WebMafia Olympics: Bonus Qualification Round

[Hamilton Brian]

Why no long setup analysis post this game?

A: Haven't gotten to it yet
B: Apparently I post long posts when I'm scum.

I assumed at this point that B is made up by brain to push you when you are town tbh so now your lazy low effort posts feel scummy tbh.

Remember that B was also created by mafia!Brain trying to create the false case on Dip (which I fell for in that game). It's a good observation to tuck in your pocket.

[BunnyGo]

A: Haven't gotten to it yet
B: Apparently I post long posts when I'm scum.

I assumed at this point that B is made up by brain to push you when you are town tbh so now your lazy low effort posts feel scummy tbh.

Remember that B was also created by mafia!Brain trying to create the false case on Dip (which I fell for in that game). It's a good observation to tuck in your pocket.

What’s your point?

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes.

His posts seem filler; mech focused; self defense oriented; off balance. But at the end of the day: vibes.

This may be normal town!Haze. I can’t convince myself yet it isn’t.

Not the reason you originally gave for your vote, though.

Yes. He’s posted more since then. I honestly couldn’t tell you without checking what I said. It was something that kotp had said I agreed with.

No, it was D&W, as I have mentioned.

Are you usually this forgetful?

[Chaqa]

Attention:

The Gambler gets a N0 action and not all players have noticed that this is the case.

This information is contained in (a) the Setup Document, and (b) the Gambler's Role PM.

In both (a) and (b) the information is assumed to be word-for-word identical.


Interest':

Will noticed that I was aware of the fact that the Gambler gets a N0 action.

Will claims he set up a reaction test, to try to discover whether I read this information in (a) the Setup Document, or (b) the Gambler's Role PM. (Since if the answer is (b), then I am scum).


Decision:

If the information is EXACTLY THE SAME in both sources, then why would I respond differently to the test in case (b), compared to case (a)??

Will, please explain why Scum!Jamie, who is in possession of the Gambler Role PM, would react totally differently, in your test, to Town!Jamie who has read the EXACT SAME WORDS in the Setup Document.

What was the scum reaction that you were looking for, in the even that your test would have caught me as scum?

Action
Jamie caught, lockscum gg

Are you still high?

How did you insert an "Action" into my post?

[Jamiet99uk]

Action
Jamie caught, lockscum gg

Are you still high?

How did you insert an "Action" into my post?

I used the keyboard on my computer.

[Hamilton Brian]

I think jamie is town but that’s my only tr atm

Why on earth would you think that this version of Jamie is town?

He seems like the only one reading and contributing a lot while also not making stuff up tbh. Like I genuinely think he is the most towny person in the game

Due to a specific post, and if so can you refer me to it, or is it because Dip and Will are scumming jamie with you, so it's a biased read? If it's the latter, nothing wrong with it, just want it acknowledged.

[Hamilton Brian]

What a strange post.

But I can't recall D&W doing anything like this when he was scum before.

I am tired of people asking me for explanations of readlists I drafted in 10 seconds.
To your credit, though, this mostly happened in past games on the redacted website that does not exist.

I just dont understand why you are doing it tho, but if you dont want to explain them, then I'll just act like they arent even there cause their helping no one

Is it Dip making a mockery of the process of early reads lists or are they openwolfing?

[Hamilton Brian]

##Call GM

It says that if Buff Boy targets mafia, buff boy won't learn anything but mafia will. Will the identity of buff boy be revealed to mafia in whatever they get in the PM?

Yes, Mafia will learn the Buff Boy's identity. The Buff Boy will be blissfully unaware and receive no information except that they did not find the Champion.

NGL I dont even think this matters there are what 11 people in this game? 10 by the end of D1, if things go right for the mafia multi kills can start coming on down . Gotta use your role on someone you think is most likely mafia N2 or N1, use it early before you lose it

You're probably right; odds of landing on mafia early on is low.

[BunnyGo]

Not the reason you originally gave for your vote, though.

Yes. He’s posted more since then. I honestly couldn’t tell you without checking what I said. It was something that kotp had said I agreed with.

No, it was D&W, as I have mentioned.

Are you usually this forgetful?

Yes

[Hamilton Brian]

D&W, if you're town, who is your third guess for scum (since you're certainly wrong about me)?

Most likely Chaqa for wanting to sheep.

I’m gonna continue to sheep you once I’m caught up

Why are you linking yourself to Dip?

And from the bot vote count you abandoned that posture?

[BunnyGo]

Yes. He’s posted more since then. I honestly couldn’t tell you without checking what I said. It was something that kotp had said I agreed with.

No, it was D&W, as I have mentioned.

Are you usually this forgetful?

Yes

It's a big reason I don't like D1...I don't have notes from previous games, and it takes me a while to settle in to a game. And then I always have to reread to double check my facts and insights. I'm only 4 pages into my reread this game.

[Yoyoyozo]

I was busy yesterday but it appears we have some interesting developments. I’ll catch up during my lunch break

[BunnyGo]

I was busy yesterday but it appears we have some interesting developments. I’ll catch up during my lunch break

A ravenous Yoyo appears!

[BunnyGo]

I was busy yesterday but it appears we have some interesting developments. I’ll catch up during my lunch break

Why do you think there's interesting developments?

[Jamiet99uk]

I was busy yesterday but it appears we have some interesting developments. I’ll catch up during my lunch break

Why do you think there's interesting developments?

Do you think there aren't?

[Jamiet99uk]

(Yoyo's last previous post was on page 9 so most of what has happened on D1 may be counted as "developments" since then).

[Hamilton Brian]

Haze with a Z is scummy for pontificating about the difference between gambling and betting instead of looking for scum.

What's scummier? Haze pontificating or your calling attention to it?

Its important a test Jamie failed BTW

Did he though? I think it was an 'absolute" stance that Will took. It sent me looking at the doc as soon as I read Will's post to check. I thought, "Are you that sure?"

[Chaqa]

Are you still high?

How did you insert an "Action" into my post?

I used the keyboard on my computer.

OK but *why*?

[BunnyGo]

I was busy yesterday but it appears we have some interesting developments. I’ll catch up during my lunch break

Why do you think there's interesting developments?

Do you think there aren't?

Those are two different statements

[DiplomacyandWarfare]

Alright here is my thought-through read list, in order:

---town---
DipandWar
kotp
BunnyGo ~ Will
HB
---null line---
FA (note: has not contributed)
ghug = damo = yoyoyozo (note: low-quality contributions)
Chaqa (note: wants to sheep)
---"I would be happy to wagon without external pressure" line---
Jamiet
Haze with a Z
---scum---

Interesting; feels early and I am not sure I note an earnestness of believability.

Say you make it to Final 3. Of your 4 townreads, excluding yourself naturally, which do you take to the final with you? Which of the 4 would you dread if they were mafia in Final 3?

Probably kotp and BunnyGo
and that would be you.