M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[President Eden]

Hamilton Brian (9): Fluminator Ezio Foxcastle BunnyGo worcej Vecna sweetandcool DiplomacyandWarfare damo666
damo666 (6): Squigs44 Dousing Chaqa foodcoats FlaviusAetius Jamiet99uk
FlaviusAetius (3): JustAGuyNamedWill aarodactyl DemonRHK
DiplomacyandWarfare (2): Hamilton Brian Kakarroto
kingofthepirates (1): kingofthepirates (lol)
Vecna (1): TheMadMonarch
BunnyGo (1): ghug
ghug (1): Bonatogether
JustAGuyNamedWill (1): Col7by
Fluminator (1): lfischl


three deaths? sheesh.


Balki Bartokomous (13): Squigs44 DiplomacyandWarfare sweetandcool Col7by FlaviusAetius ghug aarodactyl Vecna Fluminator Ezio Foxcastle Bonatogether lfischl
DiplomacyandWarfare (6): DemonRHK worcej Jamiet99uk Yoyoyozo foodcoats BunnyGo
ghug (2): Dousing JustAGuyNamedWill
damo666 (1): TheMadMonarch
No-Kill (1): Balki Bartokomous (BoldStrategyCotton.gif)


nice play with Eldritch Knight by D&W.
no kill night 2... suggestive of tadpole use or a save.

yea yea "low effort contribution" my mom said your contribution last night was low effort

Questions:

1) were you saved or offered a tadpole?

2) what do you make of fish showing up with 30 minutes to go knowing what’s going on EOD2?

I won't disclose if I was saved. I wasn't offered a tadpole.

I haven't even read lfischl's posts lol. brain told me his alignment, not my concern.
With no disrespect to him, that behavior sounds entirely normal for him and not alignment indicative.

[Dousing]

I’ll just pile on to agree that Dousing is weird, I need to read his iso but I am starting to think he might be scum.

It was either you or Squiggs that defended Flav for having a different MO to the rest of the thread.

If it was you than this argument is hypocritical. If not uhh… I just have a different MO to y'all

It was me, although I think scum have more to gain by focusing on a self defense, so just claiming "I think different, townread me" isn't what I wanted. It's people thinking about whether that difference is actually scummy or not

Fair point.

I still feel like it’s grossly unjust to say that I’ve made next to no scumreads/townreads this game.

Tbh, I don’t post a lot. At least, when I do, it’s inconsistant. If y’all aren’t a fan of that just institute a post minimum and I will just be cheering yall on from the sidelines instead of participating.

+ I’ve done a lot more analysis than what the other lurkers have done.

Anyone considering a dousing wagon should wonder if it’s better than a different lurker (like a yoyo wagon for instance)

[Vecna]

goddamn eden is in this game.

[BunnyGo]

goddamn eden is in this game.

And somehow he found more time and energy to color code VCA than the rest of us combined.

[Dousing]

Oh my god, I’m finally caught up.

Okay I’m gonna actually start my day (albeit like 90mins late)

50/50 chance I miss EoD

If I miss it - assume I have a life
If I show up - assume I don’t

P.S. the dousing wagon is lame

[Vecna]

anyways i might not be back before eod.

my preference for kills:
Will
Yoyo
Jamiet
Bunny & bona maybe
Ghug id rather sort later. flum gains more info by flipping yoyo maybe.

lets give foodcoats a bit more time imo. same for RHK i guess. Same for eden since itll be nice to have him in this regardless of alignment.

way too many options. i think killing anything below the bunny & bona line is probably a bad idea today

[BunnyGo]

anyways i might not be back before eod.

my preference for kills:
Will
Yoyo
Jamiet
Bunny & bona maybe
Ghug id rather sort later. flum gains more info by flipping yoyo maybe.

lets give foodcoats a bit more time imo. same for RHK i guess. Same for eden since itll be nice to have him in this regardless of alignment.

way too many options. i think killing anything below the bunny & bona line is probably a bad idea today

I think I disagree with everything you said. Every single take. Maybe yoyo I don’t disagree. Food and demon don’t need more time, they seem towny.

[worcej]

I'm skeptical that everyone will participate, but...

Nothing happened to me last night.

20 pages behind but also will confirm nothing happened to me last night.

[Yoyoyozo]

anyways i might not be back before eod.

my preference for kills:
Will
Yoyo
Jamiet
Bunny & bona maybe
Ghug id rather sort later. flum gains more info by flipping yoyo maybe.

lets give foodcoats a bit more time imo. same for RHK i guess. Same for eden since itll be nice to have him in this regardless of alignment.

way too many options. i think killing anything below the bunny & bona line is probably a bad idea today

[BunnyGo]

anyways i might not be back before eod.

my preference for kills:
Will
Yoyo
Jamiet
Bunny & bona maybe
Ghug id rather sort later. flum gains more info by flipping yoyo maybe.

lets give foodcoats a bit more time imo. same for RHK i guess. Same for eden since itll be nice to have him in this regardless of alignment.

way too many options. i think killing anything below the bunny & bona line is probably a bad idea today

Wah wah

[foodcoats]

It was either you or Squiggs that defended Flav for having a different MO to the rest of the thread.

If it was you than this argument is hypocritical. If not uhh… I just have a different MO to y'all

It was me, although I think scum have more to gain by focusing on a self defense, so just claiming "I think different, townread me" isn't what I wanted. It's people thinking about whether that difference is actually scummy or not

Fair point.

I still feel like it’s grossly unjust to say that I’ve made next to no scumreads/townreads this game.

Tbh, I don’t post a lot. At least, when I do, it’s inconsistant. If y’all aren’t a fan of that just institute a post minimum and I will just be cheering yall on from the sidelines instead of participating.

+ I’ve done a lot more analysis than what the other lurkers have done.

Anyone considering a dousing wagon should wonder if it’s better than a different lurker (like a yoyo wagon for instance)

Well when I read your iso you ask a lot of questions but you never say “I think so and so is scum because…”

You gave your reads as requested but provided no reasons why.

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

You’re off.

You're mom.

forced

Your mom

[Yoyoyozo]

anyways i might not be back before eod.

my preference for kills:
Will
Yoyo
Jamiet
Bunny & bona maybe
Ghug id rather sort later. flum gains more info by flipping yoyo maybe.

lets give foodcoats a bit more time imo. same for RHK i guess. Same for eden since itll be nice to have him in this regardless of alignment.

way too many options. i think killing anything below the bunny & bona line is probably a bad idea today

Wah wah

I'm way funnier when things actually work as intended

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

Oh you know what

I bet Will is scum

Like where is Will? Will why are you so chill this game?

This is the EXACT reason Im voting for Will right now, why arent you?

Thats the reason? Lmao

[foodcoats]

SWEET

HEY

HEEEEEEY

EXPLAIN YOUR FLUM VOTE

[JustAGuyNamedWill]

My theory is ghug is probably mafia that was saved by his team using the 2 wagons power up

I have an inkling that the mafia team is shitting the bed and ghug was someone they wanted to keep alive

you are so crazy for thinking this you do realize that wasting TWO pr's to save ONE person at the expense of another??
and we KNOW Dip used the duelist so this is just factually not true

I thought the battle master caused both top 2 wagons to be killed anyways

[BunnyGo]

SWEET

HEY

HEEEEEEY

EXPLAIN YOUR FLUM VOTE

I think the Flum wagon is sweet + at least one scum.

[brainbomb]

From the swirling shadows of death
And all stood perplexed
Here one minute
Yet gone the next

Ghug has died

[foodcoats]

From the swirling shadows of death
And all stood perplexed
Here one minute
Yet gone the next

Ghug has died

Do we not get an alignment here?

[Dousing]