo

That's a pretty solid POE.

[ghug]

Screw it. I want more info.
##vote ND

This created a three-way tie with Dip/Red/ND at 17 minutes left, which unfortunately looks pretty good for ND, but I don't think totally clearing.

[DemonRHK]

ghuggles, this flip makes me not like the way you look, and that makes me sad.

Granted, I look real bad too, but yea.

Also, I am having my first doubt on brain this game, but it is very small

[ghug]

ghuggles, this flip makes me not like the way you look, and that makes me sad.

Granted, I look real bad too, but yea.

Also, I am having my first doubt on brain this game, but it is very small

Check out my awesomely-timed vote for Dip day one.

[ghug]

Someone pay attention to me. I don't want to go back to work.

[miminena]

@ghug now that we're no longer under EoD pressure, could you give a reason for your will read?

[worcej]

I probably won't be available @ EoN to post, so I might as well do my "work" now...

D1 VCA now has some real good meat to it imho

Before I entered into the fray of the last 10 minutes, the votes were this:
Dip (4) - Bunny, brain, Demon, Will
Red (4) - food, kotp, ND, Spirit
ND (4) - Dip, ghug, Red, Vecna
Will (2) - bozo, mimi

I feel like the movement of ghug onto dip @ 00:05 left not something scum ghug would've done, as it kept Dip as the viable counter-wagon to Red, with little time left and would be unnecessary risk. For this, I feel good about towning him. (also, I just saw ghug reference this at Demon to defend himselve as I previewed my color choices and I feel less-good because of how he is using it actively...)

After I voted and made Red the leader at 5, Vecna, BB, and Demon all pounced on me, which opened up Dip, Will, ghug, and mimi to come at me and make me the counter wagon for Red.

Of all these votes, the ones I don't like the most are BB and Demon because they came off very opportunistic and gave them a green light to bail off their potential teammate. Demon also pointed out he looks bad based off D1 (via the cross-post of ghug being gross), so I lean a little more towny at him for owning it versus keeping that hidden. I'd say BB should be a D3 choice while letting demon slide (for now).

I think Vecna is fine - he had not liked my voting and how I was behaving, so he had justification to come at me. I don't think Vecna should be a wagon anytime soon and is probably town.

I am a little meh at Will because his actions on D1 were hyper-defensive of Redand I think scum!Will would go about doing this to justify his voting here, so I think a D3 look at Will is warranted.

Finally, mimi - who has been incredibly analytical, but I don't agree with the conclusions entirely made on D1 or N1. I suspect, ultimately, that I need to really read her (I think this is the right pronoun?) D2 to make a judgement.

Conclusion:
Towny: ND, ghug (with a little bit of on his shirt), Vecna
Lean-Towny: Demon
No idea: mimi
"Let's flip D3": BB and Will

[worcej]

Someone pay attention to me. I don't want to go back to work.

I don't think you want my attention

[worcej]

Probably not mafia:
ghug
worcej
Bunny
Spirit
At least two of Brain/Vecna/Demon
Food

Plausibly scum:
At most one of Brain/Vecna/demon
Will
Mimi
Pirates
ND
Bozo

That's a pretty solid POE.

For one of the few times in our gaming existences (outside of being scum together), I solidly agree with you.

[worcej]

The one thing I can be certain of is Worcej town

I think he’s essentially cleared atp

Expand further as to why you arrive to this.

[worcej]

might be worth it to look at DW's vote history for both days

Day 1: ghug -> Red -> bb -> Red -> ND -> Red -> worcej

Day 2: bozo -> worcej -> ND -> Spirit -> Will

putting this here for accessibility later, the bot's columns can get hard to read

I did this with my analysis, as I focused on EOD specifically, but timing of votes are important.

The closer to EOD, the more "value/impact" the vote should have.

[ghug]

@ghug now that we're no longer under EoD pressure, could you give a reason for your will read?

My current one? I gave a real reason for voting for him before EoD.

Now, it's largely how consistently Will was on Dip. I think it's highly unlikely there were no bussers on either day, and it's often the case that people bus early when there's no pressure and then can't move later, which makes him a plausible choice. Then add the fact that his reads haven't been that dynamic and the fact that Dip seemed to be looking for a third alternative at the end, and they all point to Will bussing.

[ghug]

Probably not mafia:
ghug
worcej
Bunny
Spirit
At least two of Brain/Vecna/Demon
Food

Plausibly scum:
At most one of Brain/Vecna/demon
Will
Mimi
Pirates
ND
Bozo

That's a pretty solid POE.

For one of the few times in our gaming existences (outside of being scum together), I solidly agree with you.

Shit, back to the drawing board.

[brainbomb]

Vecna is basically cleared now also for how he reacted to dips push on him. Id also say will is cleared for being first to go after dip

[ghug]

Vecna is basically cleared now also for how he reacted to dips push on him. Id also say will is cleared for being first to go after dip

I think Dip's push itself looks good for Vecna, but scum often call each other out on shit like that.

Will is definitely not clear.

[brainbomb]

I feel pretty good about pirates still being town as well.

[brainbomb]

Now to celebrate with civ 7 adventures