M 90: Shootout at the Pretty Good Corral

[damo666]

I have lots of triplets as possible scumteams but for the sake of bozo's survey I will say {kotp, lfischl, demonRHK}.


This leaves those 3 and Flav as not having taken part.

If there are not at least 2 scum in those 4 I'll be amazed.

[Jamiet99uk]

Not to me, we should consider kingofthepirates cleared town since we don't have any room for error.

Well I don't agree.

Do you think kingofthepirates is fake claiming RB as mafia, then? He was not one of your 3 scum predictions, are you updating your prediction based on his RB claim?

I am not sure. My point was that I am not just going to jump to an immediate conclusion, as you have done.

[Jamiet99uk]

If Jamie is mafia, his reaction in his posts was what he wants us to think his reaction was, not necessarily what it was.

Yes, but also no. I am confident that Hamiet would be viscerally furious. In fact, if I was his teammate he could have authentically unloaded on me. He hates fake claiming and inconsistency and that beginning of day claim drove him insane and he would have gone bonkers is we were teammates.

We are absolutely not teammates.

I think he is Town.

But it's obviously not definitive.

But it is definitive that we are not teammates. And basing your theories on that assumption is incorrect and leads to a loss for Town.

Sweet asserts that I am town, and that I am definitely not his team mate.

This appears to be a scum claim since the only way I can be town and definitively not Sweet's team-mate is if he is scum and knows I am town.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why would the Mafia even use the roleblock after Eden died. It can't roleblock people getting guns, I'm sure.

I don't know, but they practically town cleared kingofthepirates by doing it, I think the chance that kingofthepirates would fake claim a RB as mafia here is very small.

Yet you believe I came up with an insane fake claim play, and Jamiet engaged in convincing theater with me, and Balki joined in, and Jaimet improvised fake rage?

If you are going to be skeptical, please do not be selectively skeptical.

And on the other hand, this is fair comment.

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes, but also no. I am confident that Hamiet would be viscerally furious. In fact, if I was his teammate he could have authentically unloaded on me. He hates fake claiming and inconsistency and that beginning of day claim drove him insane and he would have gone bonkers is we were teammates.

We are absolutely not teammates.

I think he is Town.

But it's obviously not definitive.

But it is definitive that we are not teammates. And basing your theories on that assumption is incorrect and leads to a loss for Town.

Did you mean to say "not scum teammates"?

*Sigh* yes.

Is quibbling necessary?

Maybe I scum slipped. At least now Jamiet is clear, yay!

Hooray, I am a Town Clear.

[Jamiet99uk]

I’m the sheriff. I got a guilty scan on KotP. ##vote king ##end. See you nerds tomorrow.

Ho ho ho.

[Jamiet99uk]

I’m the sheriff. I got a guilty scan on KotP. ##vote king ##end. See you nerds tomorrow.

can't argue with the sheriff... ##vote king

Since I don't trust my sarcasm to get through the computer, THIS IS A JOKE!

random impulse gun analysis coming soon (to an AMC near you!)

I notice that although this was a joke, Kingo'Pirates has kept his vote on himself.

[Jamiet99uk]

Cool beans. Don’t f*** it up.

Why did you hold your shot yesterday?

I was not confident on any mafia, and missing could cost town the game. I think we need to use the shot today, as well as any other shots if other town guns activated.

^ This statement ^

Is not consistent with this statement, made a page before:

I always thought Jamie was a good scum candidate.

[Jamiet99uk]

Why would he be surprised by your "sudden" town read of him if you have been town reading him since at least 2 hours before D1 EOD?

My sudden ACTIVE Townread of him. That is what he is surprised by.

As opposed to my previous PASSIVE town read of him.

There is a huge difference.

E.g. I passively Townread RHK. But if I had time to critically analyze him in the most rigorous way possible, I would either find reasons to possibly scumread him, or my passive Townread of him would solidify into an active Townread of him.

This is the only post I could find where you town read him D3:

I don't think he was wrong about you.

You know, that's a good point. I think he WAS wrong about you.

So Mafia team is screwing with us.

Do you think this is more active than what you have said previously?

What Bozo?

It is currently D3, and on p.145 Sweet posted a big long post, directed at you, saying "JAMIE IS TOWN".

You READ that post because you replied "If Jamie is mafia, his reaction in his posts was what he wants us to think his reaction was, not necessarily what it was.".

Why are you now pretending that post from Sweetandcool never existed??

[Jamiet99uk]

Bozo is playing the role of detective, but he is wearing a mask. As I have just demonstrated, he is getting so deep into play-acting the investigative scum-hunter, that he is losing track of his own arguments and forgetting about very significant post exchanges which he himself was part of.

[sweetandcool]

If Jamie is mafia, his reaction in his posts was what he wants us to think his reaction was, not necessarily what it was.

Yes, but also no. I am confident that Hamiet would be viscerally furious. In fact, if I was his teammate he could have authentically unloaded on me. He hates fake claiming and inconsistency and that beginning of day claim drove him insane and he would have gone bonkers is we were teammates.

We are absolutely not teammates.

I think he is Town.

But it's obviously not definitive.

But it is definitive that we are not teammates. And basing your theories on that assumption is incorrect and leads to a loss for Town.

Sweet asserts that I am town, and that I am definitely not his team mate.

This appears to be a scum claim since the only way I can be town and definitively not Sweet's team-mate is if he is scum and knows I am town.

[Jamiet99uk]

My sudden ACTIVE Townread of him. That is what he is surprised by.

As opposed to my previous PASSIVE town read of him.

There is a huge difference.

E.g. I passively Townread RHK. But if I had time to critically analyze him in the most rigorous way possible, I would either find reasons to possibly scumread him, or my passive Townread of him would solidify into an active Townread of him.

This is the only post I could find where you town read him D3:

I don't think he was wrong about you.

You know, that's a good point. I think he WAS wrong about you.

So Mafia team is screwing with us.

Do you think this is more active than what you have said previously?

If Bozo was actually investigating my alignment, and Sweet's alignment, in the sincere manner he is attempting to present, I purport that he would not have made this post because it contradicts his own line of argument.

[Jamiet99uk]

I think that Sweet is right.

I think we are both town, and this whole thing between us since D1 has been a distracting mess.

##Vote Bozo

[damo666]

I think that Sweet is right.

I think we are both town, and this whole thing between us since D1 has been a distracting mess.

##Vote Bozo

First part correct.

Vote bad. Bozo is town and is either a poor detective or conducting a reaction test experiment (which is now spoilt).

[rdrivera2005]

I think Bozo is scum.

And think lfischl is probably scum.

Bunny, Demon and Sweet are town and probably Brain too.

What was your reason for suspecting me when you posted this?

Your D1 voting and I was feeling some apathy on you (and Balki) that didn't ping me as town.

[rdrivera2005]

@King - Just for me to understand, you are claiming RB on N1 or N2?

[BunnyGo]

Why not RHK?

Too towny. Pointing out too many good things and pushing in good ways.

Can you be more specific? For example, did you consider this pointing out a good thing:

##Vote Bunny

I don't feel any hunting from bunny. Just a lot of one liners and hedging. The vote pattern on D1 throws me off too. Way too much waffling to the point of trying to drum up artificial pressure. Just seems disinterested?

Yes. That’s a very towny post.


It’s incaccurate but town mentality motivated.

He also pointed out many mech and insight questions in public. Pointed out several key insights for me.

Will not consider voting him until much later.

[BunnyGo]

If Jamie is mafia, his reaction in his posts was what he wants us to think his reaction was, not necessarily what it was.

Yes, but also no. I am confident that Hamiet would be viscerally furious. In fact, if I was his teammate he could have authentically unloaded on me. He hates fake claiming and inconsistency and that beginning of day claim drove him insane and he would have gone bonkers is we were teammates.

We are absolutely not teammates.

I think he is Town.

But it's obviously not definitive.

But it is definitive that we are not teammates. And basing your theories on that assumption is incorrect and leads to a loss for Town.

Sweet asserts that I am town, and that I am definitely not his team mate.

This appears to be a scum claim since the only way I can be town and definitively not Sweet's team-mate is if he is scum and knows I am town.

That is a shocking claim.

[rdrivera2005]

@Bunny - Why are you so sure about King you are ebd voting him?
By the way, he is one I can vote today other then the three I nominated.

And why Flavius is town?

[BunnyGo]

Bozo is playing the role of detective, but he is wearing a mask. As I have just demonstrated, he is getting so deep into play-acting the investigative scum-hunter, that he is losing track of his own arguments and forgetting about very significant post exchanges which he himself was part of.

Agreed. @bozo unless you shoot scum today you’re in my top 3.