M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[BunnyGo]

Squigs is correct that we should presume ghug is town until someone claims he flipped scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote Fluminator because of his ridiculous push on BunnyGo.

[Squigs44]

Town hipfiring ghug there would be pretty wild, but I don't think it's this remote unfortunately lol...

If ghug was mafia aligned and this was a town hipfire, then they would be pretty stupid not to claim before dieing. Leaving town in the dark on that info is just bad. I'm going to operate on the assumption ghug is town unless we get a claim

Sure…eventually. But they don’t need to yet. Unless the archer gets them!

I'd say they definitely don't need to claim yet if ghug was town. If town janitor got a scum ghug result, they should probably claim by end of night 3, earlier if they are under pressure. Delaying more than that is a big risk

[worcej]

Wait… man this setup has been lethal as fuck.

Archer still in play.
BM used (net an additional kill)
Necro now.

[Yoyoyozo]

From the swirling shadows of death
And all stood perplexed
Here one minute
Yet gone the next

Ghug has died

I don't know why, but I'm imaging that mafia tadpoled ghug, he declined, so they shot him. That got a chuckle out of me I guess

1) he claimed he wasnt tadpoled. Had he declined he’d have let us know.

2) the tadpole has not been decided yet if it was given out. Decision by EOD

If ghug got tadpoled, he might have wanted to wait to tell us. If he let us know immediately, then he would have gotten shot because that essentially clears him as town

From mafia perspective, ghug telling us that he wasn't tadpoled is a small sign that he was considering accepting it. Buys more time. Maybe they got impatient.

He also could just not have been tadpoled. I'll do a deep dive on his posts soon

[BunnyGo]

Squigs is correct that we should presume ghug is town until someone claims he flipped scum.

Even though I expect the necromancer was town for the timing and situation.


That said, if necromancer is scum, then I suspect Flum isn’t scum. This would be a weird time for that.

[sweetandcool]

From the swirling shadows of death
And all stood perplexed
Here one minute
Yet gone the next

Ghug has died

Whoa.

Killed and janitored.

That's annoying, I want to know if he was scum.

Ghug was definitely Town. If Town did this, that's another obvious Town flushed away for no reason.

[foodcoats]

Wait… man this setup has been lethal as fuck.

Archer still in play.
BM used (net an additional kill)
Necro now.

I have no idea whether it will end up balanced and I don’t care, this setup is really fun. Gg brain.

[BunnyGo]

##Vote Fluminator because of his ridiculous push on BunnyGo.

Boo

[BunnyGo]

I don't know why, but I'm imaging that mafia tadpoled ghug, he declined, so they shot him. That got a chuckle out of me I guess

1) he claimed he wasnt tadpoled. Had he declined he’d have let us know.

2) the tadpole has not been decided yet if it was given out. Decision by EOD

If ghug got tadpoled, he might have wanted to wait to tell us. If he let us know immediately, then he would have gotten shot because that essentially clears him as town

From mafia perspective, ghug telling us that he wasn't tadpoled is a small sign that he was considering accepting it. Buys more time. Maybe they got impatient.

He also could just not have been tadpoled. I'll do a deep dive on his posts soon

[sweetandcool]

What's the record for most subs?

[worcej]

What's the record for most subs?

Idk but 26 player game is pretty up there

[foodcoats]

What's the record for most subs?

I remember you being obstinate about not explaining reads last time we were both town. But seriously if you REALLY think Flum is scum, why not explain the case?

[sweetandcool]

What's the record for most subs?

Idk but 26 player game is pretty up there

M62 had 26 players and started with two official substitutes lined up.

[sweetandcool]

What's the record for most subs?

I remember you being obstinate about not explaining reads last time we were both town. But seriously if you REALLY think Flum is scum, why not explain the case?

You literally already explained it for me. Would you like me to quote your list in reply?

[sweetandcool]

What's the record for most subs?

I remember you being obstinate about not explaining reads last time we were both town. But seriously if you REALLY think Flum is scum, why not explain the case?

You literally already explained it for me. Would you like me to quote your post in reply?

Fixed a typo

[Jamiet99uk]

##Vote Fluminator because of his ridiculous push on BunnyGo.

Boo

Are you trying to tell me Flum is right?

[sweetandcool]

##VOTE Yoyoyosup

[BunnyGo]

##Vote Fluminator because of his ridiculous push on BunnyGo.

Boo

Are you trying to tell me Flum is right?

No. He’s completely and infuriatingly incorrect.

But not in a scummy way. Scum Flum is better than that.

[BunnyGo]

##VOTE Yoyoyosup

Why?