M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[sweetandcool]

#vote will

I’m also going to hopefully do some poe later when I’m at a computer. It’s hard to actually sort people on mobile because I’m legitimately bad at phone typing so it takes forever

Fyi this was an invalid vote

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I would freeze it with four votes on me?

[sweetandcool]

Fyi this was an invalid vote

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I would freeze it with four votes on me?

Good point though. If the freeze power exists then I am scum.

So I suppose Mafia does not have the freeze power. Thank you scum Bunny for the free information.

[BunnyGo]

Honest question:

Is it time to ask the necromancer to claim? Do we just need the intel more than we need them hidden?

[BunnyGo]

Honest question:

Is it time to ask the necromancer to claim? Do we just need the intel more than we need them hidden?

Is it in fact detrimental that they stay hidden?

[sweetandcool]

Worcej, Food, Ezio, you are all TOWN.

[sweetandcool]

Worcej, Food, Ezio, you are all TOWN.

And you are currently voting TOWN.

It's your responsibility to solve this game.

I don't see what else I can do for you.

[sweetandcool]

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I would freeze it with four votes on me?

Good point though. If the freeze power exists then I am scum.

So I suppose Mafia does not have the freeze power. Thank you scum Bunny for the free information.

Oops, I think that is what you were just saying.

[BunnyGo]

Honest question:

Is it time to ask the necromancer to claim? Do we just need the intel more than we need them hidden?

Is it in fact detrimental that they stay hidden?

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

[Ezio]

Honest question:

Is it time to ask the necromancer to claim? Do we just need the intel more than we need them hidden?

Is it in fact detrimental that they stay hidden?

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

I am thinking it's claiming time.

[BunnyGo]

Is it in fact detrimental that they stay hidden?

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

I am thinking it's claiming time.

Should we start with necromancer alone just to see what it clears up by itself? I'm curious if my guess is correct. I've been pretty sure about it for a while.

[Ezio]

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

I am thinking it's claiming time.

Should we start with necromancer alone just to see what it clears up by itself? I'm curious if my guess is correct. I've been pretty sure about it for a while.

Sure.

[BunnyGo]

I am thinking it's claiming time.

Should we start with necromancer alone just to see what it clears up by itself? I'm curious if my guess is correct. I've been pretty sure about it for a while.

Sure.

Cool.

Anyone else want to weigh in?

[aarodactyl]

#vote will

I’m also going to hopefully do some poe later when I’m at a computer. It’s hard to actually sort people on mobile because I’m legitimately bad at phone typing so it takes forever

Fyi this was an invalid vote

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I thought about it more and I think if scum has a vote freeze PR, they'll probably want to save it as long as they can instead of cementing a lead wagon. If sweets is town (which I think he is) and that PR exists, they just let him get miskilled. Then the next day, they just freeze it when a few town members are on split wagons and then scum consolidates for a win.

Which is all to say, I think you're not thinking through your PR mechanics which feels very odd given how you usually play this game.

[BunnyGo]

Fyi this was an invalid vote

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I thought about it more and I think if scum has a vote freeze PR, they'll probably want to save it as long as they can instead of cementing a lead wagon. If sweets is town (which I think he is) and that PR exists, they just let him get miskilled. Then the next day, they just freeze it when a few town members are on split wagons and then scum consolidates for a win.

Which is all to say, I think you're not thinking through your PR mechanics which feels very odd given how you usually play this game.

You think they wait until KiLo to execute it? It's main use is to get a miskill.

[BunnyGo]

Fyi this was an invalid vote

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I thought about it more and I think if scum has a vote freeze PR, they'll probably want to save it as long as they can instead of cementing a lead wagon. If sweets is town (which I think he is) and that PR exists, they just let him get miskilled. Then the next day, they just freeze it when a few town members are on split wagons and then scum consolidates for a win.

Which is all to say, I think you're not thinking through your PR mechanics which feels very odd given how you usually play this game.

In the meantime, care te weigh in on my two mech questions above?

[Ezio]

that was intentional for scum power.

Fun fact! If that scum power exists, then sweet is scum! Because otherwise they could freeze it here!!

So either don't worry about it, or vote sweet!

I thought about it more and I think if scum has a vote freeze PR, they'll probably want to save it as long as they can instead of cementing a lead wagon. If sweets is town (which I think he is) and that PR exists, they just let him get miskilled. Then the next day, they just freeze it when a few town members are on split wagons and then scum consolidates for a win.

Which is all to say, I think you're not thinking through your PR mechanics which feels very odd given how you usually play this game.

You think they wait until KiLo to execute it? It's main use is to get a miskill.

Well it would be a guaranteed win.

[aarodactyl]

Honest question:

Is it time to ask the necromancer to claim? Do we just need the intel more than we need them hidden?

Is it in fact detrimental that they stay hidden?

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

I'm not sure to be honest. We have 3 confirmed town PR and 1 pretty-much-confirmed town PR. If the last town PR has used up their role, I think it makes sense for them to claim (especially if they're one of the roles we know was used). However, there's a chance that the last town PR has a non-depleted role. If they do, I don't see the point in outing them.

[BunnyGo]

I thought about it more and I think if scum has a vote freeze PR, they'll probably want to save it as long as they can instead of cementing a lead wagon. If sweets is town (which I think he is) and that PR exists, they just let him get miskilled. Then the next day, they just freeze it when a few town members are on split wagons and then scum consolidates for a win.

Which is all to say, I think you're not thinking through your PR mechanics which feels very odd given how you usually play this game.

You think they wait until KiLo to execute it? It's main use is to get a miskill.

Well it would be a guaranteed win.

miskill today or miskill tomorrow...

And if we get that PR today they don't get to use it tomorrow...

[BunnyGo]

Is it in fact detrimental that they stay hidden?

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

I'm not sure to be honest. We have 3 confirmed town PR and 1 pretty-much-confirmed town PR. If the last town PR has used up their role, I think it makes sense for them to claim (especially if they're one of the roles we know was used). However, there's a chance that the last town PR has a non-depleted role. If they do, I don't see the point in outing them.

We could ask the necromancer to claim...

If they don't claim, then that confirms they are scum.

[BunnyGo]

Question #2: Is it time to ask all VTs to claim? To move the POE?

I'm not sure to be honest. We have 3 confirmed town PR and 1 pretty-much-confirmed town PR. If the last town PR has used up their role, I think it makes sense for them to claim (especially if they're one of the roles we know was used). However, there's a chance that the last town PR has a non-depleted role. If they do, I don't see the point in outing them.

We could ask the necromancer to claim...

If they don't claim, then that confirms they are scum.

But I've been playing the last few days as if the necromancer is a specific player that I townread