M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

Rather than play the stupid game Bunny is playing, I'm just going to come out and say it.

I am the Necromancer.

Then you just claimed scum. We asked me to to claim days ago if town.

wtf autocorrect? We asked necro to claim.

[BunnyGo]

@ezio seriously? Do you not think I was 200% sure Monarch was scum before KiLo?

[BunnyGo]

@ezio seriously? Do you not think I was 200% sure Monarch was scum before KiLo?

100%

[BunnyGo]

And @ezio: you didn’t try and guess my power! It’s a fun game!

[BunnyGo]

Also, has anyone not claimed VT/PR?

[BunnyGo]

I do still think it's possible Bunny does have a scanning role (like the Enchanter, Gloom Stalker, or Urban Tracker) and its just wasted on him being scum.

Or, alternatively, he is avoiding a CC by one of the real scanners. This would explain why he is saying he's got something, but not exactly what, hoping the real scanner won't see the conflict as they aren't being CC'd.

See...scum want to know what scanning role I have. They're worried I know more and have just been a tease and they missed.

They're scared to play the game "guess Bunny's role" because guessing gives intel.

[TheMadMonarch]

Rather than play the stupid game Bunny is playing, I'm just going to come out and say it.

I am the Necromancer.

Then you just claimed scum. We asked me to to claim days ago if town.

And I, and many others, opposed every time.

YOU asked people to claim because YOU are trying to hunt the PRs.

[TheMadMonarch]

I do still think it's possible Bunny does have a scanning role (like the Enchanter, Gloom Stalker, or Urban Tracker) and its just wasted on him being scum.

Or, alternatively, he is avoiding a CC by one of the real scanners. This would explain why he is saying he's got something, but not exactly what, hoping the real scanner won't see the conflict as they aren't being CC'd.

See...scum want to know what scanning role I have. They're worried I know more and have just been a tease and they missed.

They're scared to play the game "guess Bunny's role" because guessing gives intel.

What world are you living in?

either:

A) I am scum, and I did just guess your role. Not scared, you're insane

B) I am town, I guessed your role. You think I'm scum anyway, you're insane.

[TheMadMonarch]

Also, has anyone not claimed VT/PR?

More hunting. He wants to make sure he's got them all.

[BunnyGo]

Rather than play the stupid game Bunny is playing, I'm just going to come out and say it.

I am the Necromancer.

Then you just claimed scum. We asked me to to claim days ago if town.

And I, and many others, opposed every time.

YOU asked people to claim because YOU are trying to hunt the PRs.

ROFL Not one person objected yesterday. Will be fun experiment to see who knew your role and alignment and now who you think was objecting.

[BunnyGo]

Also, has anyone not claimed VT/PR?

More hunting. He wants to make sure he's got them all.

Maybe my power tells lies…maybe I have a PR scan on someone else and want to see if they’ll like about it!!

[BunnyGo]

Going paddling. Back later.

Answer questions and no lies people. I may get more guilties if you lie…

[President Eden]

If ghug was mafia, we have a miskill to spare, we can flip Monarch and then Bunny if Monarch is town.

If ghug was town, we’re out of miskills, have to choose between Monarch or Bunny, and Monarch would be lying about ghug’s role.

…Conversely, there’s a maximalist position where we just believe in the world where Monarch is right, kill Bunny, hit mafia, and still have a miskill in our back pocket.

Thoughts? And also thoughts on the claims themselves?
I actually don’t see any glaring contradiction in Monarch’s story at first blush…

[President Eden]

I guess there’s also an other other option where they’re both town and our last two PRs and foodcoats has just been mafia the whole time.

Idk if I believe that for reasons previously stated, but for completion’s sake I’m putting it out there.

[President Eden]

This sequence also essentially guarantees the Battle Master is mafia hiding out among the VT claims. Make of that what you will.

[worcej]

this game is fucked because people are always harping about the damn prs, battlemaster this, vig that, janitor whatever. I DO NOT CARE!! please can we never talk about another pr on this damn site. never benefited town and never was worth a hoot

This is our way.

[worcej]

This isn't stupid. I guarantee there's extra intel in it.

Make a guess

i don't even know what the fucking options are. i genuinely could not say

that's a fair answer. But why won't aaro guess. I think he's scum.

so not guessing your role makes someone scum?

[worcej]

This isn't stupid. I guarantee there's extra intel in it.

Make a guess

i don't even know what the fucking options are. i genuinely could not say

I'll give you (and the others a hint): I know Monarch's alignment...

So you’re magical eh?

[worcej]

Imma level with you I really don’t feel like guessing lol.

I’m gonna do it for you but it’s going to be a lazy skim of the role doc.

that's fair. I'm scumming aaro hard for not guessing nor picking it up when I put it down several times.

Is this only because of your IRL connections?

Why scum him harder but not others like me?

[worcej]

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

It was worcej with the "posing by the grave" picture.

I thiought he was leaving evidence that ghug was scum and he was the necro.

No, I was straight up trolling.