WebMafia Olympics - Game #2 - Star Trek TNG: The Republic of Q [GAME THREAD]

[Jamiet99uk]

GM NOTICE

Editing your posts, once they have been posted, IS NOT ALLOWED.

Thank you.

[damo666]

GM NOTICE

Editing other's posts, once they have been posted, IS ALLOWED.

Thank you.

Annoying isn't it?

[damo666]

I have proposed a solution. You should all nominate a scum pair. We then rank top 3 and top 2 survivors are the policy vote tomorrow.

Damo: Glitterbomb Chaqa

This is fucking stupid.

Now we have to get it 100% right tomorrow rather than getting it 33% or 50% right today.

I have updated the proposal but it still ends up with 2 nominees.

We do not need to get it 100% right. If we kill 1 scum and 1 town we go into D3 3-1

[worcej]

Feeling far more confident now that damo is obv!scum that tried his best to salvage the game.

[Jamiet99uk]

DAMO NOTICE

Eating other people's ice cream, without asking, IS NOT ALLOWED.

Thank you.

Annoying isn't it?

Almost unforgiveable.

[damo666]

DAMO NOTICE

Eating other people's ice cream, without asking, IS NOT ALLOWED.

Thank you.

Annoying isn't it?

Forgiveable.

[damo666]

Feeling far more confident now that damo is obv!scum that tried his best to salvage the game.

If I were scum the only people I could have been saving were Flav and Will. Now if I were scum I would know that this is easily identifiable by town and given multi daykilss are possible that would be a daft move. If I were scum with Will I'd have let sleeping dogs lie (and we both survive) and if I were scum with Flav I'd have let him die and (selfishly) survive.

Before TFB's lfischl I could have just left Will and Flav to die leaving myself to survive.

I am not scum and am fairly confident that neither are Flav and Will. I don't think you are either. This means both scum ae in {Chaqa, mrs Bomb, TFB & Eden}. I have absolute zero faith in my former Town reads.

I withdraw by vote for Eden as the nominator for and now vote Will.

Btw why is nobody else participating in my scheme? Even if you scumread me the scheme is sound from a TPOV.

If we kill only 2 tomorrow and it's me and another town we have lost.

[damo666]

Returning to the hospital, should be back ol for last hour or so of night.

[damo666]

If I'm right that the 2 scum are in {TFB, Chaqa, Gbomb and Eden} given that Chaqa and Gbomb voted for Eden this implies TFB is scum.

Now if TFB is scum why the lfischl vote. I guess he was thinking this was his best chance of getting 2 town kills instead of one.

Now I suppose TFB coyld be scum with Eden and they both did an excellent job looking like town but I think one of Gbomb or Chaqa more likely but slightly less likely to be Chaqa given his reaction.

SCUM

Most likely pair downwards

{TFB, gbomb}
{TFB, Chaqa}
{TFB, Eden}

[worcej]

Feeling far more confident now that damo is obv!scum that tried his best to salvage the game.

If I were scum the only people I could have been saving were Flav and Will. Now if I were scum I would know that this is easily identifiable by town and given multi daykilss are possible that would be a daft move. If I were scum with Will I'd have let sleeping dogs lie (and we both survive) and if I were scum with Flav I'd have let him die and (selfishly) survive.

Before TFB's lfischl I could have just left Will and Flav to die leaving myself to survive.

I am not scum and am fairly confident that neither are Flav and Will. I don't think you are either. This means both scum ae in {Chaqa, mrs Bomb, TFB & Eden}. I have absolute zero faith in my former Town reads.

I withdraw by vote for Eden as the nominator for and now vote Will.

Btw why is nobody else participating in my scheme? Even if you scumread me the scheme is sound from a TPOV.

If we kill only 2 tomorrow and it's me and another town we have lost.

I think no one wants to participate because you’re scum.

Also you called it a scheme.

[President Eden]

Btw why is nobody else participating in my scheme? Even if you scumread me the scheme is sound from a TPOV.

geez, describing it like that, who would be suspicious

Feeling far more confident now that damo is obv!scum that tried his best to salvage the game.

yea. His recent reads pivot is clearly just him manufacturing a worldview that conveniently lets him scumread the people who are auto-voting him tomorrow and townread the people who might wrongly bail him out. His position didn’t emerge from an organic reassessment of the game, just him “scheming” (literally his word not mine lol) about who his allies are. I suspect he’s giving you and only you a pass because he knows you’re going to die tonight

[worcej]

##call GM

How does end votes work in this setup?

[damo666]

{TFB, PE} go top

[GlitterBomb]

So how does night phase work compared to day? What are we supposed to be doing? Strategizing how not to lose I’m gathering? Other than Damo’s stupid idea of voting for me, what do we think? Eden suggests that we find the one most scum, makes sense, that’s kinda what I’ve been focusing on anyway.

I’d also like to point out the hypocrisy of Chaqa. He declared that he would vote for anyone who voted for Eden. But he did! Was that just to make up for the fact that he somehow didn’t know his Eden vote was real? Sounds like something someone would do if it was their first game…. But I didn’t make that mistake!

So again going back to Eden’s point - IF Damo is town, who do we find most likely to be mafia instead? I’m curious to know why Damo is so set on FB? All I see is that his vote on fisch opened up Damo to do his last minute vote and get rid of fisch and mess things up for us to get more than one kill. It essentially saved Will and Flav. So did FB know what he was doing and that Damo would inevitably take the bait of a last minute vote on a pretty obvi town read?

Flav and Will were high on vote counts - are they no longer on radar? FB had zero votes and I think we need to look at why, if they’re just super good at being scummy or if they’re just town.

Just my few thoughts at the moment.

[GlitterBomb]

{TFB, PE} go top

What does “go top” mean?

[Chaqa]

So how does night phase work compared to day? What are we supposed to be doing? Strategizing how not to lose I’m gathering? Other than Damo’s stupid idea of voting for me, what do we think? Eden suggests that we find the one most scum, makes sense, that’s kinda what I’ve been focusing on anyway.

I’d also like to point out the hypocrisy of Chaqa. He declared that he would vote for anyone who voted for Eden. But he did! Was that just to make up for the fact that he somehow didn’t know his Eden vote was real? Sounds like something someone would do if it was their first game…. But I didn’t make that mistake!

So again going back to Eden’s point - IF Damo is town, who do we find most likely to be mafia instead? I’m curious to know why Damo is so set on FB? All I see is that his vote on fisch opened up Damo to do his last minute vote and get rid of fisch and mess things up for us to get more than one kill. It essentially saved Will and Flav. So did FB know what he was doing and that Damo would inevitably take the bait of a last minute vote on a pretty obvi town read?

Flav and Will were high on vote counts - are they no longer on radar? FB had zero votes and I think we need to look at why, if they’re just super good at being scummy or if they’re just town.

Just my few thoughts at the moment.

I’ve been playing mafia here for like 10 years. This is the first game ever ever where we aren’t allowed to unvote. I fucked up lol

[damo666]

{TFB, PE} go top

What does “go top” mean?

They've become my most likely scumpair.

[damo666]

So how does night phase work compared to day? What are we supposed to be doing? Strategizing how not to lose I’m gathering? Other than Damo’s stupid idea of voting for me, what do we think? Eden suggests that we find the one most scum, makes sense, that’s kinda what I’ve been focusing on anyway.

I’d also like to point out the hypocrisy of Chaqa. He declared that he would vote for anyone who voted for Eden. But he did! Was that just to make up for the fact that he somehow didn’t know his Eden vote was real? Sounds like something someone would do if it was their first game…. But I didn’t make that mistake!

So again going back to Eden’s point - IF Damo is town, who do we find most likely to be mafia instead? I’m curious to know why Damo is so set on FB? All I see is that his vote on fisch opened up Damo to do his last minute vote and get rid of fisch and mess things up for us to get more than one kill. It essentially saved Will and Flav. So did FB know what he was doing and that Damo would inevitably take the bait of a last minute vote on a pretty obvi town read?

Flav and Will were high on vote counts - are they no longer on radar? FB had zero votes and I think we need to look at why, if they’re just super good at being scummy or if they’re just town.

Just my few thoughts at the moment.

Mafia have a scumchat so your opening looks like a townslip unless TFB tutored you.

[GlitterBomb]

So how does night phase work compared to day? What are we supposed to be doing? Strategizing how not to lose I’m gathering? Other than Damo’s stupid idea of voting for me, what do we think? Eden suggests that we find the one most scum, makes sense, that’s kinda what I’ve been focusing on anyway.

I’d also like to point out the hypocrisy of Chaqa. He declared that he would vote for anyone who voted for Eden. But he did! Was that just to make up for the fact that he somehow didn’t know his Eden vote was real? Sounds like something someone would do if it was their first game…. But I didn’t make that mistake!

So again going back to Eden’s point - IF Damo is town, who do we find most likely to be mafia instead? I’m curious to know why Damo is so set on FB? All I see is that his vote on fisch opened up Damo to do his last minute vote and get rid of fisch and mess things up for us to get more than one kill. It essentially saved Will and Flav. So did FB know what he was doing and that Damo would inevitably take the bait of a last minute vote on a pretty obvi town read?

Flav and Will were high on vote counts - are they no longer on radar? FB had zero votes and I think we need to look at why, if they’re just super good at being scummy or if they’re just town.

Just my few thoughts at the moment.

Mafia have a scumchat so your opening looks like a townslip unless TFB tutored you.

I’m aware that there’s a scumchat. Nobody has tutored me. You’re getting 100% pure GlitterBomb here. Lucky you. I was trying to establish that the plan is in fact supposed to be us strategizing and I had hoped we would keep the dialogue going to do so. Unless we are are toast as some are acting we are?

[GlitterBomb]

{TFB, PE} go top

What does “go top” mean?

They've become my most likely scumpair.

Got it - thanks for explaining.