M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Col7by]

Have you seen the vote count?

The names of the current remaining players?

Vote history?

It looks like the one we use at work but better

I’ve seen all that but not vote history. Have seen the post count stuff too which I liked

Have you tried using it to keep track of peoples names?

That would probably be a good idea. I have mostly been playing on my phone and have only accessed the tracker on laptop so I’ve only looked a handful of times/can’t during most of the day

[FlaviusAetius]

Bona could be scum. The last game I played with bona he was town and was an absolute dog with a bone. Here… not so.

This doesn't look like a strong opinion, its just the 5th person saying "Bona could be scum I guess" and moving on

@squigs: were you given a tadpole or attacked last night?

Why are you asking people this can I get a clear answer

[sweetandcool]

Hi Squigs I see you there.

I think you might be right about the Battle Master being Mafia.

Why am I one of your two top scumreads, please?

If you think battlemaster was mafia then how come you think sweet is mafia? This doesnt make sense

Oh, you are right, it doesn't.

I will rethink Sweet then.

I'm lost. What does Battlemaster have to do with me?

[Squigs44]

Bona could be scum. The last game I played with bona he was town and was an absolute dog with a bone. Here… not so.

This doesn't look like a strong opinion, its just the 5th person saying "Bona could be scum I guess" and moving on

@squigs: were you given a tadpole or attacked last night?

If you're gonna hound people about claiming and use all your time on mechanics instead of scumhunting, maybe follow the thread and read when people post it?

I was not tadpoled last night, nor roleblocked

For the record I think there are some night action results where keeping silent could be beneficial to town as to not give scum information they don't yet have. They should have tadpole and roleblock information so I see no harm in a tadpole mass claim though. For all other night action results we should leave it up to the town members to decide if they think it is more beneficial to claim now or later.

[sweetandcool]

Reviewing D1, the main wagons have all died except Flavius, fisch (Town), and Flum.

Yes, perhaps ##VOTE Flum

[FlaviusAetius]

Night Ends in about 3.5 hours. If you have instructions/requests/PRorders/ or the like... be sure to DM/Discord both brain and me. Brain is busybusybusy today and I am steering the shi..p/...e..e........*****$###SSSSZXXX

Do we have to DM you and message on Discord?

I wouldn't want my orders to be missed.

I thought you were a VT?

BRUH JAMIE

[FlaviusAetius]

If you think battlemaster was mafia then how come you think sweet is mafia? This doesnt make sense

Oh, you are right, it doesn't.

I will rethink Sweet then.

I'm lost. What does Battlemaster have to do with me?

My theory is that if a mafia is a battlemaster then they would want two townie at the top, so doing it so late in the late is a BIG X TO DOUBT

[FlaviusAetius]

jamie also thinks battlemaster is probs mafia

[Foxcastle]

I would hope that a town would realize there are better cases for the battle master. If it is town, I don't suspect we can know the reasoning.

I think it makes a lot of sense to use it as scum though, including early on (when we're already down 2 extra miskills). But they wouldn't activate it if there was a chance that it would possibly kill scum, though. That would mean activating it at a time when there were virtually no votes on scum wagons. I think you'd also want to activate it close to the 30-minute deadline, as well. Balki briefly had votes about 2 hours out, but those evaporated quickly. He started getting votes again at 00:37. At that time, wagons were Dip (6), lfischl (4), ghug (3), Jamie (2), Dousing (2), Flav (2), Sweet (1), Ezio (1). (I may be missing some after the first 4 that I cribbed from the bot.)

I think this points to at least lfischl and ghug being town, and likely the rest of them.

[sweetandcool]

Oh, you are right, it doesn't.

I will rethink Sweet then.

I'm lost. What does Battlemaster have to do with me?

My theory is that if a mafia is a battlemaster then they would want two townie at the top, so doing it so late in the late is a BIG X TO DOUBT

But what does that have to do with my alignment?

[foodcoats]

I checked the Setup.

There is a PR called a Druid which can perform up to two Doc saves.

Very interesting that some people immediately assumed this did not happen.

Weird flex, but okay.

I immediately thought tadpole after no kill was shown

I didn’t, I thought, “Oh yeah this setup is full of weird stuff.”

[foodcoats]

I will ##vote foodcoats here. I would love for the wagons today to be between foodcoats, bona, and yoyo.

What is your scum case on me, bona, and yoyo?

[sweetandcool]

I would hope that a town would realize there are better cases for the battle master. If it is town, I don't suspect we can know the reasoning.

I think it makes a lot of sense to use it as scum though, including early on (when we're already down 2 extra miskills). But they wouldn't activate it if there was a chance that it would possibly kill scum, though. That would mean activating it at a time when there were virtually no votes on scum wagons. I think you'd also want to activate it close to the 30-minute deadline, as well. Balki briefly had votes about 2 hours out, but those evaporated quickly. He started getting votes again at 00:37. At that time, wagons were Dip (6), lfischl (4), ghug (3), Jamie (2), Dousing (2), Flav (2), Sweet (1), Ezio (1). (I may be missing some after the first 4 that I cribbed from the bot.)

I think this points to at least lfischl and ghug being town, and likely the rest of them.

That's what I said! Though the ghug wagon was going nowhere and I think Mafia could have defended it, so I don't think this specifically shows ghug is Town.

[Foxcastle]

I would hope that a town would realize there are better cases for the battle master. If it is town, I don't suspect we can know the reasoning.

I think it makes a lot of sense to use it as scum though, including early on (when we're already down 2 extra miskills). But they wouldn't activate it if there was a chance that it would possibly kill scum, though. That would mean activating it at a time when there were virtually no votes on scum wagons. I think you'd also want to activate it close to the 30-minute deadline, as well. Balki briefly had votes about 2 hours out, but those evaporated quickly. He started getting votes again at 00:37. At that time, wagons were Dip (6), lfischl (4), ghug (3), Jamie (2), Dousing (2), Flav (2), Sweet (1), Ezio (1). (I may be missing some after the first 4 that I cribbed from the bot.)

I think this points to at least lfischl and ghug being town, and likely the rest of them.

That's what I said! Though the ghug wagon was going nowhere and I think Mafia could have defended it, so I don't think this specifically shows ghug is Town.

Sorry if I missed your post on this, as I said I have been doing a lot of catchup quickly.

[BunnyGo]

This doesn't look like a strong opinion, its just the 5th person saying "Bona could be scum I guess" and moving on

@squigs: were you given a tadpole or attacked last night?

Why are you asking people this can I get a clear answer

I think scum know.

It’s to our advantage to know too.

And if there is someone with a tadpole, they should claim it and claim they destroy it. Scum know.

[foodcoats]

I think the food votes are btw

Poison food takes 50 Health!

[foodcoats]

I think the food votes are btw

Scum Foodcoats tends to give you food poisoning.

Why do you think I’m scum, sweet?

[Fluminator]

Reviewing D1, the main wagons have all died except Flavius, fisch (Town), and Flum.

Yes, perhaps ##VOTE Flum

Terrible reason to vote someone.
But I'm mainly curious why you think fisch is town? I'm open on being convinced on him.

[foodcoats]

I tend to agree the vig is town, but a scum vig could explain the likely tadpole if the vig shots are being used to overcome the lost kill to give them a strong swing in win potential

If Mafia shot I see no reason they wouldn't target someone like Squig, unless they intended to Tadpole them or they already are Mafia.

Damo makes no sense.

Hiding the shot to make people think it’s town is about the only thing I could think of. But there is too much cheekiness assumed for it to be scum where it just is more simple to conclude it’s a town shot.

Does it… matter?

[FlaviusAetius]

I was waiting towards the end of night phase so here it is now. Dip had said their two scum reads were balki and bunny. I had tried to follow up on that multiple times while dip was alive and right when we hit night phase. Once bunny got back on he started to try and paint me as sus in three different posts I think to paint a target to get me out before I speak more. I wait until now to say this so I didn’t want people to think it appeared as a retaliation to bunny accusing me. You will find this is the only times my name been brought up or I posted since night 2 has started other than once other town support from ghug I believe and being listed as a town read by one other person.

Bonus and bunny are my top two scum reads right now

and its a wonder why Bunny is hounding people now about whether anything happened this night; my belief; he wants something thats NAI on his record but so he can keep talking, Bunny why are YOU doing this, why not let anyone else do this or tagteam it etc? Why are YOU voting people? Why are you doing it with such URGENCY? Im so confused