M 90: Shootout at the Pretty Good Corral

[sweetandcool]

Then why exactly did you?

Why not stay quiet about your role and just wait until you have a shot lined up?

We have a treasure trove of reactions to go through now :D

No regrets.

You know what? Fair enough.

You took a risk that the real Sheriff might have cc'ed you, but since that has not materialised, fair play, you did get some reactions.

I want to ask again: When you voted for "Bona", did you realise this would be counted by the Bot as a vote for Bozo? Did you purposely cast that vote in order to move off me? If yes, why did you then repeatedly claim your vote was still on me, when it wasn't? If no, what were you doing?

I believe your Desperado claim, I just want to understand your thought processes.

I am still baffled why that counted as a Bozo vote. Don't you need the first three letters to match?

I just assumed that it was an invalid vote.

[Jamiet99uk]

Okay guys, I feel absolutely horrible.

I was fake claiming Investigative Sheriff.

I am actually Desperado and am planning to shoot near EoD, about a half hour before deadline.

I will shoot the top wagon unless it is somehow me.

I was just claiming because I knew I would shoot today until I died.

##vote sweet

Why?

If he is not the real Desperado, the real Desperado can shoot him.

[Jamiet99uk]

We have a treasure trove of reactions to go through now :D

No regrets.

You know what? Fair enough.

You took a risk that the real Sheriff might have cc'ed you, but since that has not materialised, fair play, you did get some reactions.

I want to ask again: When you voted for "Bona", did you realise this would be counted by the Bot as a vote for Bozo? Did you purposely cast that vote in order to move off me? If yes, why did you then repeatedly claim your vote was still on me, when it wasn't? If no, what were you doing?

I believe your Desperado claim, I just want to understand your thought processes.

I am still baffled why that counted as a Bozo vote. Don't you need the first three letters to match?

I just assumed that it was an invalid vote.

I think it's the first two letters, if they are unique.

So, you had not noticed Bozo _self_voting_ in the same way, before you did it?

[Jamiet99uk]

Let's just check.

Note THIS IS ONLY A BOT OPERATIONS TEST.

##Vote Sw

[brainbomb]

I think I either want to vote Flav now or flip my foodcoats read and try vecna out as my hero here. If it fails and food isnt scum I would not immediately just assume vecna is mafia either. As he probably would assume that im setting him up using his expertise as a weapon.

But I am compelled by the research that vecna is often pretty good at reading food correctly when he does so right away

[sweetandcool]

You know what? Fair enough.

You took a risk that the real Sheriff might have cc'ed you, but since that has not materialised, fair play, you did get some reactions.

I want to ask again: When you voted for "Bona", did you realise this would be counted by the Bot as a vote for Bozo? Did you purposely cast that vote in order to move off me? If yes, why did you then repeatedly claim your vote was still on me, when it wasn't? If no, what were you doing?

I believe your Desperado claim, I just want to understand your thought processes.

I am still baffled why that counted as a Bozo vote. Don't you need the first three letters to match?

I just assumed that it was an invalid vote.

I think it's the first two letters, if they are unique.

So, you had not noticed Bozo _self_voting_ in the same way, before you did it?

Correct. Huh, always thought it was three letters.

[FlaviusAetius]

I am caught up and have to go do some work.

Reviewing the game so far, I have to vote for sweet. Sweet's claim is not beneficial, in my opinion, from any town role perspective. I see brain believes that it is a possible tactic to draw scum attention onto a VT, and I understand this. But I don't think that town trying to confuse mafia is a good play for town, because mafia have information, and town does not. Fake claims lead to misunderstanding and division for town. For example, mafia can profit from sweet's fakeclaim by simply ignoring him, enabling a suspicion-spiral later in the game. Sweet's play undermines the town more than it enables our PRs.

##VOTE sweetandcool

SO here's the issue with this number one if someone is claiming you should wait for that to be proven falsely instead of just immediately voting for them, we can discover sweet's fakeness this night so there's zero reason to actually vote him D1.
ALSO
you said sweet would be doing this regardless if you thought it was a bad idea then why didnt you say it then when he first said he was going to do it cause it was optimal town play sounds like YOU are switching up...WHY, NOW?

[Balki Bartokomous]

There is no way we want Desperado to shoot anyone today, and we simply cannot believe anything Sweet says. He has no credibility.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I am caught up and have to go do some work.

Reviewing the game so far, I have to vote for sweet. Sweet's claim is not beneficial, in my opinion, from any town role perspective. I see brain believes that it is a possible tactic to draw scum attention onto a VT, and I understand this. But I don't think that town trying to confuse mafia is a good play for town, because mafia have information, and town does not. Fake claims lead to misunderstanding and division for town. For example, mafia can profit from sweet's fakeclaim by simply ignoring him, enabling a suspicion-spiral later in the game. Sweet's play undermines the town more than it enables our PRs.

##VOTE sweetandcool

SO here's the issue with this number one if someone is claiming you should wait for that to be proven falsely instead of just immediately voting for them, we can discover sweet's fakeness this night so there's zero reason to actually vote him D1.
ALSO
you said sweet would be doing this regardless if you thought it was a bad idea then why didnt you say it then when he first said he was going to do it cause it was optimal town play sounds like YOU are switching up...WHY, NOW?

Sweet is not claiming, he is preening. Nobody should or would CC anything.

[FlaviusAetius]

I am caught up and have to go do some work.

Reviewing the game so far, I have to vote for sweet. Sweet's claim is not beneficial, in my opinion, from any town role perspective. I see brain believes that it is a possible tactic to draw scum attention onto a VT, and I understand this. But I don't think that town trying to confuse mafia is a good play for town, because mafia have information, and town does not. Fake claims lead to misunderstanding and division for town. For example, mafia can profit from sweet's fakeclaim by simply ignoring him, enabling a suspicion-spiral later in the game. Sweet's play undermines the town more than it enables our PRs.

##VOTE sweetandcool

VTs do not know if they are VT or not. This would be bad play.

In fact it is bad play whatever so ##vote sweet.

I just dont understand how you can say this he's literally claiming an IMPORTANT role are you really going to throw that away? Isnt it just POSSIBLE that Sweet is actually telling the truth, dont you want to wait for the night to see if he's telling the TRUTH or not? It just doesnt make sense

[kingofthepirates]

I am now totally lost in sauce (American pronunciation).
Sweet looks to have gone off his rocker, and I'm not inclined to touch that. Imho it's all a massive joke/gimmick with no particular end goal (assuming that sweet has indeed said out of game that he will be mass fake claiming).

I'd like to hear more from lfischl, who seems to have posted the least content of substance (perhaps with the exception of chaqa, but we at least have explanation of absence from chaqa and a promise to catch up, and nothing like that from lfischl).

[FlaviusAetius]

I am caught up and have to go do some work.

Reviewing the game so far, I have to vote for sweet. Sweet's claim is not beneficial, in my opinion, from any town role perspective. I see brain believes that it is a possible tactic to draw scum attention onto a VT, and I understand this. But I don't think that town trying to confuse mafia is a good play for town, because mafia have information, and town does not. Fake claims lead to misunderstanding and division for town. For example, mafia can profit from sweet's fakeclaim by simply ignoring him, enabling a suspicion-spiral later in the game. Sweet's play undermines the town more than it enables our PRs.

##VOTE sweetandcool

SO here's the issue with this number one if someone is claiming you should wait for that to be proven falsely instead of just immediately voting for them, we can discover sweet's fakeness this night so there's zero reason to actually vote him D1.
ALSO
you said sweet would be doing this regardless if you thought it was a bad idea then why didnt you say it then when he first said he was going to do it cause it was optimal town play sounds like YOU are switching up...WHY, NOW?

Sweet is not claiming, he is preening. Nobody should or would CC anything.

Preening has something to do with birds, there's no definition of it on the internet regarding anything related to mafia. AND he IS claiming he said he HARDCLAIMS investigative sheriff

[Hamilton Brian]

Okay guys, I feel absolutely horrible.

I was fake claiming Investigative Sheriff.

I am actually Desperado and am planning to shoot near EoD, about a half hour before deadline.

I will shoot the top wagon unless it is somehow me.

I was just claiming because I knew I would shoot today until I died.

##vote sweet

Why?

If he is not the real Desperado, the real Desperado can shoot him.

Yes and if Sweet is town both die. I am not convinced Sweet is scum here.

[sweetandcool]

SO here's the issue with this number one if someone is claiming you should wait for that to be proven falsely instead of just immediately voting for them, we can discover sweet's fakeness this night so there's zero reason to actually vote him D1.
ALSO
you said sweet would be doing this regardless if you thought it was a bad idea then why didnt you say it then when he first said he was going to do it cause it was optimal town play sounds like YOU are switching up...WHY, NOW?

Sweet is not claiming, he is preening. Nobody should or would CC anything.

Preening has something to do with birds, there's no definition of it on the internet regarding anything related to mafia. AND he IS claiming he said he HARDCLAIMS investigative sheriff

I hard claim Desperado.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Sweet is not claiming, he is preening. Nobody should or would CC anything.

Preening has something to do with birds, there's no definition of it on the internet regarding anything related to mafia. AND he IS claiming he said he HARDCLAIMS investigative sheriff

I hard claim Desperado.

You are simply hardclaiming liar. Super.

[FlaviusAetius]

Alright my shot is in. Better luck next time rdrivera.

How we feelin?

You draw your firearm and get the jump on your opp.

Unfortunately your firearm is a Bug-A-Salt.

rdrivera is lightly bruised and heavily annoyed.

You do not learn rdrivera’s identity.

This isnt a role what are you doing

[sweetandcool]

Preening has something to do with birds, there's no definition of it on the internet regarding anything related to mafia. AND he IS claiming he said he HARDCLAIMS investigative sheriff

I hard claim Desperado.

You are simply hardclaiming liar. Super.

You are hard claiming joyless cynic :D

[FlaviusAetius]

Sweet is not claiming, he is preening. Nobody should or would CC anything.

Preening has something to do with birds, there's no definition of it on the internet regarding anything related to mafia. AND he IS claiming he said he HARDCLAIMS investigative sheriff

I hard claim Desperado.

:facepalm: WHY ON EARTH are you hard claiming desperado now after you hard claimed investigative sheriff!?!?

[Hamilton Brian]

Sweet found a stash of 3rd party viagra at the apothecary.

[Balki Bartokomous]

I hard claim Desperado.

You are simply hardclaiming liar. Super.

You are hard claiming joyless cynic :D

I am just deeply disappointed in you.

* Crosses arms. Looks stern.