M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

bunny no one has the time to play stupid games

This isn't stupid. I guarantee there's extra intel in it.

Make a guess

i don't even know what the fucking options are. i genuinely could not say

that's a fair answer. But why won't aaro guess. I think he's scum.

[BunnyGo]

bunny no one has the time to play stupid games

This isn't stupid. I guarantee there's extra intel in it.

Make a guess

i don't even know what the fucking options are. i genuinely could not say

I'll give you (and the others a hint): I know Monarch's alignment...

[Bonatogether]

this game is fucked because people are always harping about the damn prs, battlemaster this, vig that, janitor whatever. I DO NOT CARE!! please can we never talk about another pr on this damn site. never benefited town and never was worth a hoot

This right now matters....

guess my role (after you vote monarch)

i opened the role document once and internalized none of it. i'll just spitball tracker if it makes you happy

[Bonatogether]

This isn't stupid. I guarantee there's extra intel in it.

Make a guess

i don't even know what the fucking options are. i genuinely could not say

I'll give you (and the others a hint): I know Monarch's alignment...

is this a cop claim? or is it something requiring more than two steps of inference

[BunnyGo]

i don't even know what the fucking options are. i genuinely could not say

I'll give you (and the others a hint): I know Monarch's alignment...

is this a cop claim? or is it something requiring more than two steps of inference

Not gonna say my role. Not at least until aaro and Eden guess. The fact they demurred is off-putting. Aaro especially.

But I'll claim: GUILTY GUILTY GUILTY (on Monarch)

[Bonatogether]

claim noted. any evidence?

[BunnyGo]

claim noted. any evidence?

See: how I played panicked yesterday trying to not be too obvious at first that I had intel, while trying to get the claim there and then progressively just gave up pretense to all but claiming.

[BunnyGo]

claim noted. any evidence?

What sort of "evidence" do you expect?

[Bonatogether]

claim noted. any evidence?

See: how I played panicked yesterday trying to not be too obvious at first that I had intel, while trying to get the claim there and then progressively just gave up pretense to all but claiming.

i mean like pre-mylo/lylo

[President Eden]

Aarodactyl: VT
Bonatogether: VT
BunnyGo: PR
Ezio: VT
foodcoats: PR (hasn’t officially claimed today)
JustAGuyNamedWill: VT
President Eden: VT
TheMadMonarch: PR
Worcej: VT

Vecna, Fox, and D&W are flipped town PRs.

If the three PR claims are truthful, at least one of them is mafia.
If all VT claimants are not town PRs lying about their role, at least one of them is town; and unless one of them accepted the tadpole, two are town.

I still can’t see foodcoats’s incentive to claim the commune-with-dead role as mafia. sweet is now confirmed town and confirmed that foodcoats relayed a message (from Kak) that he wouldn’t have been able to fake. So we know foodcoats is probably truthfully relaying messages, and again I don’t see the incentive to do that as mafia. So I think foodcoats is town. (I thought this already, but here’s the reasoning again.)

“Why wasn’t he killed?” It’s probably LYLO, foodcoats’s power isn’t that powerful (he’s not going to scan someone guilty or win another miskill through a docsave), and he’s not confirmed. Evidently the mafia believe foodcoats would have been easier to miskill than Colby, which makes sense to me.

In my mind, then, there’s definitely one mafia between Bunny and Monarch. I don’t wanna steal Bunny’s PR thunder here, but my guess right now is that Bunny is the townie and Monarch is the mafiosa. This is pretty absurd scum theater for it to be both of them, so I also assume, short of a VT retracting and claiming a PR, that we still have our fifth PR and they didn’t take tadpole.

That leaves 3 mafia in the VT claimants. I’m confident it’s not Bona. I know it’s not me, but I’ll leave you to decide for yourself. worc & Will still make the most sense, and I still feel sketchier about Ezio than aaro, but I’m still not confident in my view on that yet.

[President Eden]

Holy mother of xposts Batman lol.

I started writing that a half hour ago and haven’t read shit

[Bonatogether]

claim noted. any evidence?

What sort of "evidence" do you expect?

a specific claim, with all information from it on the table, with, if fortunate but not required, prior groundwork

[President Eden]

OK I’ll add the whole paragraph I took out because I didn’t wanna steal Bunny’s thunder lol.

In my mind, then, there’s definitely one mafia between Bunny and Monarch. I don’t wanna steal Bunny’s PR thunder here, but it strikes me that if Bunny were mafia, Monarch were town, and Bunny learned Monarch’s role, then they’d probably just shoot Monarch and stir up WIFOM about foodcoats or go for a miskill on someone vulnerable. Why give her the chance to claim? And more to the point, why make such a huge show of pushing her and then out as PR immediately today? (Bunny’s push yesterday also suggests he knew previously.) In fact, why claim at all? Conversely, if Bunny is town and Monarch is mafia, then Bunny has made it pretty obvious today that he knows Monarch is a PR. Monarch doesn’t have much choice but to claim PR.

[President Eden]

##VOTE TheMadMonarch

I don’t want to END because we actually need all the time we can get here lol… but I’m with you in spirit Bunny. And sorry I didn’t go with you yesterday. I totally whiffed on what you were putting down and felt skeeved out, but I get it now.

[BunnyGo]

claim noted. any evidence?

See: how I played panicked yesterday trying to not be too obvious at first that I had intel, while trying to get the claim there and then progressively just gave up pretense to all but claiming.

i mean like pre-mylo/lylo

you mean....a CRUMB?!

Again...I'll point you to me doing "math badly" when food claimed PR and I assumed necro was town, which meant food HAD TO BE scum in that case. But that assumed as well that I was town PR.

But no...I didn't crumb any of my intel or my role. What do you take me for?

[BunnyGo]

claim noted. any evidence?

What sort of "evidence" do you expect?

a specific claim, with all information from it on the table, with, if fortunate but not required, prior groundwork

Not till other people GUESS MY ROLE!

[President Eden]

Imma level with you I really don’t feel like guessing lol.

I’m gonna do it for you but it’s going to be a lazy skim of the role doc.

[BunnyGo]

Imma level with you I really don’t feel like guessing lol.

I’m gonna do it for you but it’s going to be a lazy skim of the role doc.

that's fair. I'm scumming aaro hard for not guessing nor picking it up when I put it down several times.

[BunnyGo]

Imma level with you I really don’t feel like guessing lol.

I’m gonna do it for you but it’s going to be a lazy skim of the role doc.

that's fair. I'm scumming aaro hard for not guessing nor picking it up when I put it down several times.

Especially since he could only talk mechs for a large part of the game.

[BunnyGo]

claim noted. any evidence?

What sort of "evidence" do you expect?

a specific claim, with all information from it on the table, with, if fortunate but not required, prior groundwork

I've pointed you to prior groundwork.

Going back prior to my push on Monarch.

I've made a specific claim.

I'll not claim my role until the scum and town guess it.