M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[President Eden]

PE's logic about VCA on Fox is sound, but it leaves out the Battlemaster possibility and ignores pretty much the rest of Fox's play.

It more or less does ignore Fox's play, yes. (I did separately read some of his posts after reaching my conclusion, and I wasn't dissuaded from my conclusion. But I'm sure reading them in that lens isn't the fairest way to handle it.)

What Battle Master possibility do you think I'm not accounting for, though?

If mafia knew that both Balki and Dip would flip, then they have nothing to gain by bussing/trying to save/distancing/etc

That's true, in which case there's not much to be read from D2. I suspect if we really dug into it, we might find reasons to think mafia did/didn't know. With <10mins to EOD and 2k posts I'm not reading I'm just going to default to the lame but true "Battle Master by random chance is ~75% to be town" and suggest we kill Fox anyway lol.

[Bonatogether]

##vote colby

what are you doing

[BunnyGo]

##vote colby

where did this come from?

I’ve been trying it. Read my iso like you said

[Foxcastle]

he's openwolfing in the thread and pretending to be trash for townpoints

Im not trash, I think I have made a lot of good points.
I just like to be active and really get deep into the game thats why Im active, I think its fun. Im not wolfing, Im pushing people who I think are mafia...because thats what you do.
Never not once did I ever say to stop investigating or talking about someone, Ive ALWAYS been pro discussion, in fact I think I sparked a lot of it

YOU'VE SPENT DAYS ARGUING WE CAN'T LOOK AT FOX BECAUSE HE HASN'T POSTED A SPREADSHEET

Again, why would scum do something that likely to garner exactly this response?

[foodcoats]

Hmmm

##VOTE Flum

Sweet join me? Get yer slam dunk?

Jesus openwolfing

Hehe

Just making fun of you lol

[Squigs44]

I hate all the wagons

[President Eden]

Ah, right. Why wouldn't there be a completely new set of wagons at T-5mins lol.

[Dousing]

##VOTE Flum

[FlaviusAetius]

he's openwolfing in the thread and pretending to be trash for townpoints

Im not trash, I think I have made a lot of good points.
I just like to be active and really get deep into the game thats why Im active, I think its fun. Im not wolfing, Im pushing people who I think are mafia...because thats what you do.
Never not once did I ever say to stop investigating or talking about someone, Ive ALWAYS been pro discussion, in fact I think I sparked a lot of it

YOU'VE SPENT DAYS ARGUING WE CAN'T LOOK AT FOX BECAUSE HE HASN'T POSTED A SPREADSHEET

I have said MULTIPLE times I DIDNT say that though. I said we cant make FULL judgements on him until we SEE the spreadsheet, and we should be PRESSURING him to PROVIDE IT.
I didnt say we SHOULDNT talk about him, TALK ABOUT HIM, we've been doing it ALL DAY. AND MORE. I ONLY said we need to SEE his spreadsheet TOO

[BunnyGo]

##vote colby

what are you doing

Seeing if people would vote out a different scum.

[Ezio]

I hate all the wagons

I don't love them. ##vote Food? Can we make it happen?

[Bonatogether]

Im not trash, I think I have made a lot of good points.
I just like to be active and really get deep into the game thats why Im active, I think its fun. Im not wolfing, Im pushing people who I think are mafia...because thats what you do.
Never not once did I ever say to stop investigating or talking about someone, Ive ALWAYS been pro discussion, in fact I think I sparked a lot of it

YOU'VE SPENT DAYS ARGUING WE CAN'T LOOK AT FOX BECAUSE HE HASN'T POSTED A SPREADSHEET

Again, why would scum do something that likely to garner exactly this response?

what do you mean again? you've not said a word to me yet this game

[BunnyGo]

##VOTE Flum

##vote Flav

[Dousing]

##VOTE Flum

Nvm, ##VOTE flav

[foodcoats]

Actually whatever Flav v Flum v Fox seems destined to bear VCA fruit

You should kill Flum and pluck a scumberry!

I’m voting Flum. You are definitely a town read for me

[Bonatogether]

##VOTE Flum

fake!

[Bonatogether]

##VOTE Flum

Nvm, ##VOTE flav

REAL

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Bunny is trying to buddy me so damn hard rn

[Dousing]

I stg if we tie

[BunnyGo]

I hate all the wagons

Agreed. Hence my Colby try