MAFIA 92 - The return of the Witchfinder General [GAME THREAD]

[dargorygel]

##GM VOTE COUNT

ND (5): ghug, Red Neurax, ND, brainbomb, Vecna
ghug (3): worcej,JustAGuyNamedWill, bozotheclown
Red Neurax (2): kingofthepirates, DiplomacyandWarfare
worcej (2): damo666, foodcoats
JustaGuyNamedWill (1): miminena
foodcoats (1): SpiritoftheRadio
DiplomacyandWarfare (1): BunnyGo
Vecna (1): DemonRHK

Two End Votes on ND: ghug and brain.

ND is in the lead

Just under 7 hours left today

[ND]

why is ND self voting
##VOTE red neurax
for lurking

This is a bad reason to vote, but it may not be a bad candidate.

Note to self: Red - Ghug

#make web dip mafia great again

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I know I was, I’m kind of getting buyers remorse with the vote, I have a feeling in my gut that its wrong

then... change it?? looking through your ghug vote post, you posted a solve with like zero context. I thought it was a meme at the time but this statement makes me question that, so now idk what your idea is/was... :<

Lowkey forgot to unvote

##UNVOTE

[damo666]

ghug red?

Expect so.

[ND]

Alright. I'll check back later. Unfortunately EOD is during commute, but I'll pull over or something.

In summary:
-quack
-red and chug
-end voting D1 LOL
-civ is bland
-spirit of the radio LOL

Ok bye
#make hashtags great again

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

What devil vexes ye?

will's jumping all over the place mainly. Not necessarily AI, but still a bit weird and unsettling for me personally (lowkey feels a bit hedge-y?)... and keeping the vote after expressing distaste for it, doesn't feel logical. Could just be misreading things and just being a doofus rn though.

Lol King how can you call me out for hedging while also hedging in the same post

Also its not a hedge; a hedge is where you say “I believe this, tho it could be this”

I thought ghug was scummy, saw the thread and posts afterward, and reevaluated

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I dont like how people piledon ghug

I am the only one who voted for ghug after you, who are the other "people" you are referring to?

I’m referring to mostly the whole wagon other than wocej. I dont remember seeing a good case against Ghug other than mine (which tbf was a weak case)

[damo666]

@Red

Why will you not say

I am town

?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

i was looking back through the roles and misread "weak doctor" as "witch doctor", now i have that song stuck in my head

I told the witch doctor i was in love with you
I told the witch doctor i was in love with you
Im saying ooo ee oo a a ting tang walla walla bing bang

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Bro dip are you serious

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE DIP

I had this suspicion before the poem

Dip doesn’t seem like his usual “I am going to solve this game whether you like it or not” attitude. I dont see his usual towny drive to solve

And Dip would never do something like that as town imo

[ND]

D1 is a crap shoot. Have fun. Be merry.

#make web dip hashtags mafia great sgain!

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

ND what are your crapshoot reads

[miminena]

I thought ghug was scummy, saw the thread and posts afterward, and reevaluated

what about ghug's posts after your vote made you reevaluate?

[damo666]

##VOTE DIP

I had this suspicion before the poem

Dip doesn’t seem like his usual “I am going to solve this game whether you like it or not” attitude. I dont see his usual towny drive to solve

And Dip would never do something like that as town imo

I don't think he'd do it as anything but town.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I thought ghug was scummy, saw the thread and posts afterward, and reevaluated

what about ghug's posts after your vote made you reevaluate?

Not Ghug’s posts

The posts of others; the way that ghug seemed to be a find candidate with just about anyone

In my experience its a red flag that the person is town, especially a good scumbo like ghug

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

##VOTE DIP

I had this suspicion before the poem

Dip doesn’t seem like his usual “I am going to solve this game whether you like it or not” attitude. I dont see his usual towny drive to solve

And Dip would never do something like that as town imo

I don't think he'd do it as anything but town.

I very highly doubt that

[damo666]

##VOTE DIP

I had this suspicion before the poem

Dip doesn’t seem like his usual “I am going to solve this game whether you like it or not” attitude. I dont see his usual towny drive to solve

And Dip would never do something like that as town imo

I don't think he'd do it as anything but town.

I very highly doubt that

We shall see

[miminena]

I thought ghug was scummy, saw the thread and posts afterward, and reevaluated

what about ghug's posts after your vote made you reevaluate?

Not Ghug’s posts

The posts of others; the way that ghug seemed to be a find candidate with just about anyone

In my experience its a red flag that the person is town, especially a good scumbo like ghug

DW voted ghug early, then moved off later, worcej was clear about their reasoning (#169 and the ensuing conversation), foodcoats moved off pretty early, and bozo said that it was arbitrary in their voting post (although I don't know why they haven't moved off yet, maybe they just haven't found a better target?). This is everybody who voted ghug other than you.

The only person who voted ghug for a seemingly spurious reason was you. I don't think this necessarily means that you're mafia, I just feel like drilling you :3

If you have specific posts for why you moved off ghug that would help clear this up

[bozotheclown]

hmm... Will has been a bit weird about ghug throughout the day imo; they went from a slight read, to emphatically voting them, to feeling iffy about the wagon with little in-between. Not sure if this means anything, but it feels like an opportunity vote on a pretty arbitrary wagon.

This isn't very strong reasoning, but I am trigger happy, and would prefer to build up pressure on people other than ghug, so:

##vote JustAGuyNamedWill

Just like my vote on spirit, i'm ready to move off once a defense arrives



I don't exactly get why we should do this after having already claimed, but I can't see it being bad for town. I am not third party.



why not paired with worcej?

Or me?

It is an amazing coincidence that these posts were 14 seconds apart considering it was over an hour after DiplomacyandWarfare's post. It seems like a good indication that miminena and worcej are on the same team. I calculate that they are about 6 times more likely to both be town than mafia (by random chance).

Show your working

I made an error somewhere, Vecna was closer, but I think it should be ((11/14)*(10/13))/((3/14)*(2/13)).