M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[President Eden]

I won’t vote Fox, food, Bunny, aaro, worcej, or Ezio

Probably cool with anyone else though

[President Eden]

I swear I didn’t copy Ezio’s homework

[Foxcastle]

I won’t vote Fox, food, Bunny, aaro, worcej, or Ezio

Probably cool with anyone else though

What have worcej or Ezio done that is interesting?

Like, they have made no mistakes, not done anything contradictory or rash, just ended up in the middle of the mix. There's nothing scummy about them, but at the same time, it feels to me like there's no way they're even close to being the NK.

[worcej]

I won’t vote Fox, food, Bunny, aaro, worcej, or Ezio

Probably cool with anyone else though

What have worcej or Ezio done that is interesting?

Like, they have made no mistakes, not done anything contradictory or rash, just ended up in the middle of the mix. There's nothing scummy about them, but at the same time, it feels to me like there's no way they're even close to being the NK.

How have I not made any mistakes? I wanted yoyo killed and I was wrong there.

I scummed Jamie - turns out I was wrong there too.

[foodcoats]

I'm only going to vote bona or dousing this phase. Please make the two of them the lead wagons.

I townread worcej strongly.
I townread Eden less strongly.
I townread food strongly.
I townread bunny
I townread fox
I townread aaro
I slight townread Colby.

I’m sheeping the dead, I think.

[worcej]

My count is 13 people left in game, I'm assuming tadpole was accepted.

9-4 day 5
8-4 night 5
7-4 day 6
6-4 night 6
5-4 MYLO

So two miskills left.
Fuck.

This is why I'm at the we need to sort Monarch now point.

If we assume the slot is already dead though, then killing monarch is basically voting no kill here.

Yeah... my point is that's the problem at mylo because a no-kill is giving scum the game.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Worcej is not scum. He has been super towny and honestly has been feeling genuine

Do you think scum would try to play in a way that makes them look towny and feels genuine? I mean, they must accomplish this pretty regularly, right, because scum wins pretty regularly.

Do towns not also act towny? So if I say, DONT VOTE EZIO and you flip scum does that make me towny?

[foodcoats]

I'm only going to vote bona or dousing this phase. Please make the two of them the lead wagons.

I townread worcej strongly.
I townread Eden less strongly.
I townread food strongly.
I townread bunny
I townread fox
I townread aaro
I slight townread Colby.

I’m sheeping the dead, I think.

I guess Bona fits in The Fox Paradigm.

[Foxcastle]

I won’t vote Fox, food, Bunny, aaro, worcej, or Ezio

Probably cool with anyone else though

What have worcej or Ezio done that is interesting?

Like, they have made no mistakes, not done anything contradictory or rash, just ended up in the middle of the mix. There's nothing scummy about them, but at the same time, it feels to me like there's no way they're even close to being the NK.

How have I not made any mistakes? I wanted yoyo killed and I was wrong there.

I scummed Jamie - turns out I was wrong there too.

That's not what I mean. I mean places where you contradicted yourself. Where you did something rash. Where you confused something or went down a rabbithole on something that was pointless.

[Foxcastle]

Worcej is not scum. He has been super towny and honestly has been feeling genuine

Do you think scum would try to play in a way that makes them look towny and feels genuine? I mean, they must accomplish this pretty regularly, right, because scum wins pretty regularly.

Do towns not also act towny? So if I say, DONT VOTE EZIO and you flip scum does that make me towny?

I mean, we keep flipping people because they're not towny enough. And what has that gotten us??? A bunch of townies who didn't look that towny when they got voted.

[worcej]

What have worcej or Ezio done that is interesting?

Like, they have made no mistakes, not done anything contradictory or rash, just ended up in the middle of the mix. There's nothing scummy about them, but at the same time, it feels to me like there's no way they're even close to being the NK.

How have I not made any mistakes? I wanted yoyo killed and I was wrong there.

I scummed Jamie - turns out I was wrong there too.

That's not what I mean. I mean places where you contradicted yourself. Where you did something rash. Where you confused something or went down a rabbithole on something that was pointless.

So your expectation for me is to be somewhat like brain but I've not?

I don't understand what qualifies as rash to you in the context of mafia. Pushing cases and thoughts like Monarch is "rash" to me, but I think you're going to call it "too little too late"

[Foxcastle]

How have I not made any mistakes? I wanted yoyo killed and I was wrong there.

I scummed Jamie - turns out I was wrong there too.

That's not what I mean. I mean places where you contradicted yourself. Where you did something rash. Where you confused something or went down a rabbithole on something that was pointless.

So your expectation for me is to be somewhat like brain but I've not?

I don't understand what qualifies as rash to you in the context of mafia. Pushing cases and thoughts like Monarch is "rash" to me, but I think you're going to call it "too little too late"

Well, my personal theory is that Monarch is town and you're pushing them through because we have limited miskills left and you know pretty well that we're not anywhere on the right track.

[brainbomb]

sweetandcool (3) BunnyGo foodcoats President Eden
Dousing (2) Ezio aarodactyl
aarodactyl (1) Bonatogether
BunnyGo (1) Col7by
worcej (1) Foxcastle
foodcoats (1) JustAGuyNamedWill
TheMadMonarch (1) worcej

Sweetandcool is scheduled to die
29 minutes to go

[worcej]

That's not what I mean. I mean places where you contradicted yourself. Where you did something rash. Where you confused something or went down a rabbithole on something that was pointless.

So your expectation for me is to be somewhat like brain but I've not?

I don't understand what qualifies as rash to you in the context of mafia. Pushing cases and thoughts like Monarch is "rash" to me, but I think you're going to call it "too little too late"

Well, my personal theory is that Monarch is town and you're pushing them through because we have limited miskills left and you know pretty well that we're not anywhere on the right track.

Sure, if you're trying to constantly convince yourself that I am scum than that makes sense.

The actual reality is that I am concerned we're leaving a liability to town's success alive longer than we can afford or she's scum. Both are pro-town reasons for the kill.

[Ezio]

That's not what I mean. I mean places where you contradicted yourself. Where you did something rash. Where you confused something or went down a rabbithole on something that was pointless.

So your expectation for me is to be somewhat like brain but I've not?

I don't understand what qualifies as rash to you in the context of mafia. Pushing cases and thoughts like Monarch is "rash" to me, but I think you're going to call it "too little too late"

Well, my personal theory is that Monarch is town and you're pushing them through because we have limited miskills left and you know pretty well that we're not anywhere on the right track.

With no information on a slot, odds are pretty good that slot is town.
Usually I consider lurking scum indicative so the longer people post nothing like this the scummier they look, but I guess that doesn't apply here.
Clearly a liability.
Does anyone know Moncarch or can contact them out of the game asking them to sub?
I assume she would need to request a sub herself.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Do you think scum would try to play in a way that makes them look towny and feels genuine? I mean, they must accomplish this pretty regularly, right, because scum wins pretty regularly.

Do towns not also act towny? So if I say, DONT VOTE EZIO and you flip scum does that make me towny?

I mean, we keep flipping people because they're not towny enough. And what has that gotten us??? A bunch of townies who didn't look that towny when they got voted.

##VOTE FOX yous towny

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Lmao. ##VOTE FOOD

I disagree in principle

[aarodactyl]

I don’t enjoy that sweet left after seeing the vecna post and that Yoyo was likely to die and hasn’t come back to change their vote.

[sweetandcool]

Sorry, really busy IRL so NAI please.

I read up to yoyoyo flip.

Shockingly, nobody reacted to my Iatrophobe claim, except maybe Vecna in his long post I skimmed?

I've seen something about me claiming two roles this is false.

Kak created a code only I can read. Nothing about a PR there. I am Iatrophobe. I only referenced it once on N1 or N2 (N3?). Somebody (Flum?) said something about doctor protecting me or Squig. I said not to bother (I can't be protected).

Anyways, I'll try ##VOTE Will

I'm sorry I'm not around. I have been dead weight, but it would be better if we flip Mafia.

Oh yeah, and the fact nobody pointed out my HARD CLAIM actually is Town points. Surely my scummates would point out what everyone is missing if I was scum.

[foodcoats]

Why have Bunny and Colby been voting each other all game when no one else has really?

Are they just bussing each other back and forth? Or is it NAI ribbing because they know each other personally?