Mafia 1033 - The Next Generation [Hidden]

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

is anyone going to respond to the case i wrote

darg thinking it was about will doesn't count

One thing I noticed you said about DiplomacyandWarfare is that "It's notable that he would briefly switch to rdr but would leave that wagon to return to voting me, even as rdr's wagon ran away to a bajillion votes."

However, DiplomacyandWarfare did move his vote back to rdrivera after Just voted for rdrivera. What do you think DiplomacyandWarfare was trying to do with his vote moves?

I think he was being honest when he said that he was voting at least in part to survive, but he also was clearly working towards wagoning me - the first time he voted rdr, he was leaving my wagon at 3 votes (so both of his preferred wagons were the only ones above a single vote), and he also returned to voting me because the 'rdr wagon doesn't seem to be going anywhere' (read: he picked up an additional vote).

i think every one of his vote moves in eod1 can be explained by it being preceded by someone voting for him (second vote for me, second vote for rdr)

This is honestly not a bad point

Dip was the third vote on rdr btw

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Im wavering here

[damo666]

@Jamie why did you revote Dip at T-2 minutes when you were already voting him?

[Bonatogether]

is anyone going to respond to the case i wrote

darg thinking it was about will doesn't count

I think its pretty alright. The points are fine and I do see that it could come from town

but I do definitely agree with it being weird that he consistently scumread damo but didn’t really act on it

But i dont agree he does stuff without purpose, as either alignment. I think he does know what he is doing and I think hes town

1) i didn't say he's without purpose.
2) town-purpose shows up as usually having a progression over time. DaW doesn't have any progression in reasons over time.

what specific thing has he done to make you think he's town?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

it's simply a ridiculous claim - you're telling me you honestly townread all of darg, DaW, and neuron? bait used to be believable

It is true

I assume you object to just Dip?

why do you assume that? tell me how you could actively townread (not meaning just not scumreading, but seeing something to take them out of null) any of these people:
1) the guy openly voteshopping in the thread
2) the guy the first guy is sheeping
3) a guy who barely posts anything

Its why i was asking

I think 1: Darg isn’t voteshopping, I think he’s solving
2: Dip is also solvy and doing a lot of straight game posts that I see with him as town but I’m kind of doubting it now. Still in my townleans
3: I think Neurax is pretty innocent, i dont see his posts coming from mafia

[Bonatogether]

One thing I noticed you said about DiplomacyandWarfare is that "It's notable that he would briefly switch to rdr but would leave that wagon to return to voting me, even as rdr's wagon ran away to a bajillion votes."

However, DiplomacyandWarfare did move his vote back to rdrivera after Just voted for rdrivera. What do you think DiplomacyandWarfare was trying to do with his vote moves?

I think he was being honest when he said that he was voting at least in part to survive, but he also was clearly working towards wagoning me - the first time he voted rdr, he was leaving my wagon at 3 votes (so both of his preferred wagons were the only ones above a single vote), and he also returned to voting me because the 'rdr wagon doesn't seem to be going anywhere' (read: he picked up an additional vote).

i think every one of his vote moves in eod1 can be explained by it being preceded by someone voting for him (second vote for me, second vote for rdr)

This is honestly not a bad point

Dip was the third vote on rdr btw

thanks for your contribution, but you need to explain why third vote specifically matters for it to count

[Jamiet99uk]

@Jamie why did you revote Dip at T-2 minutes when you were already voting him?

I have explained that at least twice already.

Read the thread.

[Bonatogether]

It is true

I assume you object to just Dip?

why do you assume that? tell me how you could actively townread (not meaning just not scumreading, but seeing something to take them out of null) any of these people:
1) the guy openly voteshopping in the thread
2) the guy the first guy is sheeping
3) a guy who barely posts anything

Its why i was asking

I think 1: Darg isn’t voteshopping, I think he’s solving
2: Dip is also solvy and doing a lot of straight game posts that I see with him as town but I’m kind of doubting it now. Still in my townleans
3: I think Neurax is pretty innocent, i dont see his posts coming from mafia

1) is DaW, 2) is Darg. try again, please.

give me a specific post that neurax has made and tell me specifically how a new scum could not have made it. it's not possible - there's no reason to actively townread him

[Jamiet99uk]

Imagine Damo's only post in the last 10 pages is asking me a question I have already answered multiple times.

Just imagine.

[Bonatogether]

jamie if we kill DaW today I'll join you on will tomorrow

[Jamiet99uk]

jamie if we kill DaW today I'll join you on will tomorrow

What about Damo?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I would be okay with Vecna going here because he really hasn’t done much of anything

My pet theory I stated early is that: its like he gives us a long post so we can go ‘oh Vecna is town’ then dips

His wallpost reads wasn’t that great and he ends up with the conclusion that we should vote argent which isn’t great? Same thing with day 1, I agree with Ghug and Jamie’s take that Vecna isn’t doing much at all that replicates his town play and its a bit jarring

[Bonatogether]

jamie if we kill DaW today I'll join you on will tomorrow

What about Damo?

not my concern atm

[damo666]

Although Bona or Dip flips would aid D1 vca I'm not really convinced either is scum.

What about hi ho silver?

##argent

he's a tad too lurkio

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote Diplomacy&Warcraft

I think there was a scum effort to save him yesterday, and if he is scum, one of Damo / Bozo is his partner.

[damo666]

Imagine Damo's only post in the last 10 pages is asking me a question I have already answered multiple times.

Just imagine.

have you?

[Bonatogether]

will is about to stop pushing vecna and cease all pretensions of 'wavering' on my case against DaW

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I think he was being honest when he said that he was voting at least in part to survive, but he also was clearly working towards wagoning me - the first time he voted rdr, he was leaving my wagon at 3 votes (so both of his preferred wagons were the only ones above a single vote), and he also returned to voting me because the 'rdr wagon doesn't seem to be going anywhere' (read: he picked up an additional vote).

i think every one of his vote moves in eod1 can be explained by it being preceded by someone voting for him (second vote for me, second vote for rdr)

This is honestly not a bad point

Dip was the third vote on rdr btw

thanks for your contribution, but you need to explain why third vote specifically matters for it to count

Well it would tie the wagons onto rdr which would be the first step in saving himself

[Bonatogether]

This is honestly not a bad point

Dip was the third vote on rdr btw

thanks for your contribution, but you need to explain why third vote specifically matters for it to count

Well it would tie the wagons onto rdr which would be the first step in saving himself

yeah this was my point like 4 posts up the chain. no town credit for you!

[damo666]

Imagine Damo's only post in the last 10 pages is asking me a question I have already answered multiple times.

Just imagine.

have you?

Found it. Sorry.