M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Vecna]

i also feel jamiets reaction to all sweets shenanigans is pretty mild. You okay with lying all of a sudden jamiet?

Yeah...the only locking onto he's done all game is damo.

He didn't care about pirate self voting.

##vote jami

Humbly request the vig elim Pres for us

Or aaro...that'd be a good one too.

Maybe tadpoled sweet...

Here's a hot take: Maybe Vecna is tadpoled.

One of you started running with that idea. Almost as if a fresh tadpole inductee had the tadpole strongly in mind and ran with fingering someone.

Most people haven't bothered thinking too much about who the tadpole is. So it's notable that Bunny and Vecna are suddenly obsessed.

you know what the most interesting thing is?

flum left this giant breadcrumb start of day 3 directed at you that screams "I WAS THE ONE THAT TADPOLED YOU. ITS SAFE TO JOIN THE MAFIA. ACCEPT".

And you never batted an eye at that.

no suspicion that he was tryibg to frame you in case he flips scum?

did that just pass you by?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Hi!

Hi bunny. How are you

Tired and confused.

I’ve done 0 VCA because I don’t have the time. And gone see the benefit yet.

So I just have tone to go on. And I have some I town read. And way too many scum reads/null.

You?

Same lmao, I wanna kill da maf but I’m washed

[foodcoats]

Since the necromancer was not claimed last night, do people feel it is likely scum? If it is scum holding it they will likely claim later if they are going to be DKd and I’m curious to know what logic people would have.

For me, it is mostly “Didn’t claim it before EON, therefore scum,” because town necro would want to share ghug’s alignment; except in the case of a few people who might not grasp the mechs if they are newer and hence might not claim (as I have delayed RB claiming in the past, for example). However, I think the existence of daychat makes it more complicated (as if it is scum necro, any scum can claim it), and it would have to be a near auto-rejection of town necro claiming.

Thoughts?

[Vecna]

To be fair, with tadpole in play it's no longer easy to Town anyone.

I'm guessing best play is to pretend it doesn't exist and keep hunting the OG scum. Tadpole is kind of like the final boss.

Maybe don't trust people as much, though that is tragic.

I'm honestly disappointed in the person who accepted it.

So I'm trying to think who would have rejected and who would have accepted.

Woah woah woah what how do you know it was accepted???????

Bunny???????

because there is 0 reason not to claim if u rejected it

turn on ze brainpower

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

I'm honestly disappointed in the person who accepted it.

So I'm trying to think who would have rejected and who would have accepted.

Woah woah woah what how do you know it was accepted???????

Bunny???????

because there is 0 reason not to claim if u rejected it

turn on ze brainpower

No but claiming tadpole is a death sentence right. Cuz ppl are going to flip u

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Vecna seems to be throwin hella shade this game

hells to the yeah.

you got a problem with that, gnome?

hells to the yeah

You got a problem with me, gnome?

[Yoyoyozo]

grouping people together for reasons I haven't figured out yet:
jamiet, bunny, me
colby, aaro
sweet, worcej

[Vecna]

will they? town has no reason to hide it, only scum does.

even dying as a tadpole rejecting town is probably worth it. it gives the rest of the town a +700% boost to scum hunting efficiency.

(7 multiplied by an inferior number is still a rather disappointing scum efficiency rating but im sure itll help a tad(pole) bit)

[Yoyoyozo]

Oh, now I see it

[sweetandcool]

Yeah...the only locking onto he's done all game is damo.

He didn't care about pirate self voting.

##vote jami

Humbly request the vig elim Pres for us

Or aaro...that'd be a good one too.

Maybe tadpoled sweet...

Here's a hot take: Maybe Vecna is tadpoled.

One of you started running with that idea. Almost as if a fresh tadpole inductee had the tadpole strongly in mind and ran with fingering someone.

Most people haven't bothered thinking too much about who the tadpole is. So it's notable that Bunny and Vecna are suddenly obsessed.

you know what the most interesting thing is?

flum left this giant breadcrumb start of day 3 directed at you that screams "I WAS THE ONE THAT TADPOLED YOU. ITS SAFE TO JOIN THE MAFIA. ACCEPT".

And you never batted an eye at that.

no suspicion that he was tryibg to frame you in case he flips scum?

did that just pass you by?

Huh?

I don't know what this is and it doesn't make sense. Why would Mafia need to tell their tadpole it is okay?

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Here's a hot take: Maybe Vecna is tadpoled.

One of you started running with that idea. Almost as if a fresh tadpole inductee had the tadpole strongly in mind and ran with fingering someone.

Most people haven't bothered thinking too much about who the tadpole is. So it's notable that Bunny and Vecna are suddenly obsessed.

you know what the most interesting thing is?

flum left this giant breadcrumb start of day 3 directed at you that screams "I WAS THE ONE THAT TADPOLED YOU. ITS SAFE TO JOIN THE MAFIA. ACCEPT".

And you never batted an eye at that.

no suspicion that he was tryibg to frame you in case he flips scum?

did that just pass you by?

Huh?

I don't know what this is and it doesn't make sense. Why would Mafia need to tell their tadpole it is okay?

Exactly. Just seems like a needless risk

[Vecna]

you and flum have been having cosy interactions all game.

if you were tadpoled, that msg from flum at start of day3 would definately influe ce your decision.

and if scumflum ever flips, that msg would definately result in you dying directly after.

im sure it looks like an innocent joke to the unobservant eye, but the implications can be quite far reaching

[BunnyGo]

Turns out my Aunt and Uncle aren't going to be until the arvo. Reading through now.

What's an arvo?

[Fluminator]

We should not be looking for the tadpoled person right now. Maybe we'll get lucky but we still have tons of normal mafia to look for.

My post to Sweet was referencing my very first interaction with him on the first day. It was a joke.

I noticed food's PR softing for that speak with dead role. I am skeptical brain would give that to a mafia so I had been soft townreading him for it since he started. The VCA analysis for day 3 is still a little sketchy for him but Fox fits the bill better.

Fox is linked with both Aaro and Bunny, I need to check if Aaro and Bunny make sense together. (Beyond one babysitting the other in a previous life)

[BunnyGo]

To be fair, with tadpole in play it's no longer easy to Town anyone.

I'm guessing best play is to pretend it doesn't exist and keep hunting the OG scum. Tadpole is kind of like the final boss.

Maybe don't trust people as much, though that is tragic.

I'm honestly disappointed in the person who accepted it.

So I'm trying to think who would have rejected and who would have accepted.

Woah woah woah what how do you know it was accepted???????

Bunny???????

Anyone who was offered it, and rejected it, and didn't loudly shout about it to the thread isn't playing to their wincon and should be punished under whatever rule that is.

Quite frankly, I'm surprised the person who accepted it didn't fake claim that they rejected it. But oh well.

[BunnyGo]

This is just a complete fucking lie.

Are you so fucking lazy, or are you scum?

I'm not rereading this game much....you know, nearly 300 pages and not a lot of time.

So fine, call it lazy. But I've not done my normal double reads of a day/night and isos.

Have you SEEN me do a single ballad yet?

This is the impression you've made on me the first pass.

I guess as you would say "READ YOUR POSTS! It's OBVIOUS"

As that was so many of your posts, I got else out of your stuff.

the fuck. you got scared of jamiets bite?

yall are chickens.

Who said I'm scared of Jamie? I answered his question.

[Vecna]

We should not be looking for the tadpoled person right now. Maybe we'll get lucky but we still have tons of normal mafia to look for.

My post to Sweet was referencing my very first interaction with him on the first day. It was a joke.

I noticed food's PR softing for that speak with dead role. I am skeptical brain would give that to a mafia so I had been soft townreading him for it since he started. The VCA analysis for day 3 is still a little sketchy for him but Fox fits the bill better.

Fox is linked with both Aaro and Bunny, I need to check if Aaro and Bunny make sense together. (Beyond one babysitting the other in a previous life)

if you are town, that joke will cause problems.

also, stop with this nonsense that insinuates the setup is not random. those types of reasoning completely invalidates any other argument that follows, because the setup is guaranteed to be random. any allignment can get any role.

[BunnyGo]

##Vote Sweet

You've been flirting with evil too long. You're most likely tadpoled

@vecna

This one upvoted by sweet?

[Yoyoyozo]

I'm honestly disappointed in the person who accepted it.

So I'm trying to think who would have rejected and who would have accepted.

Woah woah woah what how do you know it was accepted???????

Bunny???????

Anyone who was offered it, and rejected it, and didn't loudly shout about it to the thread isn't playing to their wincon and should be punished under whatever rule that is.

Quite frankly, I'm surprised the person who accepted it didn't fake claim that they rejected it. But oh well.

There are perfectly acceptable reasons why someone would reject it and not claim so in thread. They could have been trying to see how mafia would react during the day in order to gauge if they should accept it. If they are acting needlessly buddy buddy, it could be an indication that they are trying to get their attention, which as scum is not a great idea this town would reject the tadpole and continue scum hunt…
Blah blah blah my point is that this isn’t necessarily true

[Fluminator]

If I signaled to Sweet I gave him a tadpole before he accepted it, that would be insanely risky.