M89: Baldurs Gate Mafia Game Thread

[sweetandcool]

Why did you shoot damo. It was pretty clear the two eod wagons were town. This is what happens when you don't listen to me.

We could also kill Fluminator.

Nah, I think he is town. At least, I think he is authentic Flum, which is more likely Town.

[Squigs44]

Dayum.

RIP Damo.

##VOTE Jamma Sam

Ghug and I finally agree on something?

[ghug]

I don’t think Balki is bullying Fox persay but it reads to me that he wants to get rid of Fox because he’s had GREAT reads on people. It’s one of his quirks. Balki is great at convincing people (I’m not sure if this is confidential information but he is a lawyer)

The way I’ve read Fox this game is that he’s good at seeing the big picture, which spells trouble for someone trying to deceptively drive bandwagons. Of course, that entire argument could be contrived and they’re both mafia, and if they’re both mafia, Balki could be saccing Fox for town points. Those are the vibes I getting so far.

X to doubt, Foxcastle made it pretty clear Balki will suspect Foxcastle no matter what for doing analysis without actual analysis, whether it was true or not(I dont think its true this game I felt Foxcastle has been helpful), soo if Fox ends up being mafia then Balki is just being Balki targetting Fox, if Fox turns up townie, then Balki is just being Balki targetting Fox, it means nothing for him and wont give him any points

I just want to be very repetitive and clear. I do not suspect Fox in this game for “doing analysis without actual analysis.” Perhaps I read him that way for those reasons in games from many years ago, but that is not the source of my suspicion here.

I suspect Fox in this game for low-risk, poorly thought-out votes and what appeared to be a purposeful attempt to exist in the blind spots of the game.

Just because I correctly scumread Fox in some but not all games years ago does not mean I should be ignored here, and I don’t like that Fox’s response was to try to discredit me in this way without engaging with my argument in this game.

I also don’t like your attempt to make this all conventional wisdom. I feel like the motivation of your post is to discredit me, and I think that’s a motivation that is more consistent with scum than town.

##vote Flavius

The stubbornness is a good look here for Balki, but I hate the vote.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Does anyone have feelings about Bonatogether's alignment? I would like to read about such feelings.

[FlaviusAetius]

It could be some sort of deficiency, but Flavius has been rabidly focused on unimportant things this game, just grinding down on them for no reason.

First the tadpole discussion, which could have lasted a couple posts, and now this weird quibbling about scumchat.

I just talk about a lot of stuff, for everytime I talked about why we shouldnt be asking people if they would or wouldnt take the tadpole I also talked about Flum and other cases I was pushing...with you!

Its not a weird quibbling people keep bringing it up as evidence that someone is mafia, and thats just so weird because theres no way that mistake was made

[BunnyGo]

I’m still only on page 116 and unlikely to catch-up before EOD.

Can anyone summarize Kay new things? Maybe the ghug wagon?

##vote diplo

[Balki Bartokomous]

X to doubt, Foxcastle made it pretty clear Balki will suspect Foxcastle no matter what for doing analysis without actual analysis, whether it was true or not(I dont think its true this game I felt Foxcastle has been helpful), soo if Fox ends up being mafia then Balki is just being Balki targetting Fox, if Fox turns up townie, then Balki is just being Balki targetting Fox, it means nothing for him and wont give him any points

I just want to be very repetitive and clear. I do not suspect Fox in this game for “doing analysis without actual analysis.” Perhaps I read him that way for those reasons in games from many years ago, but that is not the source of my suspicion here.

I suspect Fox in this game for low-risk, poorly thought-out votes and what appeared to be a purposeful attempt to exist in the blind spots of the game.

Just because I correctly scumread Fox in some but not all games years ago does not mean I should be ignored here, and I don’t like that Fox’s response was to try to discredit me in this way without engaging with my argument in this game.

I also don’t like your attempt to make this all conventional wisdom. I feel like the motivation of your post is to discredit me, and I think that’s a motivation that is more consistent with scum than town.

##vote Flavius

The stubbornness is a good look here for Balki, but I hate the vote.

You hate it because you think Flavor Flav is Town? Don't you think he's mayyyyybe scum?

[ghug]

Flavius literally got offended by my townread of him. That is not scum behavior.

I'm willing to give pass to people who pushed damo only on day 1, but the people pushing him today are on thin ice.

I have NO recollection of this; what on earth are you talking about? Why would I be OFFENDED that you are thinking Im a townie? This doesnt make any sense and I dont know why you keep making it, show me where it happened or I dont believe you

Seriously why is anyone voting for this guy?

[Balki Bartokomous]

I’m still only on page 116 and unlikely to catch-up before EOD.

Can anyone summarize Kay new things? Maybe the ghug wagon?

##vote diplo

We are all having a very robust discussion about our feelings on Bonatogether's alignment. Woud you please share your thoughts on that?

[FlaviusAetius]

Alr I'm caught up and have a few things to say.
Thing 1:
I have a new reads list
7x7_blank - with names - Copy - Copy.jpg
I keep going back and forth on damo's alignment though. I feel like I'm missing something.

Why do you keep moving around? Can you explain some of your allignments here? Why is no one in the "evil" category?

1. I keep moving people around because my reads change.
2. Which ones?
3. That's actually a good point. You are now Social Evil.

I meant why do you keep moving ME around. I dont know any alignment someone said earlier naked lists are useless and its true.
Why am I a social evil...

[sweetandcool]

I’m still only on page 116 and unlikely to catch-up before EOD.

Can anyone summarize Kay new things? Maybe the ghug wagon?

##vote diplo

There is no way bunny biffs it so badly.

##VOTE Bunny

[Balki Bartokomous]

Flavius literally got offended by my townread of him. That is not scum behavior.

I'm willing to give pass to people who pushed damo only on day 1, but the people pushing him today are on thin ice.

I have NO recollection of this; what on earth are you talking about? Why would I be OFFENDED that you are thinking Im a townie? This doesnt make any sense and I dont know why you keep making it, show me where it happened or I dont believe you

Seriously why is anyone voting for this guy?

Overwrought, overwrought, overwrought

[ghug]

Oh good, twenty pages to read.

Ghug, I need you for a sanity check. Please guide us with your wisdom. Our other beacon of light, Vecna has been fairly absent this phase.

Sweet I like you plenty but I don't need your head this far up my ass.

[Balki Bartokomous]

Oh good, twenty pages to read.

Ghug, I need you for a sanity check. Please guide us with your wisdom. Our other beacon of light, Vecna has been fairly absent this phase.

Sweet I like you plenty but I don't need your head this far up my ass.

If Sweet's head is up your ass, then what is that up Vecna's?

[FlaviusAetius]

I’m going to ##vote ghug.

No, I’m not.

##unvote

@ghug, please solve the game.

##vote Sweet?

And what's the point of voting ghug, unvoting here, and question mark voting sweet?

Seems like you want to make sure we see that you are confused... why?

TRUE! Balki you said you would solve the game, it made me think you were actually paying attention to the game before you came in, and now...it seems you are just rolling around and not actually solving the game but shifting from person to person and bringing everyone else along with you

[sweetandcool]

Oh good, twenty pages to read.

Ghug, I need you for a sanity check. Please guide us with your wisdom. Our other beacon of light, Vecna has been fairly absent this phase.

Sweet I like you plenty but I don't need your head this far up my ass.

Last game I was too hurtful and this time I'm too nice. Choose a lane!

[Balki Bartokomous]

This is a list of players currently alive. I feel like it's worth a refresher. Our focus remains very narrow.

1. Yoyo
2. Balki
3. JustAGuyNamedWill
4. Jamiet99uk
5. Bonatogether
8. Dousing
9. foodcoats
10. BunnyGo
11. ghug
12. Ezio
13. FlaviusAetius
14. DiplomacyandWarfare
16. Worcej
17. lfischl
18. Vecna
19. foxcastle
20. TheMadMonarch
21. DemonRHK
22. Col7by
23. Squiggs44
24. sweetandcool
25. fluminator
26. aarodactyl

[aarodactyl]

I like the fish voters, but am mid on the wagon.
I like the Flav wagon, but the viters on it SUUUUUUCK

Other than those two and me, who would you like to wagon?

Balki on straight policy. But you’re willing makes me hesitate.
Flum because I think it sheds a lot of light on early game links.
Yoyo is a low end policy.
Ghug is approaching worrying levels of disinterest.

My read on ghug is just that this EOD is rough for his time zone. At least personally, it’s been brutal for EOD to be so early in the afternoon. It makes it very hard (at least for me personally) to follow the conversation.

[BunnyGo]

I’m still only on page 116 and unlikely to catch-up before EOD.

Can anyone summarize Kay new things? Maybe the ghug wagon?

##vote diplo

We are all having a very robust discussion about our feelings on Bonatogether's alignment. Woud you please share your thoughts on that?

He’s done his “minimal post, minimal words, but at key spots” thing. This is NAI.

Sone things that stood out to me (because they involved me): he tried hard to get me to lay off ghug.

He tried to get people to layoff me while simultaneously giving me fun (by poking it at me).


These are more Town of him, but within his capabilities as scum.

[Jamiet99uk]

I will be hosting a pub quiz tonight and may not be on at EOD.

I see the Lfrishl wagon has crumbled.

##Vote Diplomacyand for reasons previously articulated.