M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Bonatogether]

every time i see a brain post i think someone else died

[Jamiet99uk]

so sweet, still think that msg about the tadpole was innocent?

because youre gonna be everyones #1 scumread now

Seems too prescient to me.

##VOTE Vecna

I'm almost certainly not doing anything productive this phase since a VIP is visiting today (IRL). So Fox is Town and BM WAS Mafia. So President Eden is Town.

Why did you vote for Vecna twice?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I had a thought

##VOTE VECNA

Seems Vecna has been not towny all game and yet seems to survive…

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Omg genuinely did not see sweet’s vote on vecna

[Jamiet99uk]

I read the flum death post. My main takeaway is that:
Mechanics:
-this makes me more confident BM is scum
-this means archer is definitely town. I’m assuming they haven’t claimed since they’re the only townclear at this point.

Reads:
-this makes bunny town to me due to his interactions with flum
-it makes me super suspicious of whoever led the food flashwagon on D3. The bot is somehow working for me at work (despite webdip being banned) and from a skim of this, it makes me really suspicious of Ezio, Justin and sweets. Less sus of the later votes once it became a matter of avoiding a tie.

Have a meeting in a few minutes so will disappear again. Will probably catch up from around this point when I can.

Uh no, the Archer has claimed. He claimed right before he fired.

[Ezio]

Guys take a look at EoD 3. Flum didn't end the day as a top 2 wagon but might have ended there. There is tons of relevant movement now we know that Flum was scum.
I think RHK looks town for voting Flum when he did (was 6-4 flav vs Flum he made it 6-5). He also moved back on Flav later though, and did end the day there...
Food looks very towny as well (making it 6-4 for flum)
I think people who left from Flav to Food look town as well, because they potentially put Flum at risk of being flipped.
Notably, imo, nobody did that except for dousing.

Man I need some time away. I want to believe so badly I'm right about food and this was scum v scum.

Also I'm insane because SnC did vote food after being on the Flav wagon.

[aarodactyl]

Ok. I’m thoroughly confused about the game state (though I did see fox claimed archer before the shot) and I’m probably going to need to jump on a work call any minute.

I read d3 voting as a speed wagon to save flum (despite Bona insisting that wasn’t the case), so I don’t want to vote for food today. I also feel pretty strongly that PE and bunny are town so I’m going to sheep them on the demon wagon for now just in case I’m not able to get back by eod. ##vote demon

[Jamiet99uk]

I had a thought

##VOTE VECNA

Seems Vecna has been not towny all game and yet seems to survive…

Vecna looks a damn sight townier than you do

[aarodactyl]

I read the flum death post. My main takeaway is that:
Mechanics:
-this makes me more confident BM is scum
-this means archer is definitely town. I’m assuming they haven’t claimed since they’re the only townclear at this point.

Reads:
-this makes bunny town to me due to his interactions with flum
-it makes me super suspicious of whoever led the food flashwagon on D3. The bot is somehow working for me at work (despite webdip being banned) and from a skim of this, it makes me really suspicious of Ezio, Justin and sweets. Less sus of the later votes once it became a matter of avoiding a tie.

Have a meeting in a few minutes so will disappear again. Will probably catch up from around this point when I can.

Uh no, the Archer has claimed. He claimed right before he fired.

Yeah. I just saw his claim. I was reading from newest to oldest because I don’t have time to catch up before eod

[sweetandcool]

so sweet, still think that msg about the tadpole was innocent?

because youre gonna be everyones #1 scumread now

Seems too prescient to me.

##VOTE Vecna

I'm almost certainly not doing anything productive this phase since a VIP is visiting today (IRL). So Fox is Town and BM WAS Mafia. So President Eden is Town.

Why did you vote for Vecna twice?

The first one was clearly a joke.

[Jamiet99uk]

I still want us to flip JustWill, but I will move to DemonRHK if that isn't going to fly today.

[Ezio]

this post assumes that the flum wagon ever had a possibility of being the flip, which i just don't believe. eod3 was comprised of flav and anti-flav wagons, not flum and anti-flum wagons

Flum was up by 3 votes over second place with 5 minutes left. It’s disingenuous to say that it wasn’t a real wagon.

at the instant you're talking about, dousing is only on flum for like 20 seconds max, flav is entirely voting for self-preservation at this point, and like half the wagon is afk or lurking (you, demon). there was no momentum and it was driven by pro-flav votes rather than anti-flum ones.

I'm not sure that's true. If more people on this wagon were voting to save Flav, why didn't more of them vote Food?

[Jamiet99uk]

Seems too prescient to me.

##VOTE Vecna

I'm almost certainly not doing anything productive this phase since a VIP is visiting today (IRL). So Fox is Town and BM WAS Mafia. So President Eden is Town.

Why did you vote for Vecna twice?

The first one was clearly a joke.

It still counted as a vote. You didn't need to cast the vote again.

[Ezio]

Flum was up by 3 votes over second place with 5 minutes left. It’s disingenuous to say that it wasn’t a real wagon.

at the instant you're talking about, dousing is only on flum for like 20 seconds max, flav is entirely voting for self-preservation at this point, and like half the wagon is afk or lurking (you, demon). there was no momentum and it was driven by pro-flav votes rather than anti-flum ones.

I'm not sure that's true. If more people on this wagon were voting to save Flav, why didn't more of them vote Food?

Like, who do you think was voting Flum to save Flav?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I had a thought

##VOTE VECNA

Seems Vecna has been not towny all game and yet seems to survive…

Vecna looks a damn sight townier than you do

K well i mean i know im town tbf

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Im only allowed to be voted D1 or in milo

[Dousing]

@Dousing - what is your mafia game experience?

Aside from casual games I’ve played in school, I’ve played twice before. This will be my third ever game of mafia.

Every game I’ve played was on webdip.

[Dousing]

this post assumes that the flum wagon ever had a possibility of being the flip, which i just don't believe. eod3 was comprised of flav and anti-flav wagons, not flum and anti-flum wagons

Flum was up by 3 votes over second place with 5 minutes left. It’s disingenuous to say that it wasn’t a real wagon.

at the instant you're talking about, dousing is only on flum for like 20 seconds max, flav is entirely voting for self-preservation at this point, and like half the wagon is afk or lurking (you, demon). there was no momentum and it was driven by pro-flav votes rather than anti-flum ones.

Yeah you’re kinda right,

Although there was a fair chance he could’ve been voted up. It’s not like the attempted Colby wagon

[sweetandcool]

Why did you vote for Vecna twice?

The first one was clearly a joke.

It still counted as a vote. You didn't need to cast the vote again.

Yes I did. I don't want to be mod killed for joke votes.

[Bonatogether]

Flum was up by 3 votes over second place with 5 minutes left. It’s disingenuous to say that it wasn’t a real wagon.

at the instant you're talking about, dousing is only on flum for like 20 seconds max, flav is entirely voting for self-preservation at this point, and like half the wagon is afk or lurking (you, demon). there was no momentum and it was driven by pro-flav votes rather than anti-flum ones.

I'm not sure that's true. If more people on this wagon were voting to save Flav, why didn't more of them vote Food?

aaro was afk
demon was afkesque?
dousing does vote food
flav disappears before peak flum, but was voting to save himself
food votes flav for self-pres
fox never moves despite being around, but indicates that he thinks flav is town and that food is scummy

so among the players active at eod not wagons themselves (dousing, fox), all end up voting food. demon votes flav but does offer a positive scumread of him.