WebMafia Olympics - Game #3 - Raygun's Revenge [GAME THREAD]

[BunnyGo]

Meanwhile in game thread:

ghug: Who should we "kill"?

Jamiet: Oh I really "Townread" Bunny and sweetandcool. Flum and Kak are "suspicious". You are a tiny bit too (; I absolutely love rdr.

ghug: If you shoot me now, it is good for your "teammate" (TRANSLATION: Please shoot today, I want that).

Jamiet: I'm not shooting. Let's get them the old fashioned way.

ghug: Pleaaaaaase?

Jamiet: Nah bro.

hmm ... hmm.

Would maf sweet say this?

yes

[BunnyGo]

currently rereading the game with trying to look out for hidden communication stuff, and that drew my eyes:

Hello, Fellow Townspeople.

Fluminator
heartthrob24909
JustAnImpostorNamedWill

Please join the game.

colour codes are 008080, 808000, 80BF00 and 00BFFF.

@Jamie what was your thought progress behind choosing those colour codes? Why choose those different colours?

@everyone else do you see any special hidden information that could've been conveyed with such a colour code?

No, and I don't think scum!Jamie would initiate some steganography like that

[BunnyGo]

EOD2 Votes:
Ya'll hammered Just - not going to go back and manually get them (lowkey love/hate you all as I had to fuck with the bot lol...)

...


fine - do it myself.png

Surprise surprise.

Kak and Bunny looking suspicious AF.

##VOTE Just
##END

Surprise surprise.

Kak and Bunny looking suspicious AF.

##VOTE Just
##END

You drove me off Just with your weird posting.

But now that NOBODY entered scum kill orders…

##vote Just ##end

##VOTE Just
##END

If he is not modkilled, let's Speedwagon and give Mafia no vig shots.

Hurry…

I'm in.

##Vote Just
##End

##Vote Just

##END

##VOTE Just
##END

(For the bot)

##Vote Just
##End

For the bot, and for justice!

Huh? That does fit the description?

Holding the shots is three layers deep. It is also one layer deep. Imposter is operating on layer one.

Hmm, I could be very overthinking this, true.

Argh, I hope I make no mistake and let mafia guide a misvote on a towny.

Then again, he is pretty in the PoE, so I guess not much lost.

##vote JustAnImposterNamedWill
##end

so, if I hadn't make a mistake, it would look something like this:


Final Day 2 Vote Count:
JustAnImpostorNamedWill (5) - sweetandcool*, BunnyGo*, Jamiet99uk*, Fluminator*, Kakarroto*


so, what can we see/learn from this?

Sweet's first post looks bad. Throwing shade at kaka and me while hammering Just.

[BunnyGo]

##VOTE Just
##END

If he is not modkilled, let's Speedwagon and give Mafia no vig shots.

This second post is sweet telling his active partner to holster.

##unend

[BunnyGo]

I still think Mafia was inactive.

This points to rdr and ghug (Heart really).

But I doubt it's that easy.

I think one of them absolutely has to be Mafia here.

Someone else has fooled me so far.

I don't like Kak and Flum, but that doesn't mean either are Mafia. I will just have to review and figure it out.

I feel good about Bunny though.

Jamie? You never mention.

Jamie-Sweet scumteam? Does that hold?

[BunnyGo]

Holy moly ghug and Jamie's conversation reads as thinly veiled Mafia communication. Sounds like ghug wants to shoot Bunny or I.

Jamiet says he wants to holster.

Paranoid much?

Yes

Yup...Jamie-sweet?

[BunnyGo]

Thanks a lot!

Then, @players, would it be a good idea to no-kill here? see if mafia shoots today? Do a check if worcej is just trying to fool us all?

We wouldn't really lose the situation we are in right now, if mafia doesn't shoot, right? We would get more time to think and let people add their thoughts. And IF mafia actually shoots today, we get information.

Like, it's 5-2 now, if they shoot, it's 4-2 and they only have one gun left. And we know one more lock town by their target.

If they don't shoot, we are still 5-2, and have nothing lost.

In both scenarios, we lose if we misvote, so it's better to draw this out, right?

Thoughts?

I'm using my vote...Also I think you and I are correctly widely townread; so our 3 partners should have an easier time solving here.

[ghug]

EOD2 Votes:
Ya'll hammered Just - not going to go back and manually get them (lowkey love/hate you all as I had to fuck with the bot lol...)

...


fine - do it myself.png

Surprise surprise.

Kak and Bunny looking suspicious AF.

##VOTE Just
##END

You drove me off Just with your weird posting.

But now that NOBODY entered scum kill orders…

##vote Just ##end

##VOTE Just
##END

If he is not modkilled, let's Speedwagon and give Mafia no vig shots.

I'm in.

##Vote Just
##End

##Vote Just

##END

##VOTE Just
##END

(For the bot)

##Vote Just
##End

For the bot, and for justice!

Hmm, I could be very overthinking this, true.

Argh, I hope I make no mistake and let mafia guide a misvote on a towny.

Then again, he is pretty in the PoE, so I guess not much lost.

##vote JustAnImposterNamedWill
##end

so, if I hadn't make a mistake, it would look something like this:


Final Day 2 Vote Count:
JustAnImpostorNamedWill (5) - sweetandcool*, BunnyGo*, Jamiet99uk*, Fluminator*, Kakarroto*


so, what can we see/learn from this?

Sweet's first post looks bad. Throwing shade at kaka and me while hammering Just.

I'm more and more coming to the conclusion that sweet is just a caricature of himself. I can't follow any of his lines of thought or find much evidence that he is even thinking.

[ghug]

I still think Mafia was inactive.

This points to rdr and ghug (Heart really).

But I doubt it's that easy.

I think one of them absolutely has to be Mafia here.

Someone else has fooled me so far.

I don't like Kak and Flum, but that doesn't mean either are Mafia. I will just have to review and figure it out.

I feel good about Bunny though.

Jamie? You never mention.

Jamie-Sweet scumteam? Does that hold?

I still think rd and Kak are possibilities, but that's where I'm landing.

[ghug]

Thanks a lot!

Then, @players, would it be a good idea to no-kill here? see if mafia shoots today? Do a check if worcej is just trying to fool us all?

We wouldn't really lose the situation we are in right now, if mafia doesn't shoot, right? We would get more time to think and let people add their thoughts. And IF mafia actually shoots today, we get information.

Like, it's 5-2 now, if they shoot, it's 4-2 and they only have one gun left. And we know one more lock town by their target.

If they don't shoot, we are still 5-2, and have nothing lost.

In both scenarios, we lose if we misvote, so it's better to draw this out, right?

Thoughts?

I'm using my vote...Also I think you and I are correctly widely townread; so our 3 partners should have an easier time solving here.

Can you explain your read on Kak? I did townread him, but it's weaker than others and his day has been not great.

[ghug]

##VOTE Sweet

I think I feel better here.

Jamie not knowing both scum couldn't shoot on the same day is nagging at me.

[BunnyGo]

Wait a moment we still have a MK. Didn't someone say we didn't have one? And if we manage to take a shot away then we are doing great.

Yeah no way Mafia holsters here.

And no kill sucks, way better to just try to hit Mafia.

##VOTE ghug

Why do you think we have a miskill?

[BunnyGo]

...


fine - do it myself.png



















so, if I hadn't make a mistake, it would look something like this:


Final Day 2 Vote Count:
JustAnImpostorNamedWill (5) - sweetandcool*, BunnyGo*, Jamiet99uk*, Fluminator*, Kakarroto*


so, what can we see/learn from this?

Sweet's first post looks bad. Throwing shade at kaka and me while hammering Just.

I'm more and more coming to the conclusion that sweet is just a caricature of himself. I can't follow any of his lines of thought or find much evidence that he is even thinking.

Hello.

You agreeing with me always gets my hackles up.

[BunnyGo]

Jamie? You never mention.

Jamie-Sweet scumteam? Does that hold?

I still think rd and Kak are possibilities, but that's where I'm landing.

rdr is ALWAYS a possibility when he lurks this hard.

[BunnyGo]

Thanks a lot!

Then, @players, would it be a good idea to no-kill here? see if mafia shoots today? Do a check if worcej is just trying to fool us all?

We wouldn't really lose the situation we are in right now, if mafia doesn't shoot, right? We would get more time to think and let people add their thoughts. And IF mafia actually shoots today, we get information.

Like, it's 5-2 now, if they shoot, it's 4-2 and they only have one gun left. And we know one more lock town by their target.

If they don't shoot, we are still 5-2, and have nothing lost.

In both scenarios, we lose if we misvote, so it's better to draw this out, right?

Thoughts?

I'm using my vote...Also I think you and I are correctly widely townread; so our 3 partners should have an easier time solving here.

Can you explain your read on Kak? I did townread him, but it's weaker than others and his day has been not great.

He's confident. He's not JUST posting fluff; there's thoughts (sometimes clearly wrong, but still thoughts). He was willing to die without shooting.

[BunnyGo]

##VOTE Sweet

I think I feel better here.

Jamie not knowing both scum couldn't shoot on the same day is nagging at me.

He didn't? I missed that

[BunnyGo]

##vote sweet.

And bedtime. Taking the train tomorrow, so will have 2-3 hours with little to do but fiddle with my phone.

[ghug]

Sweet's first post looks bad. Throwing shade at kaka and me while hammering Just.

I'm more and more coming to the conclusion that sweet is just a caricature of himself. I can't follow any of his lines of thought or find much evidence that he is even thinking.

Hello.

You agreeing with me always gets my hackles up.

I suspect that the game would be progressing differently if either of us were scum, so I'm treating you as a townie and trying to solve. I can understand why that would be disconcerting.

[ghug]

If we get one wrong, it's 4-2, and then we do have to speedhammer.

Wrong. Only one vig shot is allowed per day. Do you see it now?

Ohhhhhhh.

[Kakarroto]

Thanks a lot!

Then, @players, would it be a good idea to no-kill here? see if mafia shoots today? Do a check if worcej is just trying to fool us all?

We wouldn't really lose the situation we are in right now, if mafia doesn't shoot, right? We would get more time to think and let people add their thoughts. And IF mafia actually shoots today, we get information.

Like, it's 5-2 now, if they shoot, it's 4-2 and they only have one gun left. And we know one more lock town by their target.

If they don't shoot, we are still 5-2, and have nothing lost.

In both scenarios, we lose if we misvote, so it's better to draw this out, right?

Thoughts?

If worcej were fucking with us, which I am confident he is not, we'd have won already. There's no reason to worsen our position to check.

what do you mean, worsen our position?

You mean having more town? I don't think this is as good of an advantage here than you think. We have practically no information about what mafia thinks, and a lot of us, if not all, are just guessing at this point.

Also looking at some scenarios, I want mafia to use their shots as soon as possible, like, if we don't do it now, we just get into a worse and worse scenario. We should've done it yesterday, or even the day before, but I didn't think of that possibility until today and asked worcej about it.

So we need to get mafia to use their shots, even if that reduces our numbers now, we will be much safer later. And we gain finally some insight into mafia's mind here, who they want removed.

I'll go through the new posts firsts and post my thoughts about that after, had some thoughts about that before I went to bed and tried to unravel it first thing today, so have a look out for when I post them.