Mafia 91 - Battle for the Sunset Strip - GAME THREAD [Hidden]

[brainbomb]

Glitter, who do you think balki’s partners are?

[ghug]

If anyone else has a rose, they should claim, because both spirit and Brain have claimed rose and the GM has confirmed there are only 2 roses left. Anyone trying to hide a gun is probably mafia.

brain has not claimed rose in day 2. He made have had a N1 rose.

We're claiming who chose what, not which nights they have it.

People should explicitly claim which they took. Brain says a lot of things and I don't put a lot of stock in them until it's time to make a serious claim.

[ghug]

If anyone else has a rose, they should claim, because both spirit and Brain have claimed rose and the GM has confirmed there are only 2 roses left. Anyone trying to hide a gun is probably mafia.

Are you claiming a rose?

So far Sparta is our only claimed rose

This was believable when Glitter did it but not when you do it.

[brainbomb]

Regardless of claiming anything I think my interactions with Balki
Are as close to clearing as anything else you could find so far. Im still hunting and rereading to just evaluate who I think is playing a scum game.

Today is not making it easy as there are a good number of question marks.

Im asking myself if vecna truly scumread balki; if town vecna really sussed out ghug and balki and then just gave up on it. Also seeing his energy major drop off since day 1. His end of day is okayish but overall his gimmick stuff wasnt great at proving he was actually fleshing out real ideas. When he dropped the gimmick I note him listing balki as scum for

“Talking at the game rather than contributing”
If scum vecna is saying this to a teamate he is trying to either distance or signal to balki to change it up as it isnt working.

At least thats the worlds I think are a thing.

For vecna to be town he would have had to give up on his actual scumreads and then just sort of stop trying since. Seems unrealistic

[GlitterBomb]

Glitter, who do you think balki’s partners are?

I've been re-reading and trying to find anything that makes sense or gave away intentions or alliances in Balki.

Page 11 – Post 201 Stands out to me. Is this scum Balki defending scum Worcej?

Definitely highly suspicious of Worcej ATM.

Spirit hasn't stood out to me as much as others seem to have gravitated towards him.

Vecna was one who mentioned being willing to vote Will. I followed with that. He also tried to create chaos with a last minute speed wagon on Chaqa.

As opposed to spending a ton of time combing over what Balki said, I've been focusing on the comments of those who've been verified Town. What specifically stood out to me was Sparta's insights on Vecna on Page 47. He perceived a confidence shift in Vecna, going from confused and unsure townie to pretty opinionated at EOD. I absolutely agree with this.

Yoyo and Damo are popping in here and there and I'm null on them ATM.

Ghug has drilled me hard, and I think it's coming from a town perspective but I'm less sure on him than I was. Just because my reasonings and explanations aren't making sense to him, doesn't mean that they are wrong - they're just different viewpoints than how Ghug sees the game. I feel like I was talking in circles yesterday trying to explain myself and it wasn't accomplishing anything. When it comes down to it, I believe Bunny is town. He was on board with Will already, WIll was being mentioned and my thought process was that I would put my Will vote out there and see if others would put their money where their mouth was. I was trying to help contribute to a proactive push to not having last second chaotic voting.

So all of this is to say that I'm very much leaning towards it being Vecna/Worcej.

[GlitterBomb]

Glitter, who do you think balki’s partners are?

I've been re-reading and trying to find anything that makes sense or gave away intentions or alliances in Balki.

Page 11 – Post 201 Stands out to me. Is this scum Balki defending scum Worcej?

Definitely highly suspicious of Worcej ATM.

Spirit hasn't stood out to me as much as others seem to have gravitated towards him.

Vecna was one who mentioned being willing to vote Will. I followed with that. He also tried to create chaos with a last minute speed wagon on Chaqa.

As opposed to spending a ton of time combing over what Balki said, I've been focusing on the comments of those who've been verified Town. What specifically stood out to me was Sparta's insights on Vecna on Page 47. He perceived a confidence shift in Vecna, going from confused and unsure townie to pretty opinionated at EOD. I absolutely agree with this.

Yoyo and Damo are popping in here and there and I'm null on them ATM.

Ghug has drilled me hard, and I think it's coming from a town perspective but I'm less sure on him than I was. Just because my reasonings and explanations aren't making sense to him, doesn't mean that they are wrong - they're just different viewpoints than how Ghug sees the game. I feel like I was talking in circles yesterday trying to explain myself and it wasn't accomplishing anything. When it comes down to it, I believe Bunny is town. He was on board with Will already, WIll was being mentioned and my thought process was that I would put my Will vote out there and see if others would put their money where their mouth was. I was trying to help contribute to a proactive push to not having last second chaotic voting.

So all of this is to say that I'm very much leaning towards it being Vecna/Worcej.

In re-reading this...I realize I should have chosen other language than "drilled me hard".... so let's just giggle and move on before this becomes and embarrassing thing.... UGH.

[brainbomb]

Since you trust bunny, he wants everyone to claim. Glittery anything to offer?

[ghug]

##VOTE Spirit

[GlitterBomb]

If I missed something, please feel free to correct, but here's where I see the list:

BunnyGo - Gun
ghug - Gun
GlitterBomb - Gun
SpiritoftheRadio - Rose
Worcej - Gun
Yoyoyozo - Gun
Brainbomb – Has claimed both but nothing on D2...
Damo -
Vecna -

[brainbomb]

Interesting. i didnt know that many
People had claimed so far. Who did you pull that updated list from?

[GlitterBomb]

Interesting. i didnt know that many
People had claimed so far. Who did you pull that updated list from?

I went back through all of the D2 posts and read all claims. Some were in text not on a list. And Bunny's was tricky because he claimed "not a rose".... So I updated the list and added all players so we'd having a running tally. This was my way of claiming - I hadn't till now and was waiting to do the breakdown before doing so.

[brainbomb]

What has everyone learned from this massclaim event so far?

When will we resume playing mafia and scumreading people?

Who thought this would out someone?

[GlitterBomb]

What has everyone learned from this massclaim event so far?

When will we resume playing mafia and scumreading people?

Who thought this would out someone?

When are you going to claim?

[brainbomb]

What has everyone learned from this massclaim event so far?

When will we resume playing mafia and scumreading people?

Who thought this would out someone?

When are you going to claim?

Last. Because its spicy!

[GlitterBomb]

What has everyone learned from this massclaim event so far?

When will we resume playing mafia and scumreading people?

Who thought this would out someone?

When are you going to claim?

Last. Because its spicy!

Always with the drama….

[brainbomb]

I mean, as odd as this is to say you dont know my sordid history with fake claiming things. Since as long as ive been here ive lived and died by basically claiming something every game. This just happens to be a game where its more normal to claim various things. In other games where there are cops I have regularly faked being a cop with a guilty to grab the initiative and it hasnt always been popular

[ghug]

What has everyone learned from this massclaim event so far?

When will we resume playing mafia and scumreading people?

Who thought this would out someone?

The goal isn't to out someone. It's to make people commit to their claims so they can't funny business later. If you claim and move on, it doesn't have to be a focal point of the day.

[brainbomb]

Given mafia are down to two people alive it does seem sort of crazy to imagine a scum trying to claim and we end up with a third rose. A townie faking a gun here probably doesnt happen unless there is some baiting going on and someone is just that sure of themselves. Even still that move would be a long reach for scum to wanna risk wading into.

Trying to figure out if there is some twist here where scum maybe shot their own person with a rose to fake clear themselves. Havent pondered it much since we arent claiming what nights our stuff happened.

[brainbomb]

What has everyone learned from this massclaim event so far?

When will we resume playing mafia and scumreading people?

Who thought this would out someone?

The goal isn't to out someone. It's to make people commit to their claims so they can't funny business later. If you claim and move on, it doesn't have to be a focal point of the day.

Are you convinced there is still a mystery to be unraveled?

[BunnyGo]

If anyone else has a rose, they should claim, because both spirit and Brain have claimed rose and the GM has confirmed there are only 2 roses left. Anyone trying to hide a gun is probably mafia.

Are you claiming a rose?

So far Sparta is our only claimed rose

This was believable when Glitter did it but not when you do it.

Yes yes…spirit.


It was an honest error.