M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[President Eden]

I think you might be a Bard with College of Secrets. You saw that Monarch is either the Battle Master or Necromancer which are very likely to be scum roles in context. Hence your “GUILTY” is not literally an alignment check but a deduction from a role check.

How’d I do, professor?

[Bonatogether]

bunny i do not have the patience to play this game lol

[BunnyGo]

bunny i do not have the patience to play this game lol

You've already played...

Now we're waiting for others to show up.

[BunnyGo]

I think you might be a Bard with College of Secrets. You saw that Monarch is either the Battle Master or Necromancer which are very likely to be scum roles in context. Hence your “GUILTY” is not literally an alignment check but a deduction from a role check.

How’d I do, professor?

Very clever.

Now let's see how others do.

No spoilers!!

I'll be back later...it's later here and date night!

[Bonatogether]

booooring

[aarodactyl]

I'll give you (and the others a hint): I know Monarch's alignment...

is this a cop claim? or is it something requiring more than two steps of inference

Not gonna say my role. Not at least until aaro and Eden guess. The fact they demurred is off-putting. Aaro especially.

But I'll claim: GUILTY GUILTY GUILTY (on Monarch)

One of my main guesses is that this is a reaction test, and I didn't want to spoil it by saying that's what I thought it was.

(What following all assumes you're not false claiming)

If you were a knowledge PR with more info than monarch being scum, you would have told us before EON. With food having left the graveyard (Which you confirmed seeing), if you died, we would have lost all the info you had (besides Monarch being guilty). So I think it's safe to assume you either have no info and are doing a reaction test or you have a guilty on only Monarch and no clears on anyone else. The reaction test seems more likely.

I haven't read past this point in the thread. I might change my guess if there's more info shared.

[BunnyGo]

is this a cop claim? or is it something requiring more than two steps of inference

Not gonna say my role. Not at least until aaro and Eden guess. The fact they demurred is off-putting. Aaro especially.

But I'll claim: GUILTY GUILTY GUILTY (on Monarch)

One of my main guesses is that this is a reaction test, and I didn't want to spoil it by saying that's what I thought it was.

(What following all assumes you're not false claiming)

If you were a knowledge PR with more info than monarch being scum, you would have told us before EON. With food having left the graveyard (Which you confirmed seeing), if you died, we would have lost all the info you had (besides Monarch being guilty). So I think it's safe to assume you either have no info and are doing a reaction test or you have a guilty on only Monarch and no clears on anyone else. The reaction test seems more likely.

I haven't read past this point in the thread. I might change my guess if there's more info shared.

You still never GUESSED MY ROLE!

It's amazing...all those words any you continue to dodge the question. Why?

[aarodactyl]

See: how I played panicked yesterday trying to not be too obvious at first that I had intel, while trying to get the claim there and then progressively just gave up pretense to all but claiming.

i mean like pre-mylo/lylo

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

[BunnyGo]

i mean like pre-mylo/lylo

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

It was worcej with the "posing by the grave" picture.

I thiought he was leaving evidence that ghug was scum and he was the necro.

[aarodactyl]

Imma level with you I really don’t feel like guessing lol.

I’m gonna do it for you but it’s going to be a lazy skim of the role doc.

that's fair. I'm scumming aaro hard for not guessing nor picking it up when I put it down several times.

I'm pretty sure you're some worthless role like Iatrophobe. Either that or you have some limited role like Gloom Stalker but you haven't hit anyone (except maybe Monarch since you've been saying she's scum).

The only other thing you could be implying is the PR cop (college of secrets). However, I don't think that's likely because I think you would have included all your scans in an EOD post.

To be honest, the claim that I'm scum because I'm not noticing something that you're implying is obvious is kind of insulting. I had a pretty rough last couple of weeks, and I'm sorry if I'm not catching on to your hints.

[aarodactyl]

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

It was worcej with the "posing by the grave" picture.

I thiought he was leaving evidence that ghug was scum and he was the necro.

Huh. I didn't pick up on that at all. I thought it was just a funny meme because they tend to get in fights in mafia games.

[BunnyGo]

is this a cop claim? or is it something requiring more than two steps of inference

Not gonna say my role. Not at least until aaro and Eden guess. The fact they demurred is off-putting. Aaro especially.

But I'll claim: GUILTY GUILTY GUILTY (on Monarch)

One of my main guesses is that this is a reaction test, and I didn't want to spoil it by saying that's what I thought it was.

(What following all assumes you're not false claiming)

If you were a knowledge PR with more info than monarch being scum, you would have told us before EON. With food having left the graveyard (Which you confirmed seeing), if you died, we would have lost all the info you had (besides Monarch being guilty). So I think it's safe to assume you either have no info and are doing a reaction test or you have a guilty on only Monarch and no clears on anyone else. The reaction test seems more likely.

I haven't read past this point in the thread. I might change my guess if there's more info shared.

It's not a reaction test.

And you have good sound logic here.

Now vote Monarch and we can move on.

I'm not telling the scum team what my actual role is. Let 'em sweat.

[Bonatogether]

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

It was worcej with the "posing by the grave" picture.

I thiought he was leaving evidence that ghug was scum and he was the necro.

it's a common meme

[BunnyGo]

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

It was worcej with the "posing by the grave" picture.

I thiought he was leaving evidence that ghug was scum and he was the necro.

Huh. I didn't pick up on that at all. I thought it was just a funny meme because they tend to get in fights in mafia games.

Hence why I've been assuming ghug was scum and necro was town.

And the people who all assumed otherwise seemed a bit scummy to me (like the team agreed to push a narrative to make the necro hide and seem scummy)

[BunnyGo]

Ok, to be honest, I thought you just messed up your math because you were up late or something. I didn't consider you were town PR and counting yourself. That would have been too sloppy.

This is reminding me of something though. You said the other day that you were pretty sure you noticed someone crumbing their role. I'm thinking now that Monarch was the one that was crumbling and you're saying they have to be mafia since you+food are the remaining town PR. That doesn't indicate anything about your role.

It was worcej with the "posing by the grave" picture.

I thiought he was leaving evidence that ghug was scum and he was the necro.

it's a common meme

I'm aware...but the timing of it seemed a clever crumb.

[aarodactyl]

Not gonna say my role. Not at least until aaro and Eden guess. The fact they demurred is off-putting. Aaro especially.

But I'll claim: GUILTY GUILTY GUILTY (on Monarch)

One of my main guesses is that this is a reaction test, and I didn't want to spoil it by saying that's what I thought it was.

(What following all assumes you're not false claiming)

If you were a knowledge PR with more info than monarch being scum, you would have told us before EON. With food having left the graveyard (Which you confirmed seeing), if you died, we would have lost all the info you had (besides Monarch being guilty). So I think it's safe to assume you either have no info and are doing a reaction test or you have a guilty on only Monarch and no clears on anyone else. The reaction test seems more likely.

I haven't read past this point in the thread. I might change my guess if there's more info shared.

It's not a reaction test.

And you have good sound logic here.

Now vote Monarch and we can move on.

I'm not telling the scum team what my actual role is. Let 'em sweat.

If Monarch was town and scum had the vote freezing power, we'd have lost already. So ##vote Monarch

That said, there's a non-zero chance you're scum and pushing a miskill.

I need to step away from my computer for now. I might not be back on tonight.

[BunnyGo]

One of my main guesses is that this is a reaction test, and I didn't want to spoil it by saying that's what I thought it was.

(What following all assumes you're not false claiming)

If you were a knowledge PR with more info than monarch being scum, you would have told us before EON. With food having left the graveyard (Which you confirmed seeing), if you died, we would have lost all the info you had (besides Monarch being guilty). So I think it's safe to assume you either have no info and are doing a reaction test or you have a guilty on only Monarch and no clears on anyone else. The reaction test seems more likely.

I haven't read past this point in the thread. I might change my guess if there's more info shared.

It's not a reaction test.

And you have good sound logic here.

Now vote Monarch and we can move on.

I'm not telling the scum team what my actual role is. Let 'em sweat.

If Monarch was town and scum had the vote freezing power, we'd have lost already. So ##vote Monarch

That said, there's a non-zero chance you're scum and pushing a miskill.

I need to step away from my computer for now. I might not be back on tonight.

From town perspective there's a chance I'm scum trying to bus scum for credit...

[Ezio]

See: how I played panicked yesterday trying to not be too obvious at first that I had intel, while trying to get the claim there and then progressively just gave up pretense to all but claiming.

i mean like pre-mylo/lylo

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

Yea this math made me think you were PR or scum. I settled on PR after I looked at your claim. Your play yesterday made me worried you were scum, but clearly I was wrong about Sweet, so I'm probably wrong about everything.

At the moment, I think it is pretty likely we only have 4 town PR's.

[Ezio]

##vote Monarch of course.

I could also see Bunny+Food+Worcej or some other combination like Sweet was pushing. My reads have been so completely wrong this game.

[President Eden]

If you don’t trust yourself, you could trust the guy who got yesterday right and whose worldview is still intact.