Mafia XL - A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

[damo666]

Scrub that. List is a failsafe option. Who should I pass to?

[damo666]

I have a 5/6 chance of survival (NK notwithstanding) so doc (and I think I have you sussed Mr Crumble) save DrCJG. But wait scum will know that so they will target Squigs so save him. But no wait scum know that etc etc.

Screw you scum. That's that little strategy fucked. It's all about guessing.

[DrCJG]

RHK didn't get to use the box.

There should be at least one list or item in the box based on what Balki did. My initial thought is if you are going to pass it to town to try and take an item and leave what I expect is a list option... if you are going to try to pass to scum then take the list option... but I will give it some more thought.

[damo666]

RHK didn't get to use the box.

There should be at least one list or item in the box based on what Balki did. My initial thought is if you are going to pass it to town to try and take an item and leave what I expect is a list option... if you are going to try to pass to scum then take the list option... but I will give it some more thought.

I'm gonna list and pass to popular scumread out of bo_,Sox ghug bozo ND durga

[ND]

Well the game had changed. I have some time to post some thoughts in a bit. Will do so.

[damo666]

Could it be as simple as ghug bo ND or was there scum on RHK? If so who?

Also, should I declare who I pass box to?

[flash2015]

Scrub that. List is a failsafe option. Who should I pass to?

If you list, it seems logical to pass it back to Squigs.

[ND]

In d1 and d2 I now find it more likely than not that the primary wagons were not necessarily made to protect damo but to compete against rhk. Still, there is an outside chance that damo is still scum, but I'm starting to think I'm wrong on him. As for flash I think there is still evidence to suggest he is an opportunist scum.

I'll publish a full list of my scum suspects at eon.

[worcej]

Actually if demonRHK listed it's 2/3 take
Yes?

He never got a chance to use it, so it's in the same condition as Balki left it.

[worcej]

Scrub that. List is a failsafe option. Who should I pass to?

If you list, it seems logical to pass it back to Squigs.

Not true at all - you have to list or take, so you'd be rolling the dice on a town clear.

Damo - give it to someone other than our town-clears, but someone who you also think is town.

[worcej]

Could it be as simple as ghug bo ND or was there scum on RHK? If so who?

Also, should I declare who I pass box to?

I am not against this other than the fact you put a target on their head in case the mafia choose to go for them, but more than likely they will be hunting the last PR.

[Foxcastle]

##GM NOTE: If you live in the United States and are eligible to do so, go vote today.

Also, just over 6 hours remain in Night 5.

[ND]

I'm voting don't worry guys. Straight ticket.

[ND]

For the good guys (R)

[ghug]

I'm voting don't worry guys. Straight ticket.

I'm shocked.

[ghug]

I still think you should just risk letting yourself die, damo. If whoever you give it to gets lynched, it could end up back on a clear and explode, which would be bad for us. Losing you costs us nothing but your friendly presence.

[flash2015]

I'm voting don't worry guys. Straight ticket.

Are you sure about all of them???

[flash2015]

Scrub that. List is a failsafe option. Who should I pass to?

If you list, it seems logical to pass it back to Squigs.

Not true at all - you have to list or take, so you'd be rolling the dice on a town clear.

Damo - give it to someone other than our town-clears, but someone who you also think is town.

I said "if you list", or did you not read that part? Isn't it better to keep a guaranteed town clear alive vs passing to someone who is not so clear?

[ghug]

If you list, it seems logical to pass it back to Squigs.

Not true at all - you have to list or take, so you'd be rolling the dice on a town clear.

Damo - give it to someone other than our town-clears, but someone who you also think is town.

I said "if you list", or did you not read that part? Isn't it better to keep a guaranteed town clear alive vs passing to someone who is not so clear?

The box recipient could still die the next night if he lists.

[bozotheclown]

I am glad it worked out, but I think the observer counterclaiming DemonRHK right away would have been the better way to go. I have the feeling that the scum team has a better idea what is going on with the PRs than most of the town.

If DrCJG and Squigs are going to keep the specifics of their claims hidden, I do not think it is worth discussing their claims tonight.

If the box ended up with a town player, I think they should perform a list so they do not risk exploding. I am sure that is what the scum will do if they have the box, there is no reason to increase the chances that the box kills a town player. They should also let us know they have the box and where it will be sent, so we can try to keep track of the box.

Strongly disagree. We're on track for MYLO. Your death doesn't cost us a mislynch, it just reduces the pool of potential mislynches.

I believe if the box kills a scum instead of a town, it would buy us another mislynch, so anything that decreases the chance of a town getting killed by the box is a good idea.