MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[Vecna]

There is also the fact that if bozo, ghug, or demon live till near the end, they will usually be a miskill anyway even if town imo. Unless mechanics or really really solid hunting on their part clears them

I dont feel that way about ghug at all.

He is much more like me. His reads arent that amazing, but he is pretty much unkillable most of the time

[SpiritoftheRadio]

unless you're a day vig

[Vecna]

There is also the fact that if bozo, ghug, or demon live till near the end, they will usually be a miskill anyway even if town imo. Unless mechanics or really really solid hunting on their part clears them

I dont feel that way about ghug at all.

He is much more like me. His reads arent that amazing, but he is pretty much unkillable most of the time

which is also funnily how ghug gives himself away as scum quite often. Because as scum he will always try. To sneak in a sneakattack to vote me out while im gone or in a weakened state.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

so what you're saying is, we have to kill ghug in order to avoid the witch getting a point? Cowabunga it is

[Vecna]

unless you're a day vig

uh yeah, ive been vigged more often than ive been voted out (as town).

You should ask ND about that. Genius stole my gun and killed me with it. It was pretty funny. But also incredibly dumb.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

unless you're a day vig

uh yeah, ive been vigged more often than ive been voted out (as town).

You should ask ND about that. Genius stole my gun and killed me with it. It was pretty funny. But also incredibly dumb.

I was there when it happened, and was rolling as I was scum at the time. I love all you knuckleheads

[miminena]

i'll put some reads down for now, this is mostly thought dumping and not very well thought out so please scrutinize

confirmed town: Mimi (at least from my perspective)
pretty towny: kotp (although I should check myself on this one, since I vibe very well with them. I have a bad habit of heavily trusting mafia in in-person games.)
leaning town: Will, Spirit, DW, Bunny, ND, bozo, ghug; from towniest to nullest
null cutoff: Demon (they've lurked this whole game while seemingly pretending to be active. I don't like it, but I can't really develop a read)
leaning mafia: Vecna (this is a very slight lean, and honestly with their recent posting this might move up to a town lean. the only reason that they're a mafia lean in the first place is that they started the flash wagon on worcej, which doesn't mean that much in retrospect), foodcoats (they turned the wagon on Red into an actual wagon, and it feels weird how they went from relatively low and sporadic posting on day 1 to being the highest poster atm. maybe there's a good reason for this, please let me know if that's the case), worcej (very slight, only putting them here because of the damo kill, since they were damo's main suspicion during day 1. could definitely switch to a town lean one I look back through the end of day 1 fiasco.)
pretty scummy: nobody atm
person who I currently have a slight scum read on but everyone else seems to town read so idk: bb (their voting patterns seem very opportunist all throughout, and they claimed vt rather than town initially, which was something damo was pretty set about, so the nk on damo points to bb imo)

I'd be fine voting anyone Demon and under except for worcej rn; my preferred vote is bb, but that seems unrealistic, and second is foodcoats, but that's already a wagon and I don't want it to run away barely over 24h into they, so i'll withhold my vote for now.

I put no notes on town leans because that category is pretty much just people who are relatively null but not exactly scummy, which I don't have much reasoning for. admittedly it's a bit large, and consists of some people I haven't thought about enough. I'll work on sifting through it throughout the day

[SpiritoftheRadio]

In fairness to ND, he went through an iron man 3 arc and came back to do good stuff a couple days later. He came off so genuinely disappointed in himself that town didn't even kill him for it.

[miminena]

i'll put some reads down for now, this is mostly thought dumping and not very well thought out so please scrutinize

confirmed town: Mimi (at least from my perspective)

pretty towny: kotp (although I should check myself on this one, since I vibe very well with them. I have a bad habit of heavily trusting mafia in in-person games.)

leaning town: Will, Spirit, DW, Bunny, ND, bozo, ghug; from towniest to nullest

null cutoff: Demon (they've lurked this whole game while seemingly pretending to be active. I don't like it, but I can't really develop a read)

leaning mafia: Vecna (this is a very slight lean, and honestly with their recent posting this might move up to a town lean. the only reason that they're a mafia lean in the first place is that they started the flash wagon on worcej, which doesn't mean that much in retrospect)

foodcoats (they turned the wagon on Red into an actual wagon, and it feels weird how they went from relatively low and sporadic posting on day 1 to being the highest poster atm. maybe there's a good reason for this, please let me know if that's the case)

worcej (very slight, only putting them here because of the damo kill, since they were damo's main suspicion during day 1. could definitely switch to a town lean one I look back through the end of day 1 fiasco.)
pretty scummy: nobody atm

person who I currently have a slight scum read on but everyone else seems to town read so idk: bb (their voting patterns seem very opportunist all throughout, and they claimed vt rather than town initially, which was something damo was pretty set about, so the nk on damo points to bb imo)

I'd be fine voting anyone Demon and under except for worcej rn; my preferred vote is bb, but that seems unrealistic, and second is foodcoats, but that's already a wagon and I don't want it to run away barely over 24h into they, so i'll withhold my vote for now.

I put no notes on town leans because that category is pretty much just people who are relatively null but not exactly scummy, which I don't have much reasoning for. admittedly it's a bit large, and consists of some people I haven't thought about enough. I'll work on sifting through it throughout the day

spacing for readability

[Vecna]

alright, time for bed

[Vecna]

lol, its as if trump suddenly appeared in this thread and finally managed to make mexico pay for some walls.

Hi minima

[worcej]

Superbowl > mafia.

Just expressing I exist so GMs don’t PM me

[Vecna]

In fairness to ND, he went through an iron man 3 arc and came back to do good stuff a couple days later. He came off so genuinely disappointed in himself that town didn't even kill him for it.

he wasnt disappointed in himself lol. He went full-on FUCK THIS VECNA GUY, WHAT A NOOB, ITS ALL HIS FAULT.

[miminena]

activity has been pretty low overall on d2 eh?

I know im not -that- active myself, but it seems like theres been quite little posts so far today.

after miskilling red, we were cursed to all be lurkers. also superbowl

My ABBA parody made everyone reconsider how they were spending their time

I love abba as much as the next girl, but with the witch theming you really should have parodied something wicked

lol, its as if trump suddenly appeared in this thread and finally managed to make mexico pay for some walls.

Hi minima

hey girlypop~

(assuming you're talking to me)

[miminena]

activity has been pretty low overall on d2 eh?

I know im not -that- active myself, but it seems like theres been quite little posts so far today.

after miskilling red, we were cursed to all be lurkers. also superbowl

My ABBA parody made everyone reconsider how they were spending their time

I love abba as much as the next girl, but with the witch theming you really should have parodied something wicked

lol, its as if trump suddenly appeared in this thread and finally managed to make mexico pay for some walls.

Hi minima

hey girlypop~

(assuming you're talking to me)

oh hey i had post 1234 :3

[ND]

Yeah that whole thing was unfortunate. At the time I thought it was brilliant though.

[BunnyGo]

so sorry about that red, you will be missed.

this end of day makes me feel a lot better about will. a cursory read of the votes puts foodcoats and spirit at immediate suspicion for me, the red wagon wasn't that prominent before they voted on it. i'll try to do a closer read in the next few minutes

I feel like you’re looking too far in the past on this and ignoring votes that were made after I threw a wrench into everything

Fair point, but I do want to let it sit for a while before I get into it, the weirdness just happened after all.

Just read this 5 times to see if I thought it was scum theatre or not. After 3 reads I was sure it was. After 5 I think not...

[ND]

Anyway, I have been scrolling through this. A few things:
1. Diplomacy&Warfare just voting for lurkers is very intellectually bankrupt. It's an easy crutch when you don't have much to contribute. I still don't think he is scum though.
2. Bozo made some good speculative points regarding EOD on Page 55-56ish about the Worcej/Red wagons. I like the line of thought and I do plan to revisit that again. Everyone should.
3. Ghug unfortunately is still a null for me. He is really playing a lazy game which can be interpreted a few ways. I won't comment on the out of game stuff, but that really shouldn't be addressed here. If you sign up for a game, you should be expected to play it and not constantly cry about it.

I need to think about the game some more.

[SpiritoftheRadio]

I feel like you’re looking too far in the past on this and ignoring votes that were made after I threw a wrench into everything

Fair point, but I do want to let it sit for a while before I get into it, the weirdness just happened after all.

Just read this 5 times to see if I thought it was scum theatre or not. After 3 reads I was sure it was. After 5 I think not...

Everything other post mimi makes, she comes off as scum, the next one always feels town, I've ruled out really evaluating her for now after doing this dance over and over.

[ghug]

I find new and creative ways to be openly scummy every single game.

Not all of them on purpose

lol yeah dude same, those were solid posts coming back though. I wanna see if I can get my dream from D1 to come true, ghug and foodcoats as the top wagons

Oof