M 90: Shootout at the Pretty Good Corral

[BunnyGo]

Can you be more specific? For example, did you consider this pointing out a good thing:

Yes. That’s a very towny post.


It’s incaccurate but town mentality motivated.

He also pointed out many mech and insight questions in public. Pointed out several key insights for me.

Will not consider voting him until much later.

OK, you are my next most likely mafia if RHK is town.

Literally nobody else agrees with you about that.

Damo and I agree about a LOT in his big post. I think rdr is not scum based on the late D1 push by Balki. But otherwise we agree about a lot.

I suggest you shoot fishy.

[Jamiet99uk]

This is the only post I could find where you town read him D3:

Do you think this is more active than what you have said previously?

What Bozo?

It is currently D3, and on p.145 Sweet posted a big long post, directed at you, saying "JAMIE IS TOWN".

You READ that post because you replied "If Jamie is mafia, his reaction in his posts was what he wants us to think his reaction was, not necessarily what it was.".

Why are you now pretending that post from Sweetandcool never existed??

OK, there were 2 posts. Were the details of that post accurate?

There were two posts, one of which went into great detail, and which you replied to, and then conveniently forgot about.

The details of that post were setting out what it would look like if I was scum contriving to pretend to get emotional. As I read it, Sweet concluded that this is not an accurate picture of what actually happened, and that my reaction was genuine, not contrived, and that I am Town.

This is the correct conclusion. I am Town.

[BunnyGo]

Bozo is playing the role of detective, but he is wearing a mask. As I have just demonstrated, he is getting so deep into play-acting the investigative scum-hunter, that he is losing track of his own arguments and forgetting about very significant post exchanges which he himself was part of.

Agreed. @bozo unless you shoot scum today you’re in my top 3.

Can you be more specific about what you agree with?

It feels like you’re portraying yourself being solvy town rather than are actually being yourself being solvy town.

[Jamiet99uk]

Bozo is playing the role of detective, but he is wearing a mask. As I have just demonstrated, he is getting so deep into play-acting the investigative scum-hunter, that he is losing track of his own arguments and forgetting about very significant post exchanges which he himself was part of.

Agreed. @bozo unless you shoot scum today you’re in my top 3.

Can you be more specific about what you agree with?

He agrees with what I said.

[bozotheclown]

What Bozo?

It is currently D3, and on p.145 Sweet posted a big long post, directed at you, saying "JAMIE IS TOWN".

You READ that post because you replied "If Jamie is mafia, his reaction in his posts was what he wants us to think his reaction was, not necessarily what it was.".

Why are you now pretending that post from Sweetandcool never existed??

OK, there were 2 posts. Were the details of that post accurate?

There were two posts, one of which went into great detail, and which you replied to, and then conveniently forgot about.

The details of that post were setting out what it would look like if I was scum contriving to pretend to get emotional. As I read it, Sweet concluded that this is not an accurate picture of what actually happened, and that my reaction was genuine, not contrived, and that I am Town.

This is the correct conclusion. I am Town.

Did you know sweetandcool has been town reading you since D1?

[bozotheclown]

Yes. That’s a very towny post.


It’s incaccurate but town mentality motivated.

He also pointed out many mech and insight questions in public. Pointed out several key insights for me.

Will not consider voting him until much later.

OK, you are my next most likely mafia if RHK is town.

Literally nobody else agrees with you about that.

Damo and I agree about a LOT in his big post. I think rdr is not scum based on the late D1 push by Balki. But otherwise we agree about a lot.

I suggest you shoot fishy.

Can you tell me why you think kingofthepirates and lfischl are mafia?

[DemonRHK]

Morning all. I'm caught up.

bozo is town. I think his waving the gun around threatening is dumb, but scum don't claim guns.

The RB claim from kotp is fucking me up. With a dead cop the RB is useless, why even use it?

So there are two schools of thought:

The RB is real, and the scum team has no goddamn clue what they are doing. Which would make me suspect Flav, fish, and likely a heavy lurk like rdr.

The RB is a ploy, which leads me to a big brain play attempt, I think king was browbeat into the claim by a teammate. That leads me to Jamie. Jamie, Flav, fish?

The issue lies with bozo right now. Us winning or losing is on him. He's going to fucking shoot me, and has made no attempt to hide it. That means if we kill wrong, AND scum has a gun, we lose.

We have to be right today, and there is one scum I am sure on.

##Vote Flav

And for senor 2nd amendment, I'm currently on Flav, fish, rdr.

[bozotheclown]

this is pretty pathetic. its not like I dont know what youre doing.


what will we do without chaqa
the guy who I never followed on any of his scumreads is gone... what ever will I do
theres just... no taste left in my mouth.. only ashes

Hmmm, well it is true I ended up mostly agreeing with Eden. When we flip King I will have the satisfaction of correctly scumreading two scum. Eden will be so pleased.

I haven't followed your scumreads either this game because you've been pretty off with your tunnels.

Still bizarre you haven't bothered trying to DK me. It's almost like you don't actually believe that I'm Mafia.

I haven't followed your scumreads either this game because you've been pretty off with your tunnels.

Balki was one of my scumreads. quite consistently and often in fact. Another of my tunnels was flav, who you are now stating you think is mafia and youd like to build a case on him. Another person ive scumread has been Jamie who has been trying to kill you for a week now and you seem to enjoy that.

Didn't anyone else read N2 and wonder why the mafia chose to NK someone who they knew already used their gun?

[bozotheclown]

Morning all. I'm caught up.

bozo is town. I think his waving the gun around threatening is dumb, but scum don't claim guns.

The RB claim from kotp is fucking me up. With a dead cop the RB is useless, why even use it?

So there are two schools of thought:

The RB is real, and the scum team has no goddamn clue what they are doing. Which would make me suspect Flav, fish, and likely a heavy lurk like rdr.

The RB is a ploy, which leads me to a big brain play attempt, I think king was browbeat into the claim by a teammate. That leads me to Jamie. Jamie, Flav, fish?

The issue lies with bozo right now. Us winning or losing is on him. He's going to fucking shoot me, and has made no attempt to hide it. That means if we kill wrong, AND scum has a gun, we lose.

We have to be right today, and there is one scum I am sure on.

##Vote Flav

And for senor 2nd amendment, I'm currently on Flav, fish, rdr.

Why are you sure about Flavius?

[bozotheclown]

Predictions of the final 3 mafia:

bozo: RHK, Jamie, sweetandcool
sweetandcool: Flavius, kingofthepirates, bozo
Jamie: bozo, lfischl, kingofthepirates
rdrivera: lfischl, Jamie, Flavius
BunnyGo: kingofthepirates, lfischl, Jamie
damo: kingofthepirates, lfischl, RHK
RHK: Flavius, lfischl, rdrivera

[DemonRHK]

Why are you sure about Flavius?

Balki.

D1, Flav was out doing that parroting bullshit, and Balki came in white knighting for him.

I backed off D2 because I did that tunnel shit last game and got a PR killed.

Then Eden came out with that scan, and we got Balki. It makes D1 make so much god damn sense.

[lfischl]

Predictions of the final 3 mafia:

bozo: RHK, Jamie, sweetandcool
sweetandcool: Flavius, kingofthepirates, bozo
Jamie: bozo, lfischl, kingofthepirates
rdrivera: lfischl, Jamie, Flavius
BunnyGo: kingofthepirates, lfischl, Jamie
damo: kingofthepirates, lfischl, RHK
RHK: Flavius, lfischl, rdrivera

Jamie, kingofthepirates, rdr

Still catching up, internet is awful right now so that and responses will be slow

[kingofthepirates]

Good morning everyone. gun analysis ended up being a brick wall since it had assumptions regarding flavor and Balki's status (mainly the latter). 2 predictions for final scum are as follows:
1. Flavius. Already mentioned before.
2. fish. several people complaining about my lurking and fluff (and yes, I was sick following a 4th of July outing), but from my bot reading, fish has added even less than I have (objectively by character count, and IMHO substance).

scum number 3 eludes me, I'll read back more in the afternoon. Last night (in bed thinking) I was entertaining ideas of rdr or jamie for final scum, but I intend on reading through the bot more to see if there's any sort of suspicious interaction between my first 2 scum predictions and anyone else.

[kingofthepirates]

@King - Just for me to understand, you are claiming RB on N1 or N2?

sorry I missed this. I claim RB N2

[Jamiet99uk]

OK, there were 2 posts. Were the details of that post accurate?

There were two posts, one of which went into great detail, and which you replied to, and then conveniently forgot about.

The details of that post were setting out what it would look like if I was scum contriving to pretend to get emotional. As I read it, Sweet concluded that this is not an accurate picture of what actually happened, and that my reaction was genuine, not contrived, and that I am Town.

This is the correct conclusion. I am Town.

Did you know sweetandcool has been town reading you since D1?

We were arguing so much on D1 that I did not think he was.

It became clear to when he explicitly started saying it.

Why?

[Jamiet99uk]

this is pretty pathetic. its not like I dont know what youre doing.

what will we do without chaqa
the guy who I never followed on any of his scumreads is gone... what ever will I do
theres just... no taste left in my mouth.. only ashes

Hmmm, well it is true I ended up mostly agreeing with Eden. When we flip King I will have the satisfaction of correctly scumreading two scum. Eden will be so pleased.

I haven't followed your scumreads either this game because you've been pretty off with your tunnels.

Still bizarre you haven't bothered trying to DK me. It's almost like you don't actually believe that I'm Mafia.

I haven't followed your scumreads either this game because you've been pretty off with your tunnels.

Balki was one of my scumreads. quite consistently and often in fact. Another of my tunnels was flav, who you are now stating you think is mafia and youd like to build a case on him. Another person ive scumread has been Jamie who has been trying to kill you for a week now and you seem to enjoy that.

Didn't anyone else read N2 and wonder why the mafia chose to NK someone who they knew already used their gun?

I suggested a theory.

Didn't you notice?

[Jamiet99uk]

@Bozo:

This it was if reminding you need:

Ack, RIP Brainbomb.

I'm wondering if scum killed him there to lock in his (inaccurate) read on me. Clearly he was as keen as mustard to send me to Boot Hill. But sadly that would not be in Town's interests.

[kingofthepirates]

Predictions of the final 3 mafia:

bozo: RHK, Jamie, sweetandcool
sweetandcool: Flavius, kingofthepirates, bozo
Jamie: bozo, lfischl, kingofthepirates
rdrivera: lfischl, Jamie, Flavius
BunnyGo: kingofthepirates, lfischl, Jamie
damo: kingofthepirates, lfischl, RHK
RHK: Flavius, lfischl, rdrivera

Jamie, kingofthepirates, rdr

Still catching up, internet is awful right now so that and responses will be slow

Imma do a quick count, including my scum prediction of flav and lfischl (with an empty slot 3).

RHK 2
Jamie 4
sweet 1
Flav 4
kotp 5
bozo 2
lfischl 6
rdr 2
damo 0
bunny 0

[rdrivera2005]

Morning all. I'm caught up.

bozo is town. I think his waving the gun around threatening is dumb, but scum don't claim guns.

The RB claim from kotp is fucking me up. With a dead cop the RB is useless, why even use it?

So there are two schools of thought:

The RB is real, and the scum team has no goddamn clue what they are doing. Which would make me suspect Flav, fish, and likely a heavy lurk like rdr.

The RB is a ploy, which leads me to a big brain play attempt, I think king was browbeat into the claim by a teammate. That leads me to Jamie. Jamie, Flav, fish?

The issue lies with bozo right now. Us winning or losing is on him. He's going to fucking shoot me, and has made no attempt to hide it. That means if we kill wrong, AND scum has a gun, we lose.

We have to be right today, and there is one scum I am sure on.

##Vote Flav

And for senor 2nd amendment, I'm currently on Flav, fish, rdr.

You said you are caught up so why you didn't consider the idea that was already mentioned that scum could have RBed Kotp to set him up?

And I would never use a RB in this situation with scum winning so your reasoning is weird.

And why you are so sure Bozo is shooting you?

[DemonRHK]

You said you are caught up so why you didn't consider the idea that was already mentioned that scum could have RBed Kotp to set him up?

And I would never use a RB in this situation with scum winning so your reasoning is weird.

And why you are so sure Bozo is shooting you?

- I did, but every player needs to draw their own conclusions. Just because someone else mentions something doesn't mean anyone else does, and it would be dumb as shit to ignore the possibility.

-That may be, but you are also are low activity, and going away for a whole night and letting your scumteam decided what to do would be in your wheelhouse. No offense.

- Because I'm apparently his top scumread and every third post is why I am satan incarnate.