Mafia XL - A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum

[yavuzovic]

Xorxes throws votes around. A scum would be more careful but as I remember from my scum game, I was caring acting like town more than strategic playing. Xorxes is clever. I think he can act. I will not vite him until I find another scummy clue. This is just an assumption.

[rdrivera2005]

Yeah Foxcastle, ffs, sent me my role pm already. How is Jamiet supposed to read me otherwise.

( )

I guess you're just dicking around. But I'm not sure what Worcej thinks he's doing. Let's talk about that, Vecna....

So, Worcej decided to present a theory regarding Pandoras Box. His theory was dependent on the assumption that the GM would have ensured the Box was placed with a Roman at the start of the game. This as we can see is at odds with what the GM said about the Box in the setup post.

So either:

1. Worcej didn't read the Pandoras Box rules before deciding to make a post about the distribution of the Box.

Or:

2. Worcej had read the rules but genuinely did not believe what the GM had written.

Or:

3. Worcej had read the rules, but hoped other players had not, so that he could misdirect us.


Which do you think is most likely?

Both Squigs and Vecna already answered it's not 3 and I agree, it would be incredibly stupid as scum.
Worcej could you please answer so Jamie can move forward...

I liked Vecna's posts, get mostly the same feelings I got when reading the first pages. And no, I am not trying to buddy him before someone accuses me.

I also want to hear from Balki why Bozo is so obviously town?

[Jamiet99uk]

Pandora’s Box is most likely in the hands of a Townie, and it offers that person a power. Let’s keep that info hidden for that reason.

Also, Town has an Observer and Mafia doesn’t. Observer is pretty darn critical, and will help us assess claims about the Box and PR claims later on.

Let’s keep PR and Box information quiet on Day 1. No fake claims. No real claims. Let’s just hunt scum.

Let's make a psychologic read here. Balki tries to convince us mafias aren't OP. I feel like it is scummy - I mean we usually try to convince people we're weak. But underlined words feel genuine. I can't really read him as scum but I have a suspicion now.

Alert! Alert!
Scumslip detected!

[yavuzovic]

Pandora’s Box is most likely in the hands of a Townie, and it offers that person a power. Let’s keep that info hidden for that reason.

Also, Town has an Observer and Mafia doesn’t. Observer is pretty darn critical, and will help us assess claims about the Box and PR claims later on.

Let’s keep PR and Box information quiet on Day 1. No fake claims. No real claims. Let’s just hunt scum.

Let's make a psychologic read here. Balki tries to convince us mafias aren't OP. I feel like it is scummy - I mean we usually try to convince people we're weak. But underlined words feel genuine. I can't really read him as scum but I have a suspicion now.

Alert! Alert!
Scumslip detected!

Lol, it's just a general statement. We means "we players", towns do same thing too

[Vecna]

Yeah a small part of me has this slight tingle that Jamiet is just upping the theatrics because he knows its an easy townread for him as well. He could do that as either allignment. Regardless, lets lynch Xorxes

[Jamiet99uk]

@Xorxes can you explain why you have changed your vote so often already?
I mean in the first few pages you pretty much cast a vote every 5 minutes.
Worse than an over-caffienated Brainbomb.

[Foxcastle]

##CALL GM
PLEASE CONFIRM THAT ALL ROLE PMS WERE SUCCESSFULLY SENT?

##GM NOTE: All role PMs were sent on the forum messaging system and were successfully sent as far as the GM knows. If you didn’t receive a role PM, please let me know as soon as possible.

[Vecna]

I DIDNT RECEIVE A ROLE PM

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote Vecna

This is becoming intolerable.

[Jamiet99uk]

##CALL GM

Please could you help Vecna by posting his Role PM here where he can read it?

[Foxcastle]

##CALL GM
Please could you help Vecna by posting his Role PM here where he can read it?

##GM NOTE: Obviously not. As stated previously, all role PMs were sent successfully as far as the GM knows. Any player who hasn't received a role PM should let me know directly.

[yavuzovic]

Vecna stop it. I know you received your PM

[Vecna]

My role just got upgraded with my new role pm. Im a PR now.

[Szpoti]

As a complete and utter noob, I've been reading carefully all the posts submitted so far, and at this point I would like to reveal my role - Village Idiot (not referring to another player). I'm fully overwhelmed by the sheer amount of posts, and have zero understanding how some of you may arrive at any conclusion as to the roles of other players. I therefore would vote today for no lynch:

##VOTE NoLynch (please correct my syntax in that regard).

[Jamiet99uk]

Aaaaaand <Mute> Vecna for the rest of this phase.

[Szpoti]

....actually, by saying I'm the Village Idiot, I'm implying that I am town, aren't I?!

So this is how it works!

[Vecna]

Muting players is against the rules jamiet. Certainly you would be aware that is totally amoral (especially because I cannot poke at you anymore effectively that way)

[Vecna]

You should probably reread your role pm Chipotle because the way youre doing it right now youre scum claiming.

##vote Chipotle

[Jamiet99uk]

....actually, by saying I'm the Village Idiot, I'm implying that I am town, aren't I?!

So this is how it works!

Salve, socius Romanorum.

[brainbomb]

Vote count thingy

ND (2) RagingIke297 DrCJG
rdrivera2005 (1) peterlund
bo_sox48 (1) Durga
thdfrance (1) xorxes
Jamiet99uk (1) Balki Bartokomous
peterlund (1) Tom Bombadil
ghug (1) thdfrance
xorxes (1) Vecna
Vecna (1) Jamiet99uk

No‑Lynch (1) Szpoti

End-votes (0/11)

Non-votes: bozotheclown bo_sox48 damo666 DemonRHK ghug rdrivera2005 Squigs44 worcej