M1034: SOLE SURVIVOR: GAME THREAD

[ghug]

Am I missing something? Have I been hallucinating in thinking readlists are normally posted with the top being either town or scum, going down to players read as being on the opposite team?

Your lines were confusing.

[dargorygel]

Why am I being held responsible for this vote?
I wanted a vote based on the %%
I did not ask for you guys to start random bandwagons
I did not ask for darg to start a bandwagon on food
I did not ask for red to tie and leave me under 5 minutes to make a decision

and frankly, I am starting to consider a jamie/darg team because they are making a very concentrated effort to pin yesterday's vote on me

The only vote being "pinned" on you is your own. Do you not see the inconsistent nature of your vote?

[ghug]

Why am I being held responsible for this vote?
I wanted a vote based on the %%
I did not ask for you guys to start random bandwagons
I did not ask for darg to start a bandwagon on food
I did not ask for red to tie and leave me under 5 minutes to make a decision

and frankly, I am starting to consider a jamie/darg team because they are making a very concentrated effort to pin yesterday's vote on me

You don't see how your vote would look like an attempt to save me?

[ghug]

We now have a situation where the 10 post rule becomes a bit silly.

I have circa!00% decided to vote Dip but once I vote I have no incentive to post.

darg (mistakenly?) voted early so he has no more reason to post.

dip has no defence

zzzzzz

There are two scum, you know. So, just a thought, but perhaps we can talk about who you think Dip's team mate is.

Is it Ghug?

That would make sense.

Do you think it's odd that damo is this confident?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Why am I being held responsible for this vote?
I wanted a vote based on the %%
I did not ask for you guys to start random bandwagons
I did not ask for darg to start a bandwagon on food
I did not ask for red to tie and leave me under 5 minutes to make a decision

and frankly, I am starting to consider a jamie/darg team because they are making a very concentrated effort to pin yesterday's vote on me

You don't see how your vote would look like an attempt to save me?

I see that. It is entirely decent evidence that is being ridiculously overused.
Why doesn't anybody else see that there were three other people who voted for that wagon?
The same people who worked to develop the food wagon are now conveniently blaming it on me for a decision I had 5 minutes to make and, frankly, I didn't expect to have to make!

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

oh btw
I had an entire case arguing for a jamie/straight scumteam based on a potential soft jamie made d1
didn't want to post it d1 because I wanted to see if straight followed jamie's vote d1 and by the time straight voted it was too late to get any sort of vote going
I was going to post it like 30 seconds before EoN as I do but then I missed EoN
would anyone like to see it?

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

4 food voters
straight is dead
ghug gets a pass, more or less, for being a big wagon at the time

darg, well into d1 and having a lot of time to consider it, being able to start a wagon on literally anyone, chose that out of all the players currently present, food was the scummiest

I, having 2 minutes to consider it, being able to choose between ghug and food, panicked and voted the player with less posts

I made a bad decision in a bad situation.
Darg made a bad decision in a good situation.

I know none of you are dumb enough to think I was in control here
except possibly jamie*

[Red Neurax]

Why am I being held responsible for this vote?
I wanted a vote based on the %%
I did not ask for you guys to start random bandwagons
I did not ask for darg to start a bandwagon on food
I did not ask for red to tie and leave me under 5 minutes to make a decision

and frankly, I am starting to consider a jamie/darg team because they are making a very concentrated effort to pin yesterday's vote on me

i do believe that you had 2 days to make a decision, and waiting for me to vote was your perogative.

[Bonatogether]

You may now post of course

For the bot:

StraightFlush has died! He was an alliance member

this eod time is awful but curious kill

can't imagine why he would be the target

He seemed quite towny to me I have to say; fairly genuine. I think Mafia would have had a hard time mis-flipping him today. Bit mean to NK the new guy though :-/

let's think

who would be toxic enough to nk a new player?

[Bonatogether]

Lolololol
I forgot the one vote!!!

Well... I guess I am voting for dip!

I might be biased...
but this seems very, very, very fake

honestly i'm a believer of this one

[Bonatogether]

Why am I being held responsible for this vote?
I wanted a vote based on the %%
I did not ask for you guys to start random bandwagons
I did not ask for darg to start a bandwagon on food
I did not ask for red to tie and leave me under 5 minutes to make a decision

and frankly, I am starting to consider a jamie/darg team because they are making a very concentrated effort to pin yesterday's vote on me

why would you ever assume that people would hold to a vote they made earlier if not forced?

[Bonatogether]

A: I didn't like the ghug wagon because of the bona vote
B: ghug and food were literally right next to each other
C: (this is what ended up tiebreaking, as need I remind you red forced me to make a decision in those last 5 minutes) food had less posts than ghug

A: is bullshit because Bona's vote was cast very early in the game, long before you listed Ghug as one of your top 3 scumreads that you definitely "want to kill".

That is literally the reason I didn't like the bona vote
it was cast early in the game and therefore without any good reasons

it was purely meme, before i had fully internalized the rules. maybe you thought it had bad vibes but that's probably because you don't live for the silly

[Bonatogether]

You are also avoiding the issue, which is, at the risk of repeating myself, that ghug and food were 1 spot away from each other
also, that readlist was posted quite a lot before my vote. Is it so inconceivable that my reads shifted between two players who I had similar reads on in the first place?

They were barely a page apart.

a page and like 90 minutes

90 minutes, that famed length of time

[Bonatogether]

oh btw
I had an entire case arguing for a jamie/straight scumteam based on a potential soft jamie made d1
didn't want to post it d1 because I wanted to see if straight followed jamie's vote d1 and by the time straight voted it was too late to get any sort of vote going
I was going to post it like 30 seconds before EoN as I do but then I missed EoN
would anyone like to see it?

no scum would put the case in front of me, and therefore i know the case must be in the cup in front of you

[Red Neurax]

Lolololol
I forgot the one vote!!!

Well... I guess I am voting for dip!

I might be biased...
but this seems very, very, very fake

honestly i'm a believer of this one

If you think it's fake, what do you think that insinuates

[dargorygel]

Yes, what would a scum motivation for voting early be? Thoughtless, yes... maybe silly... but what does it gain me as scum?

I remain satisfied with my vote though.

[Red Neurax]

Yes, what would a scum motivation for voting early be? Thoughtless, yes... maybe silly... but what does it gain me as scum?

I remain satisfied with my vote though.

i feel like, in this situation voting early as a mafia would not gain any advantage as it seems like diplomacyandwarfare is in the hot seat anyways and voting early takes away the advantage of a vote pivot

[Bonatogether]

I might be biased...
but this seems very, very, very fake

honestly i'm a believer of this one

If you think it's fake, what do you think that insinuates

let's think

if a player is being fake, this implies that they are actively not revealing a truth

why would they do this? town could have reason to do this, both mechanical and gambit-wise, but scum can only do this. probability math works out that fakery is likely scummery.

[Bonatogether]

Yes, what would a scum motivation for voting early be? Thoughtless, yes... maybe silly... but what does it gain me as scum?

I remain satisfied with my vote though.

i didn't call the vote fake - i live in a glass house here, and i throw no stones. the thing i didn't like was the thing that i was directly responding to

[dargorygel]

Yes, what would a scum motivation for voting early be? Thoughtless, yes... maybe silly... but what does it gain me as scum?

I remain satisfied with my vote though.

i didn't call the vote fake - i live in a glass house here, and i throw no stones. the thing i didn't like was the thing that i was directly responding to

Umsy umsy... I did.not thonk, write, or say that you said that what I said was fake.

From the pov from which I view this gameworld, dip accused me of fakery.