M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Jamiet99uk]

The first one was clearly a joke.

It still counted as a vote. You didn't need to cast the vote again.

Yes I did. I don't want to be mod killed for joke votes.

Why would you be modkilled for that?

[Bonatogether]

Flum was up by 3 votes over second place with 5 minutes left. It’s disingenuous to say that it wasn’t a real wagon.

at the instant you're talking about, dousing is only on flum for like 20 seconds max, flav is entirely voting for self-preservation at this point, and like half the wagon is afk or lurking (you, demon). there was no momentum and it was driven by pro-flav votes rather than anti-flum ones.

Yeah you’re kinda right,

Although there was a fair chance he could’ve been voted up. It’s not like the attempted Colby wagon

the four votes that moved onto flum at eod were not stable flum votes - there wasn't a core argument that he was scum that was acknowledged by those four in the way that there were narratives of flav or food being scum

[Bonatogether]

hi eden

[Jamiet99uk]

Sweet gets a scum notch for voting Vecna twice, because this is a sketchy strategy I've seen used in the past, and I've even done it myself occasionally.

Basically, voting the same person more than once can create a false impression that a wagon is actually gaining momentum, when in fact it is not.

[sweetandcool]

Sweet gets a scum notch for voting Vecna twice, because this is a sketchy strategy I've seen used in the past, and I've even done it myself occasionally.

Basically, voting the same person more than once can create a false impression that a wagon is actually gaining momentum, when in fact it is not.

[sweetandcool]

It still counted as a vote. You didn't need to cast the vote again.

Yes I did. I don't want to be mod killed for joke votes.

Why would you be modkilled for that?

Because I hurt brainbomb's feelies once. That guy has it out for me.

[Dousing]

##Vote food
I hope everyone has had a nice weekend.
I will try to get some semblance of back into the game. May not be by end of day though.

You voted for the counter-wagon to Foodcoats at EoD last day.

Why did you do that, and why are you now back to thinking Foodcoats is scum?

Foodcoats was a viable wagon all of D3 and you didn't vote for him at any point, preferring to vote for Yoyo, Flum, and then Flavius.

Why didn't you vote for Foodcoats?

When you voted for Flavius you said "fine, have your kill" as if you were resigning reluctantly to vote Flavius and weren't really behind the wagon. Yet you strongly scumread him D1 and N1, and repeatedly voiced a scumread on him D2 as well.

So why "fine, have your kill"...? Why not "yeah, we're going to get Flav at last, I've been scumreading him since D1!" ?

Discuss?

Woah

##vote DemonRHK

[sweetandcool]

##VOTE Demon

Quick everyone, huge wagon forming, join the party.

##VOTE Demon

There's another one. Wow votes are piling in like pigs in a blanket!

[Jamiet99uk]

Yes I did. I don't want to be mod killed for joke votes.

Why would you be modkilled for that?

Because I hurt brainbomb's feelies once. That guy has it out for me.

You're incredibly jokey this afternoon aren't you.

[sweetandcool]

##Vote food
I hope everyone has had a nice weekend.
I will try to get some semblance of back into the game. May not be by end of day though.

You voted for the counter-wagon to Foodcoats at EoD last day.

Why did you do that, and why are you now back to thinking Foodcoats is scum?

Foodcoats was a viable wagon all of D3 and you didn't vote for him at any point, preferring to vote for Yoyo, Flum, and then Flavius.

Why didn't you vote for Foodcoats?

When you voted for Flavius you said "fine, have your kill" as if you were resigning reluctantly to vote Flavius and weren't really behind the wagon. Yet you strongly scumread him D1 and N1, and repeatedly voiced a scumread on him D2 as well.

So why "fine, have your kill"...? Why not "yeah, we're going to get Flav at last, I've been scumreading him since D1!" ?

Discuss?

Woah

##vote DemonRHK

My plot is already working, epic!

[Ezio]

at the instant you're talking about, dousing is only on flum for like 20 seconds max, flav is entirely voting for self-preservation at this point, and like half the wagon is afk or lurking (you, demon). there was no momentum and it was driven by pro-flav votes rather than anti-flum ones.

I'm not sure that's true. If more people on this wagon were voting to save Flav, why didn't more of them vote Food?

aaro was afk
demon was afkesque?
dousing does vote food
flav disappears before peak flum, but was voting to save himself
food votes flav for self-pres
fox never moves despite being around, but indicates that he thinks flav is town and that food is scummy

so among the players active at eod not wagons themselves (dousing, fox), all end up voting food. demon votes flav but does offer a positive scumread of him.

I see. Afk yea.
Dousing went bona-flav-flum-flav-food. Does that feel pro Flav?
Fox didn't end the day voting for food.
Idk it feels weird to describe the entire wagon in such a way, when it only applies to like 2 people, and it doesn't look like it really applies

[sweetandcool]

Why would you be modkilled for that?

Because I hurt brainbomb's feelies once. That guy has it out for me.

You're incredibly jokey this afternoon aren't you.

Yeah, probably too much, sorry.

Thanks for not getting mad at me.

[Bonatogether]

I'm not sure that's true. If more people on this wagon were voting to save Flav, why didn't more of them vote Food?

aaro was afk
demon was afkesque?
dousing does vote food
flav disappears before peak flum, but was voting to save himself
food votes flav for self-pres
fox never moves despite being around, but indicates that he thinks flav is town and that food is scummy

so among the players active at eod not wagons themselves (dousing, fox), all end up voting food. demon votes flav but does offer a positive scumread of him.

I see. Afk yea.
Dousing went bona-flav-flum-flav-food. Does that feel pro Flav?
Fox didn't end the day voting for food.
Idk it feels weird to describe the entire wagon in such a way, when it only applies to like 2 people, and it doesn't look like it really applies

dousing - ultimately, yes
fox cannot be described as protecting flum lmao

[Ezio]

@bona
@monarch
@demon
@dousing
Why are you all voting food right now?
I would appreciate hearing in your own words.

[President Eden]

##VOTE Demon

Quick everyone, huge wagon forming, join the party.

##VOTE Demon

There's another one. Wow votes are piling in like pigs in a blanket!

##VOTE DemonOverlord

[Bonatogether]

also not all people on a wagon evenly affect wagon character

[Ezio]

aaro was afk
demon was afkesque?
dousing does vote food
flav disappears before peak flum, but was voting to save himself
food votes flav for self-pres
fox never moves despite being around, but indicates that he thinks flav is town and that food is scummy

so among the players active at eod not wagons themselves (dousing, fox), all end up voting food. demon votes flav but does offer a positive scumread of him.

I see. Afk yea.
Dousing went bona-flav-flum-flav-food. Does that feel pro Flav?
Fox didn't end the day voting for food.
Idk it feels weird to describe the entire wagon in such a way, when it only applies to like 2 people, and it doesn't look like it really applies

dousing - ultimately, yes
fox cannot be described as protecting flum lmao

Did I get it flipped? I thought you were arguing the Flum wagon was to protect Flav.

[Dousing]

I'm not sure that's true. If more people on this wagon were voting to save Flav, why didn't more of them vote Food?

aaro was afk
demon was afkesque?
dousing does vote food
flav disappears before peak flum, but was voting to save himself
food votes flav for self-pres
fox never moves despite being around, but indicates that he thinks flav is town and that food is scummy

so among the players active at eod not wagons themselves (dousing, fox), all end up voting food. demon votes flav but does offer a positive scumread of him.

I see. Afk yea.
Dousing went bona-flav-flum-flav-food. Does that feel pro Flav?
Fox didn't end the day voting for food.
Idk it feels weird to describe the entire wagon in such a way, when it only applies to like 2 people, and it doesn't look like it really applies

FWIW my votes were all done in a panic I essentially blacked out lmao

I’m not present for a lot of EoD’s so they always make me go a bit crazy. I did actually want to vote foodcoats that day though

[Dousing]

Does anyone find it weird that the demon wagon has gained steam this easily?

[Vecna]

so sweet, still think that msg about the tadpole was innocent?

because youre gonna be everyones #1 scumread now

Seems too prescient to me.

##VOTE Vecna

I'm almost certainly not doing anything productive this phase since a VIP is visiting today (IRL). So Fox is Town and BM WAS Mafia. So President Eden is Town.

how do you conclude the bm is mafia?