M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[aarodactyl]

M62 had 26 players and started with two official substitutes lined up.

That game had the best rookie class of any game (no offense colby). Also my phone did die but I’m home and charged it. I’m going to set my desktop up (it’s currently hooked up with my work laptop) and then use it so I can actually make a well formatted post and look at more than 1 thing at once

The amount of posts where aaro explains the minutiae of his daily life is too high.

Sorry I had twitter and webdip open and mixed them up

[Squigs44]

This is the post I didnt like where you pushed others to join an lfischl wagon:

@squig & Vecna & Colby & aaro & Flum & fox &jamie

You all wanted fish at some point day 2. He was a lead wagon. With lots of discussion about him.

I haven’t seen or heard any reasons this is gone but I think I’m the only one who has voted him today.

Wassup?

The replacement happened before that:

Lfischl has been replaced by President Eden

President Eden has replaced lfischl

Fine. But I started that train of thought before that even.

You posted a reads list with him at scum followed by a naked vote. Didnt push the wagon until after the sub tho. From my perspective, town wants to give that slot more time since new information is now available from the sub. You instead reacted by pushing harder on that slot

[Fluminator]

I wouldn't hate a Fox kill, but would be really be that theatrical with Balki?

[foodcoats]

That game had the best rookie class of any game (no offense colby). Also my phone did die but I’m home and charged it. I’m going to set my desktop up (it’s currently hooked up with my work laptop) and then use it so I can actually make a well formatted post and look at more than 1 thing at once

The amount of posts where aaro explains the minutiae of his daily life is too high.

Literally 0 people joined me voting him. You’re welcome to try again

Alright.


##VOTE aarodactyl

[Dousing]

Bunny stock is dropping for me here.

And before anyone claims this is an OMGUS situation let it be known that I’ve been scumreading bunny since N1

ROFL

Dousing: I’ve been defending you homie

Also Dousing: I’ve been scumming Bunny since N1 when I was defending him

Dousing: I’ve been defending you[r mass tadpole/roleblock claim] homie

Also Dousing: I’ve been scumming [a lot of other actions] Bunny [has taken] since N1

I just double checked: I started scumreading Bunny since they started shading dip on N1

[President Eden]

Bump

So you're telling me your spreadsheet went the way of Hunter Biden's laptop?

My dad isn't obsessed with it, so probably not.

[worcej]

I did a iso read of Bunny and am left thoroughly unimpressed. Their voting record is abysmal, their early reads/scumhunting was weak and I couldn't follow some of their progression. Notably their comments around KoP and Balki had a weird progression that could very well fit with a scum!Bunny. I also dont love the amount of time spent role playing day 1 and talking about mechanics after that time. A high percentage of Bunnys posts are not solving. And those that are "solving" just don't feel like they are really digging beyond the surface.

I also dont like Bunny trying to rally a lfischl/PE wagon right after PE subbed in, seems like potentially scum!Bunny afraid of town!PE being better than town!lfischl. Not sure why town!Bunny would want to rush the lfischl wagon there.

Bunny has stated that they hate the early game because there is less solving to be done, so I can sorta see a scenario where this is just town!Bunny who is lost and waiting for more info to solve, but from what I *have* seen, its been pretty bad.

Im fine keeping Bunny in my PoE with Jamie/Bona (and lfischl/PE pending more PE posts) - just got to decide if I want to try to keep this Bona wagon going or flip to Bunny to make the EoD more interesting

I don’t like my towncore turning on each other…

[sweetandcool]

I wouldn't hate a Fox kill, but would be really be that theatrical with Balki?

Yes, that is like the best case for it. And it's not a bad case.

[Dousing]

Bunny stock is dropping for me here.

And before anyone claims this is an OMGUS situation let it be known that I’ve been scumreading bunny since N1

ROFL

Dousing: I’ve been defending you homie

Also Dousing: I’ve been scumming Bunny since N1 when I was defending him

Dousing: I’ve been defending you[r mass tadpole/roleblock claim] homie

Also Dousing: I’ve been scumming [a lot of other actions] Bunny [has taken] since N1

I just double checked: I started scumreading Bunny since they started shading dip on N1

Well somewhere between scumreading <—> a spot in the scumlean category

[BunnyGo]

This is the post I didnt like where you pushed others to join an lfischl wagon:



The replacement happened before that:

Fine. But I started that train of thought before that even.

You posted a reads list with him at scum followed by a naked vote. Didnt push the wagon until after the sub tho. From my perspective, town wants to give that slot more time since new information is now available from the sub. You instead reacted by pushing harder on that slot

Pushing harder on the people who disappeared from pushing the slot

[Fluminator]

@Fox, why did you scum read Dip the whole day? Did you have any reasons or was it just you decided he was scum?

[President Eden]

I wouldn't hate a Fox kill, but would be really be that theatrical with Balki?

Particularly with daychat, sure.

Maybe I'm being unfair to cases based on things that happened before I subbed in, but I haven't felt any alternatives to be grounded in real data like my suspicion of Fox is.

[Dousing]

Can someone tell me if there's any more to the yoyo case other than him being a sub?

I think you understate what we know about yoyo

As Ezio and I said his votes/scumreads are random or useless:

Thanks. Can someone also give me the case on Will?

*doesn’t make eye contact in the hopes the teacher doesn’t call on me*

[BunnyGo]

The amount of posts where aaro explains the minutiae of his daily life is too high.

Literally 0 people joined me voting him. You’re welcome to try again

Alright.


##VOTE aarodactyl

##vote aar

[Squigs44]

Fine. But I started that train of thought before that even.

You posted a reads list with him at scum followed by a naked vote. Didnt push the wagon until after the sub tho. From my perspective, town wants to give that slot more time since new information is now available from the sub. You instead reacted by pushing harder on that slot

Pushing harder on the people who disappeared from pushing the slot

So you didnt actually want a lfischl wagon, you just wanted to call those not on the wagon scummy? I dont understand the distinction you are trying to make here?

[sweetandcool]

@Fox, why did you scum read Dip the whole day? Did you have any reasons or was it just you decided he was scum?

Good point, we should pay attention to Dip's voters before the duel. No way so many players can't do basic analysis on a slot and instead incorrectly come to the conclusion that obvious town Dip was Mafia.

[worcej]

Can someone tell me if there's any more to the yoyo case other than him being a sub?

Read my wall

[BunnyGo]

You posted a reads list with him at scum followed by a naked vote. Didnt push the wagon until after the sub tho. From my perspective, town wants to give that slot more time since new information is now available from the sub. You instead reacted by pushing harder on that slot

Pushing harder on the people who disappeared from pushing the slot

So you didnt actually want a lfischl wagon, you just wanted to call those not on the wagon scummy? I dont understand the distinction you are trying to make here?

I scum read him as much as anyone. I found the voting patterns VERY suspicious. NOBODY wanted to try again? They’d all moved on? They’d ALL decided to just give Eden a pass? Wanted to see what was up.

[BunnyGo]

Pushing harder on the people who disappeared from pushing the slot

So you didnt actually want a lfischl wagon, you just wanted to call those not on the wagon scummy? I dont understand the distinction you are trying to make here?

I scum read him as much as anyone. I found the voting patterns VERY suspicious. NOBODY wanted to try again? They’d all moved on? They’d ALL decided to just give Eden a pass? Wanted to see what was up.

So id be happy if a wagon took off. But if Eden later flips scum, I think we can look hard at that pool for bussers who disappeared

[Fluminator]

Literally 0 people joined me voting him. You’re welcome to try again

Alright.


##VOTE aarodactyl

##vote aar

I was thrown off by Aaro voting me out of nowhere for suspecting you. Do you think he's buddying you?