M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[foodcoats]

Ezio says it well and I'll just reinforce that the timing of your claims scream to me that you're focused on ensuring you live. The logical thing I can point to is you're the scum PR that could cause the game to end with the vote mechanics so you're a great use of our last miskill.

Add in Colby's posts and I think this is even more true...

This is actually a good theory as to why sweet is working so hard today. It's tinfoil-tunnelling but it aligns with my theory that the scumteam actually has Iatrophobe.

Wait…what?! How is that your theory?

Okay, I guess you have not had time to read everything today Bunny.

You can go back into my iso. Essentially I think that sweet "truthfully" claimed Iatrophobe because it is one of the scum abilities, and I gave some reasoning as to why a VT would not claim a PR to save themselves, versus a scum fakeclaiming and how they would decide what role to fakeclaim.

[Ezio]

Shameful to see Town burying their heads in the sand.

This isn't convincing. Your play has sucked this game if you're town and we're not "ignoring the game" or "making policy kills" to day kill you here.

Keep putting together arguments for why your scum team is scum.

Keep pushing on Eden/Bunny/will and whomever your final scum is.

If you're town, your arguments today might be the difference in MYLO. Calling us *all* bad for scum reading you is terrible.

[foodcoats]

Nina were do you stand on things how you feeling

Who is Nina?

[foodcoats]

Ok finally caught up. To be honest, this generally just feels like a repeat of the conversation from last night.

I agree with the argument that sweets has been harming town with their gameplay. That does not mean they’re scum. And at this point, we need to catch scum instead of voting players that we think aren’t playing well.

I think a number of points have been raised that point to sweet playing as scum would and not just being bad town.

[Ezio]

##vote just
I think he started day 1 seeming helpful and as the game has gone on has not been present. But we can get a lot of info from the vote by seeing who has tried to align with him throughout if his claims have not been as strong. D5 he parked his vote on vecna who we saw was confirmed town and then food. Same for day 4 just in reverse. Day 3 he was all over the place throwing votes at many people. Ending with flav (town), me and food. Day 2 he started on bunny and then went grugh. Day 1 stuck flav (town). I think he has skated by knocking out towns and we can get some good info from this vote

Guys I think we have our first Scum v Scum EoD. They've finally decided bussing is their best bet.

[Col7by]

Nina were do you stand on things how you feeling

Who is Nina?

Bona it was autocorrect

[foodcoats]

Dude I need to get my tinfoil hat. I can feel the brainwaves hitting me telling me that Food is scum and has pooled the wool over my head.
It's why I need to hear town PR claim ASAP.
If food is right and mafia hit our PR with the tadpole, may God have mercy on our soul.

WE DO NOT NEED A CLAIM.

We need to pray we have one more PR who has a valuable ability.

I was extremely suspicious of Bunny fishing for PRs before. Don't you start, too.

too late on that bby. I was telling Bona I was down with a mass VT claim and a mass PR claim.
I'm also the one who got the ball rolling on Will for his meme post, yet you blamed that on Eden.
Curious...
(I don't actually think you're scum, I'm just lacking any confidence in my reads after having not caught any scum ever this game)

Is this directed at me? There is too much info going through my head but didn't someone say Eden started it and I pointed out how you had started it? Maybe it was me... I have to re-read myself, I guess?

In any event when I re-read that interaction I did not conclude anything new about you or Just... I think you are town and Just is scum still.

[BunnyGo]

Nina were do you stand on things how you feeling

Who is Nina?

I think our group has a new catchphrase

[worcej]

Nina were do you stand on things how you feeling

Who is Nina?

[Col7by]

##vote just
I think he started day 1 seeming helpful and as the game has gone on has not been present. But we can get a lot of info from the vote by seeing who has tried to align with him throughout if his claims have not been as strong. D5 he parked his vote on vecna who we saw was confirmed town and then food. Same for day 4 just in reverse. Day 3 he was all over the place throwing votes at many people. Ending with flav (town), me and food. Day 2 he started on bunny and then went grugh. Day 1 stuck flav (town). I think he has skated by knocking out towns and we can get some good info from this vote

Guys I think we have our first Scum v Scum EoD. They've finally decided bussing is their best bet.

I guess I don’t following completely. What is bussing and does this make me look town or scum lol. I’m assuming you’re saying sweet and will are scum and you think I am and am making those two the lead vote getters?

[foodcoats]

##vote just
I think he started day 1 seeming helpful and as the game has gone on has not been present. But we can get a lot of info from the vote by seeing who has tried to align with him throughout if his claims have not been as strong. D5 he parked his vote on vecna who we saw was confirmed town and then food. Same for day 4 just in reverse. Day 3 he was all over the place throwing votes at many people. Ending with flav (town), me and food. Day 2 he started on bunny and then went grugh. Day 1 stuck flav (town). I think he has skated by knocking out towns and we can get some good info from this vote

Guys I think we have our first Scum v Scum EoD. They've finally decided bussing is their best bet.

Yeah, I have not called it out because I am watching, hoping we get scum, and can discuss how they were bussing.

I have theories...

[BunnyGo]

This is actually a good theory as to why sweet is working so hard today. It's tinfoil-tunnelling but it aligns with my theory that the scumteam actually has Iatrophobe.

Wait…what?! How is that your theory?

Okay, I guess you have not had time to read everything today Bunny.

You can go back into my iso. Essentially I think that sweet "truthfully" claimed Iatrophobe because it is one of the scum abilities, and I gave some reasoning as to why a VT would not claim a PR to save themselves, versus a scum fakeclaiming and how they would decide what role to fakeclaim.

Read nothing but Mad’s mad ISO since midnight last night.


I think you and Ezio are right about the team:

Sweet-Mad-Colby-just(?)

[Col7by]

Nina were do you stand on things how you feeling

Who is Nina?

Lol

[sweetandcool]

Shameful to see Town burying their heads in the sand.

This isn't convincing. Your play has sucked this game if you're town and we're not "ignoring the game" or "making policy kills" to day kill you here.

Keep putting together arguments for why your scum team is scum.

Keep pushing on Eden/Bunny/will and whomever your final scum is.

If you're town, your arguments today might be the difference in MYLO. Calling us *all* bad for scum reading you is terrible.

Several players have seen me "meltdown" like this and every time I have been Town.

They should know better. But then again it seems several of those players are actually Mafia so of course they are not going to make the correct read.

I don't have time to keep pushing my cases on my scumreads.

I literally stayed up late building my case on why I was Town and why certain players were Town and why Eden was Mafia. I worked hard all day yesterday on it too and convincing Town.

And barely anyone responded directly to my actual case, and the few that did were incredibly dismissive.

Just look at Bunny's response (who was in my PoE): there was none! Instead he pushed the narrative that I was scum or stupid since I wasn't counting PRs. He has completely ignored the issue at all.

[Ezio]

##vote just
I think he started day 1 seeming helpful and as the game has gone on has not been present. But we can get a lot of info from the vote by seeing who has tried to align with him throughout if his claims have not been as strong. D5 he parked his vote on vecna who we saw was confirmed town and then food. Same for day 4 just in reverse. Day 3 he was all over the place throwing votes at many people. Ending with flav (town), me and food. Day 2 he started on bunny and then went grugh. Day 1 stuck flav (town). I think he has skated by knocking out towns and we can get some good info from this vote

Guys I think we have our first Scum v Scum EoD. They've finally decided bussing is their best bet.

I guess I don’t following completely. What is bussing and does this make me look town or scum lol. I’m assuming you’re saying sweet and will are scum and you think I am and am making those two the lead vote getters?

Bussing is when scum vote other scum. Usually done for towncred.

[sweetandcool]

Wait…what?! How is that your theory?

Okay, I guess you have not had time to read everything today Bunny.

You can go back into my iso. Essentially I think that sweet "truthfully" claimed Iatrophobe because it is one of the scum abilities, and I gave some reasoning as to why a VT would not claim a PR to save themselves, versus a scum fakeclaiming and how they would decide what role to fakeclaim.

Read nothing but Mad’s mad ISO since midnight last night.


I think you and Ezio are right about the team:

Sweet-Mad-Colby-just(?)

What a convenient line up of scumreads.

Everybody's least favorite players currently.

Sweet the fake claimer.
Mad the lurker.
Will the lurker and the member.
Colby the sweet defender.

Very tidy group.

[Ezio]

Shameful to see Town burying their heads in the sand.

This isn't convincing. Your play has sucked this game if you're town and we're not "ignoring the game" or "making policy kills" to day kill you here.

Keep putting together arguments for why your scum team is scum.

Keep pushing on Eden/Bunny/will and whomever your final scum is.

If you're town, your arguments today might be the difference in MYLO. Calling us *all* bad for scum reading you is terrible.

Several players have seen me "meltdown" like this and every time I have been Town.

They should know better. But then again it seems several of those players are actually Mafia so of course they are not going to make the correct read.

I don't have time to keep pushing my cases on my scumreads.

I literally stayed up late building my case on why I was Town and why certain players were Town and why Eden was Mafia. I worked hard all day yesterday on it too and convincing Town.

And barely anyone responded directly to my actual case, and the few that did were incredibly dismissive.

Just look at Bunny's response (who was in my PoE): there was none! Instead he pushed the narrative that I was scum or stupid since I wasn't counting PRs. He has completely ignored the issue at all.

Keep grinding. When you play like brainbomb you've got to *play like brainbomb*.
You gotta make wall after wall of wildly different cases. on similar-ish people.
You've gotta figure out how to do it all quickly.
If you can do all this, not scumslip, and make it seem like it's coming from a town perspective, you might have a chance.
It's fruitless work.
A thankless task.
We're probably going to day kill you anyways.
But it's the route you seem to have chosen lol.

[sweetandcool]

Shameful to see Town burying their heads in the sand.

This isn't convincing. Your play has sucked this game if you're town and we're not "ignoring the game" or "making policy kills" to day kill you here.

Keep putting together arguments for why your scum team is scum.

Keep pushing on Eden/Bunny/will and whomever your final scum is.

If you're town, your arguments today might be the difference in MYLO. Calling us *all* bad for scum reading you is terrible.

Several players have seen me "meltdown" like this and every time I have been Town.

They should know better. But then again it seems several of those players are actually Mafia so of course they are not going to make the correct read.

I don't have time to keep pushing my cases on my scumreads.

I literally stayed up late building my case on why I was Town and why certain players were Town and why Eden was Mafia. I worked hard all day yesterday on it too and convincing Town.

And barely anyone responded directly to my actual case, and the few that did were incredibly dismissive.

Just look at Bunny's response (who was in my PoE): there was none! Instead he pushed the narrative that I was scum or stupid since I wasn't counting PRs. He has completely ignored the issue at all.

Bunny, worcej, President Eden, maybe Bunny have all seen this before.

[BunnyGo]

Okay, I guess you have not had time to read everything today Bunny.

You can go back into my iso. Essentially I think that sweet "truthfully" claimed Iatrophobe because it is one of the scum abilities, and I gave some reasoning as to why a VT would not claim a PR to save themselves, versus a scum fakeclaiming and how they would decide what role to fakeclaim.

Read nothing but Mad’s mad ISO since midnight last night.


I think you and Ezio are right about the team:

Sweet-Mad-Colby-just(?)

What a convenient line up of scumreads.

Everybody's least favorite players currently.

Sweet the fake claimer.
Mad the lurker.
Will the lurker and the member.
Colby the sweet defender.

Very tidy group.

What did you make of mad’s posts today?

[sweetandcool]

This isn't convincing. Your play has sucked this game if you're town and we're not "ignoring the game" or "making policy kills" to day kill you here.

Keep putting together arguments for why your scum team is scum.

Keep pushing on Eden/Bunny/will and whomever your final scum is.

If you're town, your arguments today might be the difference in MYLO. Calling us *all* bad for scum reading you is terrible.

Several players have seen me "meltdown" like this and every time I have been Town.

They should know better. But then again it seems several of those players are actually Mafia so of course they are not going to make the correct read.

I don't have time to keep pushing my cases on my scumreads.

I literally stayed up late building my case on why I was Town and why certain players were Town and why Eden was Mafia. I worked hard all day yesterday on it too and convincing Town.

And barely anyone responded directly to my actual case, and the few that did were incredibly dismissive.

Just look at Bunny's response (who was in my PoE): there was none! Instead he pushed the narrative that I was scum or stupid since I wasn't counting PRs. He has completely ignored the issue at all.

Keep grinding. When you play like brainbomb you've got to *play like brainbomb*.
You gotta make wall after wall of wildly different cases. on similar-ish people.
You've gotta figure out how to do it all quickly.
If you can do all this, not scumslip, and make it seem like it's coming from a town perspective, you might have a chance.
It's fruitless work.
A thankless task.
We're probably going to day kill you anyways.
But it's the route you seem to have chosen lol.

Brainbomb sticks with his reads when he knows he is right.