M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Dousing]

I want movement ##VOTE Bunny

[worcej]

Lol ghug died again

Sucks to suck

Quick we need a custodian themed one.

I'd need some help to know what you mean

[foodcoats]

I don’t think aaro will be the final winner here so I will go full throttle with my biggest scumread which at least a few others seem to agree with

##VOTE bona

[sweetandcool]

Quick we need a custodian themed one.

I'd need some help to know what you mean

Add a pile of poo, and a mop in someone's hand. Maybe a big custodial key ring as well.

[FlaviusAetius]

I joined it but I cant let Fox live down that he literally LIED about having a spreadsheet

WHERE FLAV?!?!?
WHERE DID HE LIE?!?!?!
QUOTES!!!! I NEED QUOTES!!!!

I feel like the foxcaslte//spreadsheet thing was common knowledge for quite a while.

I’m pretty sure he did say smt but even if Fox never outright said “I have a spreadsheet with everyone on it” he AT LEAST lied by omission by letting the rumor circulate for so long

Here are oyur quotes and notice how I UNDERLINED "heavily implied" meaning I ONLY got the quotes that he literally said spreadsheet(where he LITERALLY said it) he also says he IMPLIED it. WOW. And now Dousing is saying he let this rumor go one for so long this is Fox is so done for this Im sorry Im not letting him live this down until I get a proper explanation

[Yoyoyozo]

Completely random, but have you guys ever played that Mario Party 2 game on N64 where the Boo ghosts are dancing around you and one of them is slightly off and that’s where you need to jump? That’s what an anarchist is in my reads.

[Dousing]

I don’t think aaro will be the final winner here so I will go full throttle with my biggest scumread which at least a few others seem to agree with

##VOTE bona

Bona works too

##VOTE bona

[Fluminator]

##Vote Fox, I didn't appreciate how averse he was to voting Balki at the end there. Let's make him the runway wagon.

I still think his Dip wagon was terrible too.

[Fluminator]

Quick we need a custodian themed one.

I'd need some help to know what you mean

I don't understand why mafia or town would kill ghug but I'm not complaining this game

[Dousing]

Idk about the fox wagon. I want to hear what Fox has to say for one more day

[Dousing]

Quick we need a custodian themed one.

I'd need some help to know what you mean

I don't understand why mafia or town would kill ghug but I'm not complaining this game

Agree

[FlaviusAetius]

why are you preemptively white knighting flav?

I townread him and see people scumreading him due to misunderstanding his logic. I think people will have more accurate reads of Flav if they understand Flavs thought processes better.
It's no secret I disagree with some of the ways webdip players operate. I've complained about townslips/scumslips, hyperfocusing on mechanics before we have relevant info, etc. I think webdip as a whole attributes differences in thought processes to scuminess too much (myself included tbh). This is an attempt to correct that in part

But if you disagree and think Flavs poorly made assumptions make him more likely scum, I look forward to hearing all about that

if you've read what i've had to say, i've never claimed that his thought process makes him scum. i've only said that his constant attempts to push people away from making reads on fox is dog shit as town play, and likely to be scum. those posts are in the thread we both share, so i encourage you to read them.

But I didnt say that did I? I said how can we judge someone without getting the full picture on them you want to scum read him for lots of good reasons I dont deny those reasons, but I also explained why even YOU should want to see Fox's spreadsheet it would give us good stuff on him, and I didnt leave an open ended time limit I said he had to do it soon, and soon meant today and we finally pressured him and look waht happened?

He doesnt have a spreadsheet!

[FlaviusAetius]

##Vote Fox, I didn't appreciate how averse he was to voting Balki at the end there. Let's make him the runway wagon.

I still think his Dip wagon was terrible too.

See that was crazy too, I even defended him against Balki and ever since that interraction he's had with Balki he's been mr. mafia

[Dousing]

I townread him and see people scumreading him due to misunderstanding his logic. I think people will have more accurate reads of Flav if they understand Flavs thought processes better.
It's no secret I disagree with some of the ways webdip players operate. I've complained about townslips/scumslips, hyperfocusing on mechanics before we have relevant info, etc. I think webdip as a whole attributes differences in thought processes to scuminess too much (myself included tbh). This is an attempt to correct that in part

But if you disagree and think Flavs poorly made assumptions make him more likely scum, I look forward to hearing all about that

if you've read what i've had to say, i've never claimed that his thought process makes him scum. i've only said that his constant attempts to push people away from making reads on fox is dog shit as town play, and likely to be scum. those posts are in the thread we both share, so i encourage you to read them.

But I didnt say that did I? I said how can we judge someone without getting the full picture on them you want to scum read him for lots of good reasons I dont deny those reasons, but I also explained why even YOU should want to see Fox's spreadsheet it would give us good stuff on him, and I didnt leave an open ended time limit I said he had to do it soon, and soon meant today and we finally pressured him and look waht happened?

He doesnt have a spreadsheet!

That’s a good point, Fox only caved under pressure.

If there wasn’t any pressure put on him there’s a good chance he would’ve just let the mystique build up

[Dousing]

For the record (very good chance I’m tunneling) my first choice kill would be yoyo

Gut instinct

[FlaviusAetius]

You mean the whole spreadsheet thing?

yes

I mean, I think that still boils down to a bad assumption from Flav. He clearly thinks that Fox has a spreadsheet and that his posts/reads were influenced by the spreadsheet. So to him, asking for a spreadsheet was akin to asking someone for reasons after they place a naked vote or some similar situation.
Fox has since said he has no spreadsheet, so Flavs obviously in the wrong here. But the question is what's the scum motivation for Flav to demand a spreadsheet vs what's the town motivation? I see you've said it's anti-town, which I understand, but what does scum!Flav gain by insisting for more info from Fox before giving a final read on Fox? And is it inconsistent for a town!Flav to act this way?

wait wait wait you KNEW Fox had no spreadsheet despite him saying he did? Why arent YOU voting for Fox right now when you knew 30 pages ago

[aarodactyl]

WHERE FLAV?!?!?
WHERE DID HE LIE?!?!?!
QUOTES!!!! I NEED QUOTES!!!!

I feel like the foxcaslte//spreadsheet thing was common knowledge for quite a while.

I’m pretty sure he did say smt but even if Fox never outright said “I have a spreadsheet with everyone on it” he AT LEAST lied by omission by letting the rumor circulate for so long

Here are oyur quotes and notice how I UNDERLINED "heavily implied" meaning I ONLY got the quotes that he literally said spreadsheet(where he LITERALLY said it) he also says he IMPLIED it. WOW. And now Dousing is saying he let this rumor go one for so long this is Fox is so done for this Im sorry Im not letting him live this down until I get a proper explanation

Now that I'm finally on desktop, I'm realizing that all the error messages I've been seeing at the end of your posts have been actual pictures. Can you please embed them or use quotes going forward? It seems the attachments are broken on mobile (or at least they don't show previews) so it makes it really hard to read them.

[FlaviusAetius]

Idk about the fox wagon. I want to hear what Fox has to say for one more day

Who would you rather we take down instead? Someone else previously said we dont need to take down a lurker today(yoyozo), plus there arent any lurkers anymore(probably because of the uncovering of the designated mafia role plot)
So D1-->Middle of D2 is important to finding that one out.

Who would Fox be under my theory...maybe a skater I would say what kind of analysis has he actually done without his spreadsheet? I really wanted to catchup until I got to ghug being dead but we are running out of time Im going to look back at Fox and see what kind of analysis he has actually done.

My prediction? NONE

[FlaviusAetius]

I feel like the foxcaslte//spreadsheet thing was common knowledge for quite a while.

I’m pretty sure he did say smt but even if Fox never outright said “I have a spreadsheet with everyone on it” he AT LEAST lied by omission by letting the rumor circulate for so long

Here are oyur quotes and notice how I UNDERLINED "heavily implied" meaning I ONLY got the quotes that he literally said spreadsheet(where he LITERALLY said it) he also says he IMPLIED it. WOW. And now Dousing is saying he let this rumor go one for so long this is Fox is so done for this Im sorry Im not letting him live this down until I get a proper explanation

Now that I'm finally on desktop, I'm realizing that all the error messages I've been seeing at the end of your posts have been actual pictures. Can you please embed them or use quotes going forward? It seems the attachments are broken on mobile (or at least they don't show previews) so it makes it really hard to read them.

I dont know how to embed, but yes I can quote them directly

[Dousing]

yes

I mean, I think that still boils down to a bad assumption from Flav. He clearly thinks that Fox has a spreadsheet and that his posts/reads were influenced by the spreadsheet. So to him, asking for a spreadsheet was akin to asking someone for reasons after they place a naked vote or some similar situation.
Fox has since said he has no spreadsheet, so Flavs obviously in the wrong here. But the question is what's the scum motivation for Flav to demand a spreadsheet vs what's the town motivation? I see you've said it's anti-town, which I understand, but what does scum!Flav gain by insisting for more info from Fox before giving a final read on Fox? And is it inconsistent for a town!Flav to act this way?

wait wait wait you KNEW Fox had no spreadsheet despite him saying he did? Why arent YOU voting for Fox right now when you knew 30 pages ago

Squigs defending fox castle despite him being SUCH a runaway wagon gives town vibes imo

I feel like a mafia member would prefer to bus and gain some towncred instead of defending a cause they know is gonna make them look sus