M 90: Shootout at the Pretty Good Corral

[President Eden]

Independent of wagonometrics I think the pool I would shoot from is foodcoats, KOTP, fishy, D&W, worcej, rdr. That’s not in any specific order either

Add in DemonRHK and remove Lfischl and I agree.

I don’t mind adding RHK, but what makes you want to take fishy out the pool? You know he’ll die if he’s outside the water too long

[Vecna]

BB, D&W, Food, HB, Bozo

My current guess is that group contains all 4 scum

[Chaqa]

Someone should shoot Jamie for over 200 posts on D1 btw.

That's a crime worth killing for.

It's OK. Half of them are about Sweet and the other half are about UK elections or pronunciation.

[damo666]

BB, D&W, Food, HB, Bozo

My current guess is that group contains all 4 scum

I'll give you evens

[lfischl]

BB, D&W, Food, HB, Bozo

My current guess is that group contains all 4 scum

I’d take brain out of that group

[BunnyGo]

I've gone to the pub because I hoped the pub quiz would be on.

The pub quiz isn't on but I've just been bought a drink by a group of random people who appear to be celebrating the fact that one of them just got out of prison.

I may or may not still be here for EoD.

that sounds like fun.

dont make any mentions of dropping the soap

Or that you're a solicitor

[Chaqa]

You aren't adding anything. You aren't making case, giving ideas.

You are HECKLING every person in the game from the BALCONY. You have just served to shade every post in the game.

There is no solving, it's all stirring the pot. All carbs no meat.

I quite strongly disagree with you on this one. I think Flavius has been very productive and driving conversation.

If anyone here is all carbs, it's you.

[BunnyGo]

You guys are trying to put me face down in the dust so you can check out my assless chaps, is that it?

I didn't know there would be cake.

The cake is a lie

[BunnyGo]

You aren't adding anything. You aren't making case, giving ideas.

You are HECKLING every person in the game from the BALCONY. You have just served to shade every post in the game.

There is no solving, it's all stirring the pot. All carbs no meat.

I quite strongly disagree with you on this one. I think Flavius has been very productive and driving conversation.

If anyone here is all carbs, it's you.

take my upvote

[damo666]

I've gone to the pub because I hoped the pub quiz would be on.

The pub quiz isn't on but I've just been bought a drink by a group of random people who appear to be celebrating the fact that one of them just got out of prison.

I may or may not still be here for EoD.

that sounds like fun.

dont make any mentions of dropping the soap

Or that you're a solicitor

Or a plain clothes cop

[Balki Bartokomous]

235 posts from Jamiet? My goodness.

Sometimes I find myself just wanting to kill one of the low posters today because 20 posts is not enough. But then other times I find myself just wanting to kill Jamiet because 235 is too many. And other times I just want to kill sweetandcool because I'd like to see him die.

Towntree
Balki
KPOP
Falvius
Chaqa
Brainbomb

Wouldn't kill Bunnygo or Eden today, even though I don't really know what alignment they are.

I'm not feeling much conviction about anything else.

I still feel like Jamiet's interaction around the fake claims and his pity party seem insincere, and that he is likely our best chance to turn over a scumrock today.

What about KOTP strikes you as town? He's leaving little impression on me.

I found his first few posts to be very pure. But I want to give you a better answer than "vibes."

Here is a post he made on page 7:

jeez, 1.5 hours since I last read and we already have some fire works. oh boy! Here, have a (small) thought dump.

sweet, I have no clue what this kind of ridiculous gambit you have chosen to play is going to do, or what you hope to accomplish by it, but damn is it interesting. Still, its giving me the heebie jeebies. Too insane to judge alignment.

Jamie's coming hard right out the gate. Very unexpected. I'm hesitant to label it scum theater as others have, but this is VERY different from what I would expect. Too similar to what I would expect of mid-late game jamie to call it shitposting or gimmicks. I want to say slight mafia lean? but only barely.

personally I don't buy into shooting the lurkers D1. Give them some time to prove themselves.

Too lazy to judge anything else really. Balki seems to be his usual bubbly helpful self. that's all. more discussion to foll- SQUIRREL! *runs off cartoon style after a squirrel*

Here is a post he made on page 16:

So some questions I've had while catching up:
what's up with foodcoats? both vecna and bunny and scumming them, and for the life of me I can't tell why, outside of one comment about alleged buddying????
then why does damo want to shoot vecna???
are we still within shit posting time? are the above 2 issues both shit posting (doubtful since bunny is actually still on vecna)?

I think that the reason I am reacting positively to these posts is that he is questioning strands of thought in the thread and pushing back against some scumreads that I think lack much of a basis. He does this with reads on Sweet, Foodcoats, and Vecna, and it just looks different than what I expect of a scumplayer, who would be more inclined to support strands of thought that push kills. But they also just "look sincere" to me, and I grok the reasoning.

[Chaqa]

Foodcoats makes good sharp observations as town that make sense and that I can identify an investigative and inquiring mindset.

He has done nothing like that all game. He's been fluff-posting and being nice to people, and even his game-related posts are not strong at all so far.

As chaqa said, as soon as it became potentially dangerous to scumread Sweet (if youre a scum with allignment information) he suddenly backed off. Nothing changed there with that additional claim from a town pov.

But most importantly; its not about what he's said. Its about what he hasnt said. Anything that rings like towny observation. Foods often quite quick and clear in that regard.

Im gonna be honest I do NOT like that food has not been on for 21 hours I would >prefer< if he was here to actually defend himself, he hasnt been here for half the day...

Classic mafia strategy to withdraw into the shadows when suspected/voted.

I recall Food being especially poor under pressure, so this jives.

[damo666]

Let's REO rdr

[rdrivera2005]

I would wager large against that being the exact team. Quite large, at terrible odds.

I don't see Damo-Sweet as a pair. Would wager large against that pair alone.

I can see Balki-Eden as a pair. I can see Eden-Damo. I can see Eden-Sweet.

I think an Eden-Damo pair have high chances to be both Mafia. Balki is still null, which is bad. And Sweet is probably town.

What makes you pair Eden and Damo?

Basically I think both are scum, not necessarily tied. They both cast some opportunistic votes.

From a very personal POV both said I am scummy without any reasoning. And the fact Eden still didn't join Damo on my wagon could be something.

[lfischl]

Let's REO rdr

What does REO mean?

[BunnyGo]

I FEAR NO EVIL!

This is why the tie mechanic is pro town...

[damo666]

Let's REO rdr

What does REO mean?

speedwagon

[BunnyGo]

You guys still want to kill food after that assless chaps quip? I don't.

I am feeling ambivalent.

##vote rdrivera. I have him at Null. But I feel like I will have him at Null seven days from now as well. Let's do a solid for future Balki, and maybe he is scum.

this is your worst post so far this game...it makes me question if what we had was real

[Chaqa]

You guys still want to kill food after that assless chaps quip? I don't.

I am feeling ambivalent.

##vote rdrivera. I have him at Null. But I feel like I will have him at Null seven days from now as well. Let's do a solid for future Balki, and maybe he is scum.

ngl it made me almost think of moving my vote. Almost.

[Chaqa]

thank you for letting me pocket you btw chaqa

like a little baby kangaroo into the pouch you go

I don't really view you as a townread to be fair.