M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[Fluminator]

A DUEL HAS BEEN INITIATED

Diplomacy and Warfare vs Balki Bartokomous

Wait, this was 31 minutes before eod. So mafia would have needed a 1 minute reaction to trigger battlemaster in this case if it was in response to the duel.

So maybe the whole battlemaster thing was decided before the duel?

[Ezio]

anyways, now that we know kak wasnt killed for his primary read, we can dig into his lesser reads that he was vocal about before that eon post.

I have a feeling well find potentially 2 more scum there

Can I ##VOTE Vecna at night?

Yeah seriously.

Ezio too.

Lol what.

[lfischl]

RIP D&W, would have been awesome had you lived

Now that balki's flipped scum, how many of the 4 remaining scum do we think were on the Damo/HB wagons D1, could it have been all 4?

[FlaviusAetius]

If it has to be used 30 minutes before, scum knew both were dying either way. (assuming scum used the power but it makes no sense for a town to use it there)

Dip was town didnt we already go over this

[foodcoats]

Can I ##VOTE Vecna at night?

Yeah seriously.

Ezio too.

Lol what.

Say things of substance or face my continued confirmation bias.

[Fluminator]

Ehh maybe it's not as clearcut as we thought. I think there's a reasonable chance that mafia knew both were dead anyway because of battlemaster. So any people voting Balki over Dip don't get as much credit as they might otherwise get.
(Even though I was the one who really got the swing on Balki going after his nokill vote)

It's not impossible it was a town PR move knowing it likely happened before the duel.

I think the main moral is the Dip wagon to begin with was just terrible and those are the most suspicious people.

[Fluminator]

If it has to be used 30 minutes before, scum knew both were dying either way. (assuming scum used the power but it makes no sense for a town to use it there)

Dip was town didnt we already go over this

I'm talking about the Battlemaster power where the top 2 vote getters die

[Squigs44]

Battle master could have been town as well

[foodcoats]

RIP D&W, would have been awesome had you lived

Now that balki's flipped scum, how many of the 4 remaining scum do we think were on the Damo/HB wagons D1, could it have been all 4?

Since it was largely tvt (ham v dam) for hours before EOD I think two or even three MAY have been off wagon. Depends what we think of Flav, too.

[Fluminator]

Battle master could have been town as well

Yeah, it actually makes sense as town to use it early in day 1/2. Just unfortunate the duel happened that round too. I wasn't aware it had to be used 30 minutes before deadline.

[Fluminator]

Ok, back to work. I think the game is finally getting good though. So again, good work Dip. Enjoy your retirement, you did your duty.

[Squigs44]

In fact, why wouldn't scum battle master have used it day 1 with TvT?

[Vecna]

In fact, why wouldn't scum battle master have used it day 1 with TvT?

because this way they get to watch vigs shoot at damos and town wagon obvtowns like flavius and d&w

[Fluminator]

In fact, why wouldn't scum battle master have used it day 1 with TvT?

To be clear, the damo vig was still bad so I don't endorse his death, but it is useful for town to know if the day 1 wagons were TvT. Mafia wouldn't use it in that situation.

If a scum had it, they'd use it for the final miskill or use it when he's looking like he'll get killed I think. (Or if they had quick reflexes in a situation exactly like this)

[Foxcastle]

A DUEL HAS BEEN INITIATED

Diplomacy and Warfare vs Balki Bartokomous

Wait, this was 31 minutes before eod. So mafia would have needed a 1 minute reaction to trigger battlemaster in this case if it was in response to the duel.

So maybe the whole battlemaster thing was decided before the duel?

This would make sense if there was another scum wagon that they thought was likely. But that seems iffy...

[Fluminator]

scratch that, even with quick reflexes it doesn't make sense mafia to use it. And Balki was genuinely trying to survive still.
It was a town PR.

[Fluminator]

A DUEL HAS BEEN INITIATED

Diplomacy and Warfare vs Balki Bartokomous

Wait, this was 31 minutes before eod. So mafia would have needed a 1 minute reaction to trigger battlemaster in this case if it was in response to the duel.

So maybe the whole battlemaster thing was decided before the duel?

This would make sense if there was another scum wagon that they thought was likely. But that seems iffy...

Yeah sorry bud, I don't think mafia knew Dip was dying, so your townslip is no longer a townslip lol.

I still think you're more likely town based on interactions with Balki. Maybe. I'll have to re-read.

[Fluminator]

One last post. Awfully convenient Demon that you don't follow your #swingthesubs strategy the round a sub is up for swing. HUH

[Squigs44]

Bona bona bona... we gonna iso Bona tonight. Don't let me forget. But I'm busy for the next few hours

[DemonRHK]

The pirate iso took 10 seconds and was beyond useless. Ugh.

I would bet the battle master was a mafia power popped early in the day going for a double up on damo and dip. I would say this theory would make fish and/or ezio look better.

Flum or yoyo maybe? Yoyo is in the SwingTheSub pool anyway.